Daniel Talia vs Jake Carlisle

[kade]

Are you seriously going to tell me that Jenkins is better than Carlisle now?

jenkins has show more consistency as a forward than carlisle. Are you basing this on 2 games?

 

[timtamWB]

jenkins has show more consistency as a forward than carlisle. Are you basing this on 2 games?

Carlisle's also showed a bit as a forward last year and a bit throughout this year. Would you take Jenkins before Carlisle if you had the choice?

 

[Bailey01]

Carlisle's also showed a bit as a forward last year and a bit throughout this year. Would you take Jenkins before Carlisle if you had the choice?

I probably would take Carlisle in long term but consistency is the key

 

[timtamWB]

I probably would take Carlisle in long term but consistency is the key

Yes, but this is Carlisle's first full year in the forward line. He's still only 22, Jenkins is 25. For essentially a 2nd year KPF, I think Carlisle's done pretty well, and I'm confident that while he won't keep this hot streak up, he'll definitely become more consistent.

 

[Bailey01]

Yes, but this is Carlisle's first full year in the forward line. He's still only 22, Jenkins is 25. For essentially a 2nd year KPF, I think Carlisle's done pretty well, and I'm confident that while he won't keep this hot streak up, he'll definitely become more consistent.

This is Jenkins' 3rd in the AFL so he's got plenty of years left. Don't forget he is still learning the game as a Basketball convert so he's got room for improvement. Small sample size for Carlisle as a forward. How about let's see if he can put more excellent games together? More than 2

 

[Vindicater]

Jenkins goes alright

Urrgghhh..

 

[eth-dog]

This is Jenkins' 3rd in the AFL so he's got plenty of years left. Don't forget he is still learning the game as a Basketball convert so he's got room for improvement. Small sample size for Carlisle as a forward. How about let's see if he can put more excellent games together? More than 2

It's his 4th year. It's his 3rd at Adelaide