Strategy Changes v St Kilda

[Gysberts2Bate]

IN: Trac
Out: Lewis

Either T Smith or Pedersen in if Hogan misses. If anyone other than Lewis or Vince is dropped for Trac I'll spew.

 

[Topkent]

ANB out for Trac. Even if his work rate is good his form isn't. Never ever been anything wrong with players going back to find confidence.

Pedo for Hogan if not fit.

 

[Dancing Potato]

Any of Lewis, Vince or ANB for Petracca. There's arguments for and against all of them.

Pedo if Hogan isn't right.

No further changes are warranted.

 

[dylan93]

In: Trac, Baker/Pedo
Out: ANB, Weid

 

[Crusty Demon]

In: Trac, Baker/Pedo
Out: ANB, Weid

I think we just have to keep playing Weid now. I think Pedo's papers have been stamped unfortunately. He'll only be used if one of Hogan, Weid or TMac get injured.

Weid showed some good signs in that last quarter I thought. Clunked a couple of nice marks. I think we have to persist with him now. Pedo might be a better player right here and now, however we can't wait too much longer to pump games into Weid.

I think we'll only see one change barring injuries. Trac in and ANB out. Harmes did enough this game to keep his spot where ANB didn't. I don't think Goodwin would want to make too many changes to a winning side. Hopefully we turned a corner in that second half. We beat the Saints and we'll be back on track..

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Weid has taken as many contested marks this season as Pedo has in his last 7 games

 

[BG32]

Maybe Harmes should keep his spot. He became the dad of the saints last time we played, shat all over them in the space of 10 minutes

 

[demondavey]

Out - Lewis, Hogan
In - Petracca, Smith

 

[Topkent]

Weid has taken as many contested marks this season as Pedo has in his last 7 games

We may as well have played with 21 in the first 3 quarters. Started to do something in the last but let's not pretend he was good.

 

[rhaz]

One change I'd like to see for the Saints is Gawn's goalkicking routine. Not good at the moment.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

We may as well have played with 21 in the first 3 quarters. Started to do something in the last but let's not pretend he was good.

I’m not saying he is, huge regression on last week. But I’m sick of this Pedo worship. Reeks of the same being done for Frost earlier this year before he came in and stunk it up.

 

[demondavey]

We may as well have played with 21 in the first 3 quarters. Started to do something in the last but let's not pretend he was good.

We’ve got to keep playing him

 

[demondavey]

I’m not saying he is, huge regression on last week. But I’m sick of this Pedo worship. Reeks of the same being done for Frost earlier this year before he came in and stunk it up.

I was a big Frost advocate but see the benefits of him not being in the side.

 

[Topkent]

We’ve got to keep playing him

I didn't say not too. I'd give him another 2 and with Hogan potentially injured he might need to step up as well.

 

[deeco]

OUT: Boiled lollies.
IN: Chocolate.

 

[ponsdale]

Only ANB out for Trac, I think. I’d be happy with that.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[Jay May]

OUT: Boiled lollies.
IN: Chocolate.

I prefer boiled lollies. But only change I'd make is anb for trac. Not sold on weids but he clunked a few late and pedo didn't kill it last night.
If hogan misses, I'd bring jeffy back

 

[Blackas87]

Out: Neal-Bullen
In: Petracca

 

[Daemon]

Petracca in for Lewis/Vince. Viney in for the other one (wishful thinking)

 

[Sylvia Saint]

Some of you are biased. Vince and Lewis might be older than the pyramids but they contributed more today (and previously) than Alex Neal-Fumble.

In. Petracca
Out. ANB

 

[PerfectFooty]

ANB i called to be dropped last week. Makes bad decisions under pressure, and fumbles so much which puts him under pressure anyway. But at least you all cottoned on!

Out: Nib
In: Trac

 

[schmuttt]

Don't rate Harmes at all but he did enough to hold his spot. ANB has to go, zero impact for a few weeks now.

Out: ANB
In: Petracca

 

[mrmonkey]

One change I'd like to see for the Saints is Gawn's goalkicking routine. Not good at the moment.

Yes after the Hawthorn game after missing the near identical shot against Geelong it was highlighted what he was doing wrong. Which was him moving to the right causing him to hook left. Two weeks later It's the same problem so obviously nothing is getting done about it because it's such an easy fix.

 

[Tempy Tiger]

Can’t believe no-one has mentioned Tyson as an out. He was the worst on ground by a long way.
Out: Tyson, Hoges/Weid
In: Trac, Pedo

Lewis was terrible too but he won’t be dropped as we all know.

 

[Scythe]

Petracca was still in hospital yesterday, wouldn’t say he’s a guaranteed starter for this week.