David Hale vs Will Minson

[The_Flying_Egg]

Hale has had more chances than Willy due to the fact Luke Darcy is a footballing God and he is only starting to make the ruck position his own now. Willy has not been given as much of a chance and is less experienced, but he has already began to show he could be a very good ruckman for us

I'd take Willy mainly due to his agression and attack on the ball which are second to none. I also think Willy has a lot more confidence in his ability than Hale does

 

[Borgsta]

Both drafted in 2002.

The poster wasnt referring to draft dates, do some research.

 

[BulldogMike]

Will Minson is majorly superior to Hale and is by far a better player. Minson would also snap him with some decent body contact so you know who i'd take.

 

[ARDENSTREETforever]

Thats that feral Bulldog coming out in ya mike, wheres the North man, who we all know?

 

[mocaholic]

i will get back to you once ive seen em both play

You are obviously not related to Robert "Gee, I haven't seen either of them play but I reckon Hale is better...." Walls.

Surely you can make an opinion judged on their size, hairdo or jumper no.? This IS BigFooty you know.

 

[DaVillaBlues]

Nearly 10 years on, i thought it would be interesting to revisit this poll

I voted for Hale myself, been a pivotal part in 2 Hawthorn premierships, and yes i am aware Minson was AA last year.

I probably have too much time on my hands, going through years old polls !

 

[Chism]

I probably have too much time on my hands, going through years old polls !

Agree.

Closed.