Coach vs Coach

[hawks_time]

Over their awesome coaching careers who do you think was the better of these 2 coaches?

 

[Jatz]

sheedy

 

[inthesong]

Matthews Delivered Collingwood there First prem in 30 odd years then came in to brisbane and delivered 3 Premierships in is first 6 years. Amazing Coach and Player, probably the equal best asset (along with Barassi) the game has had thus far.

Sheedy was great but 4 Prems in 27-28?? years is about par with the hsitory of the club 16 in 111

 

[tigers_of_old_08]

Sheedy, the master coach..

 

[ad4eva]

Its interesting.

Both you could argue for different reasons but im going with Matthews.

Hes beaten Sheedy in two Grand Finals too, if that makes any difference.

 

[BluesMan]

over their playing career Mathews but as coach sheedy!

 

[Carlton_Blues]

sheeds

 

[Pioneer]

I would pick Sheedy any day of the week over Matthews.