Changes v WCE

[statman87]

Another good 2 quarters put together by Port Adelaide only to be blown away in the last once again can this season get any worse? All the players hard work to get within 17 points early in the last all blown out the window with another piss poor display to lose again by over 70 points.

IN
Salopek
Carlile
Young
Pittard
Surjan


Out
McCarthy (Needs to find form in the SANFL)
Moore (Needs a rest by the look of it)
Pfeiffer (thought he'd do more to retain his spot, 7 touches doesnt do that)
Chaplin (injury)
Hartlett (Suspension)

EMG Wingard Jonas Banner

 

[Portia]

IN: Litt
Out: Hardman

 

[Shane_Mag]

Out: Logan, Trengove, McCarthy, Rodin

In: whoever is available

 

[Schulzenfest]

Oh look, a statman thread where Logan and Rodan remain in the side despite stinking it up as usual. What a shocker.

In: Surjan (or Jonas if Surjan is unfit)
Out: LOGAN. Logan absolutely must go. He's the worst player in the AFL and we're a significantly worse side when we play him. Stats back me up on that. IMO we'll instantly be a 5 goal better side if we replace him with a competent small defender like Surjan or Jonas.

In: Carlile
Out: Chaplin/Trengove. Don't care which, both as bad as each other. Probably get rid of Chappy because he's going to Richmond. Don't let the door hit you on the way out.

In: Wingard
Out: Rodan. Never should've been brought back. Is the same flashy, unfit, unaccountable player he was when he was dropped.

In: Young
Out: McCarthy. Hasn't played a good game in two months. Young was good in the SANFL and deserves his spot back.

If Moore needs a rest (and his form indicates that he does), give Salopek one last chance to salvage his career. Plenty of far less talented players than Salopek have been given far more chances than Salopek.

 

[finbarr]

If Logan isn't delisted at years end we're just not serious.

 

[Macca19]

I think if Surj and Pittard had been fit for the last 2 months then Logan probably wouldnt have got much of a look in.

 

[Schulzenfest]

No excuses for the coaching staff on this one. I don't care if the whole team is injured. Logan shouldn't be getting a look in ahead of inanimate carbon rod.

 

[Andre]

If Logan isn't delisted at years end we're just not serious.

"But he's tough."
Yeah, he should go, but the club the last few years is like a dog who keeps shitting on my lawn every couple of weeks. They'll have to prove they aren't an incontinent poodle before I trust them again. If he's on the list next year though I'll be saying.

Shirley you aren't serious.

 

[Andre]

No excuses for the coaching staff on this one. I don't care if the whole team is injured. Logan shouldn't be getting a look in ahead of inanimate carbon rod.

At least Rod doesn't periodically injure his own team mates.

 

[YoungsterPA]

Logan sadly won't be dropped this week

This will be his 100th game for port I'm pretty sure so he will play

 

[Janey]

I think if Surj and Pittard had been fit for the last 2 months then Logan probably wouldnt have got much of a look in.

Jasper is meant to be OK for next week so hopefully he gets to play the last few games for the year.

 

[CrimsonRaven]

Young needs to come in, had 25 touches 5 clearances 3I50s and 2 R50s for North.

 

[PatientMental]

Out: Zumba.

In: Football.

 

[tesseract]

Please Port, keep Logan in, for I want to see McGinnity and Logan battle it out to see who's the biggest spud in the AFL.

 

[shewho]

Logan sadly won't be dropped this week

This will be his 100th game for port I'm pretty sure so he will play

Then one last game in case he has a son to a woman who doesn't fumble and can distribute by hand and foot.

 

[Junk]

Out: Logan, McCarthy, Rodan, Pfeiffer, Chaplin
In: Surjan, Salopek, Young, Pittard, Carlile

(out: turnovers)
(in: youth, hardness, skill and Carlile)

 

[Eddie Dingle]

Please Port, keep Logan in, for I want to see McGinnity and Logan battle it out to see who's the biggest spud in the AFL.

This might be the only contest we win.

 

[stanmack]

Doesn't matter who we bring in , I think the Darwin game killed any kind of fitness we had. If Buddy and Roughead had played we would have lost to them by as much as last year. Our players true fitness bases are showing through now. Seventeen points down with seventeen minutes to go into the last 1/4 and we lose by 72. Thats as bad as anything we dished up last year.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Please Port, keep Logan in

The words of every one of our opponents.

McGinnity is better than Logan. At least McGinnity is good defensively. Logan is terrible offensively and defensively.

 

[Francis Soyer]

Out: Logan, McCarthy

In: Anyone who can hit a target under pressure or in the clear

 

[FishingRick04]

We may as well keep him in if it helps the Bulldogs and maybe Melbourne jump us

 

[Peck]

Rodin? More like Rodout!

I actually don't care at the moment unfortunately. I would drop Logan as well though, neither of these players should play for us ever again.

 

[S.Patrol.G]

I've always respected Logan for his commitment to the contest, but he makes us a much worse team. He really should be playing A3's.

 

[FishingRick04]

It's good to see there is a mass awakening over Logan. Thomas will be next

Thank god for GWS I say

 

[StrappingTape]

Think thats really positive thinking to think melbourne will jump us. We will beat brisbane anyway I think