Changes v Sydney

[Holden Hillbilly]

Out: Butcher
Neade

In: Lobbe
Young

 

[Alyx]

Out: Butcher
Neade

In: Lobbe
Young

/thread.

Maybe White, too.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Hard to argue with that.

Feel a statement should be made on White for his poor effort but I'll give him a chance.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Out: Neade, White
In: Krak (sub), Young

Lobbe in for Butcher if available. We won't truly get to see what Paddy is capable and how much of a weapon he's going to be for us until he's lining up on the second KPD/second ruck every week.

 

[Dylan8]

Young to vest, Monfries starts. Neade out.

Who comes out for Lobbster? It'll have to be Butcher unfortunately.

 

[Scott03]

Out: not having the smallest player in the afl as your main target

But yeah,

Out neade, butch

In lobbe young

 

[Vdubs]

What happened to Cam O'Shea?
Really rated his desperation in finals last year.

 

[PepeSilvia]

Young to vest, Monfries starts. Neade out.

Who comes out for Lobbster? It'll have to be Butcher unfortunately.

Exactly this.

If Lobbe gets up, I think Butch goes (unfortunately).

 

[BornPort]

What happened to Cam O'Shea?
Really rated his desperation in finals last year.

He is doing his usual 'Start the year shit and come good for finals'

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Young needs to start I reckon. Contested ball has been a big problem since preseason, and I feel it's because we don't have the right numbers of mids/talls.

 

[port09]

Out:Butcher,Pittard,Neade
In:Krak,Lobbe,young

 

[Shane_Mag]

Out: Butcher
Neade

In: Lobbe
Young

Agree with this. Butcher was really disappointing. Started well but was virtually a witches hat for 3 quarters.

 

[Abraham Nuscrack]

Out - Butch (If Lobbe fit), Impey (no match up), Neade

In - Lobbe (if fit), O'Shea, Young (sub)

 

[DazzaTys]

Out: lack of effort to get the ball forward in the last 3 mins with Impey kicking the ball sideways to Pittard.

But seriously, Neade out, Young in.

 

[Nemisis]

Lobbe in = Butch out

 

[edgie]

Before I make a call and get lambasted, am I the only one who thought Westhoff was more unsighted than Butch?

 

[Kickpuncher]

Butcher was average tonight so he goes out for Lobbe

Neade out for Young

Also I'd rather have Krak in the side over Pittard but I'll probably get roasted for that call.

 

[spookism]

Before I make a call and get lambasted, am I the only one who thought Westhoff was more unsighted than Butch?

If you don't count the first quarter, than yes.

Doesn't make your point any less valid however, unfortunately.

 

[philthy05]

Agree with this. Butcher was really disappointing. Started well but was virtually a witches hat for 3 quarters.

Re-watch. Every time the ball went his way he made a contest of it. We had some terrible terrible forward entries that meant even a prime tredrea would have been a ball watcher. Kicking it high to Neade while butch has a one on one 30 metres out is where it went wrong

 

[PJ Power]

Out: Butcher
Neade

In: Lobbe
Young

Agree, but White very lucky and must play sub. Krakouer for White isn't far away now

 

[Schulzenfest]

Before I make a call and get lambasted, am I the only one who thought Westhoff was more unsighted than Butch?

Unsighted is the wrong word, but he was ****ing sleepwalking through that last quarter, and his laziness played a part in a couple of Freo goals. Really disappointing effort. Lucky he has runs on the board.

 

[Dylan8]

Before I make a call and get lambasted, am I the only one who thought Westhoff was more unsighted than Butch?

Westhoff has far more in the bank and far more versatility so he's safe.

 

[CharlieKelly]

IN: Lobbe, Young

OUT: Butcher, Neade

Monfries start, Young the sub

 

[philthy05]

Agree though that if lobbe is fit then butch would have to be the out just for the sake of keeping our run and not being top heavy. Westhoff lucky to stay in based on what he can do

 

[tim cotrill]

He is doing his usual 'Start the year shit and come good for finals'

too many beers in the offseason then shreds up for the finals.