Preview Changes versus Geelong

[Carnthe]

Jmac doesn't do enough for my liking so i think he should go back to the 2's and work on getting the ball more and impacting the game more, agree with campbell I have him in my outs also along with cam delaney. Ziebell, hansen and pederson should replace the 3 mentioned.

This is the same Jamie MacMillan that had 21 touches, 6 inside 50s, 1 goal and 2 goal assists? He was next cab off the rank for goals contributed after Edwards, Harper, McIntosh, Anthony and Bastinac.

 

[THE MOEMAN]

This is the same Jamie MacMillan that had 21 touches, 6 inside 50s, 1 goal and 2 goal assists? He was next cab off the rank for goals contributed after Edwards, Harper, McIntosh, Anthony and Bastinac.

Yep he also had just 10 disposals against essendon.
Macmillan only got 21 touches in a full game against GWS compare it to Mullett who got 16 touches and 2 goals in 1 half.

 

[Saintly31]

IN: L. Delaney, Ziebell
OUT: C. Delaney, Thomas

B: McMahon - Thompson - Macmillan
HB: Firrito - L. Delaney - Wright
C: Bastinac - Adams - Wells
HF: Harper - Petrie - Mullett
F: Harvey - McIntosh - Edwards
FOLL: Goldstein - Swallow - Ziebell
I: Anthony - Atley - Cunnington
S: Campbell

E: Hasen- Pedo - Warren

* Luke in for Cam. Need the bigger bodied defender for the Cats and I'm assuming Narni isn't right to play. Car Keys to get Hawkins, Thompson to J-Pod.

*JZ in for Thomas. Again, another harder body around the ball. Jack an automatic selection.

*Mullett/Wright playing off back/forward flank respectively. I'd like Sammy to go forward and I think Mullett's more use off hb, but Scott seems set in playing Wright in defence.

*No room for Hansen. Big fan of Pedo and would mind having him as the sub at the expense of Campbell.

Good summary.

Personally;

Ins: C Delaney (to make it x2), JZ (obviously), Pederson (need him in the 1s)

Outs: LT (injured), Campbell (another poor game), Anthony (im with Moeman, downhill skier...stats inflate him so much its ridiculous - against Geelong....no)

 

[Husk]

Yep he also had just 10 disposals against essendon.
Macmillan only got 21 touches in a full game against GWS compare it to Mullett who got 16 touches and 2 goals in 1 half.

Yeah Mullet was better IMO.

I think JMac stays in this week though.

 

[THE MOEMAN]

Good summary.

Personally;

Ins: C Delaney (to make it x2), JZ (obviously), Pederson (need him in the 1s)

Outs: LT (injured), Campbell (another poor game), Anthony (im with Moeman, downhill skier...stats inflate him so much its ridiculous - against Geelong....no)

??? I've been calling for macmillan to get dropped not anthony.

 

[Saintly31]

Apologies, meant L Delaney in with C Delaney......knew I gio it wrong when I was typing!

 

[Saintly31]

??? I've been calling for macmillan to get dropped not anthony.

Sorry, struggling with the new phone! Comment was from Jacko together with yours which I missed.

Apologies Moeman

 

[DarwinRoo]

Most over-rated player on this board. Don't rate as highly as others and I have mullett, atley and wright ahead of him

I think you are mistaking McMillian with Harper.

 

[THE MOEMAN]

I think you are mistaking McMillian with Harper.

Na...macmillan is the most over-rated on this board. Doesn't have a specific aspect of the game that he excels in, he is just average at everything.

 

[DarwinRoo]

He isn't average at all. Mullet had the same disposals as Harper and kicked more goals in less game time and Harper plays forward, McMillian doesn't.

 

[THE MOEMAN]

He isn't average at all. Mullet had the same disposals as Harper and kicked more goals in less game time and Harper plays forward, McMillian doesn't.

Harper also has more talent in his little finger than jmac does in his entire body.
Harps doesn't need a ton of disposals to impact a game, his 1 percenters are amazing laying sheppards and tackles like a crazy man. And his disposal and speed is elite.

Jmac needs to go back to the 2's and learn to impact games more.

 

[Deep We11s 1]

Harper also has more talent in his little finger than jmac does in his entire body.
Harps doesn't need a ton of disposals to impact a game, his 1 percenters are amazing laying sheppards and tackles like a crazy man. And his disposal and speed is elite.

Jmac needs to go back to the 2's and learn to impact games more.

Moe (now I get it), Macmillan is a gun and Anthony is a definite. Don't know what you've been smoking mate, both are in best 22 ATM.

 

[DarwinRoo]

What a load of shit.

 

[GarnerSmash]

Jesus, some funny shit in this thread of late.

 

[THE MOEMAN]

Moe (now I get it), Macmillan is a gun and Anthony is a definite. Don't know what you've been smoking mate, both are in best 22 ATM.

I agree anthony is best 22 and was very good in the preseason games aswell as on the weekend but jmac is not yet best 22.

 

[rooboy44]

Harper also has more talent in his little finger than jmac does in his entire body.
Harps doesn't need a ton of disposals to impact a game, his 1 percenters are amazing laying sheppards and tackles like a crazy man. And his disposal and speed is elite.

Jmac needs to go back to the 2's and learn to impact games more.

I haven't read every post every on BF but pretty sure this might be the stupidest...... you are joking aren't you? I agree with you bout Harps, hes unreal but Jmac being the most overrated player and having no talent? Jmac is the future of our half back line. I'd be getting Sam Wright out before Jmac any day of the week.

 

[THE MOEMAN]

I haven't read every post every on BF but pretty sure this might be the stupidest...... you are joking aren't you? I agree with you bout Harps, hes unreal but Jmac being the most overrated player and having no talent? Jmac is the future of our half back line. I'd be getting Sam Wright out before Jmac any day of the week.

Never said he has no talent, just saying harps is much more talented.
I agree jmac is probably going to be a good hbf but atm he is not best 22 imo

 

[rooboy44]

Never said he has no talent, just saying harps is much more talented.
I agree jmac is probably going to be a good hbf but atm he is not best 22 imo

And you think Wright is? Give me a break. I don't mind Wright but Jmac gets the nod over him every time at the moment, I don't really see where Wright fits in.

 

[THE MOEMAN]

And you think Wright is? Give me a break. I don't mind Wright but Jmac gets the nod over him every time at the moment, I don't really see where Wright fits in.

Most definetly have wright over jmac. Wright is very versatile and can play almost every position on the ground, is great off both feet and has excellent footy smarts.

 

[GarnerSmash]

And the laughs keep coming.....

 

[THE MOEMAN]

And the laughs keep coming.....

Great input coming from this guy. Keep the enthralling feedback coming.
Lot of love for jmac on this board

 

[ThePezDispenser]

I think you are mistaking McMillian with Harper.

Couldn't be... Harper deserves even more recognition

 

[shintemaster]

This thread reads like jozeph created 5 aliases and started trolling himself. I have no idea who is serious and who isn't.

 

[Husk]

Seems everyone has an axe to grind for one player or another.

At least they are mixing it up a bit. A refreshing change from the Hansen and LT bashing.

 

[Fart Cummings]

not sure who makes way but still reckon we are a better side with pedo in it!