EDFL Div 1 Discussion 2023

[Charlie Bucket]

You're the one introducing "some random" to the discourse.
He's speaking of the one that's actually signed to play at Wallan not someone's brother that most wouldn't know of..

No I didn’t.

I spoke about his brother Shaun not being a very good player and my surprise at him potentially being a good signing at Wallan. Clear as day in what I posted. Didn’t mention any random player.

For some reason that was confusing for you and others?

 

[Gremlin77]

No I didn’t.

I spoke about his brother Shaun not being a very good player and my surprise at him potentially being a good signing at Wallan. Clear as day in what I posted. Didn’t mention any random player.

For some reason that was confusing for you and others?

Shaun Stewart has signed from Rupertswood, I was talking about him. No idea who you are referring to, misunderstanding

 

[BlueJet]

No I didn’t.

I spoke about his brother Shaun not being a very good player and my surprise at him potentially being a good signing at Wallan. Clear as day in what I posted. Didn’t mention any random player.

For some reason that was confusing for you and others?

Yes you did & it isn't confusing anyone as the rest of us knew who was being discussed.
It was you assuming that it was Chris Stewart's brother - it isn't.
Play on.

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

Alright enough discussions about the Stewarts. Lets move on

 

[Charlie Bucket]

Yes you did & it isn't confusing anyone as the rest of us knew who was being discussed.
It was you assuming that it was Chris Stewart's brother - it isn't.
Play on.

I assumed it was his brother Shaun. It was cleared up that it wasn’t and I explained why I thought it was strange his brother was possibly a good pick up for Wallan when he’s not a very good footballer. Pretty straight forward discussion between two posters.

Others then responded being confused with who I was talking about.

For some reason, you then decided to chirp up like a bit of a dill.

 

[PortVic]

The Stewart brothers could be up there with best brother combination in Local footy. My favourites are Shylo & Dean Smith spewing they never played together

 

[Div1fanatic]

Mo Saad to West Coburg.
Will be a handy player for the burgers during all their away games.
Cant imagine him maxing out his speed and talent on that pathetic excuse of an oval WC call home.

 

[ZingerAbed]

Saad, Saad and Taha is a potent forward line

 

[Silver Tongue]

Neutral supporter champ. As my username suggests, I am but a fanatic of the best division in local football.

You went early with the 'champ' call my friend. Not sure the bullying claim holds weight to be honest.

 

[Aucklander]

Saad, Saad and Taha is a potent forward line

Could easily go the H & A season unbeaten again.

 

[ZingerAbed]

Could easily go the H & A season unbeaten again.

But all for nothing if they can’t do it on the big stage

 

[StormRider]

Saad, Saad and Taha is a potent forward line

Not sure on the new recruit Saad, however strong back lines will contain.
Just look back on last 2 finals and all 6 forwards were shutdown over the last 8 quarters.
They need a strong and tall forward to help them out not sure another quick non tall is answer.

 

[ZingerAbed]

Not sure on the new recruit Saad, however strong back lines will contain.
Just look back on last 2 finals and all 6 forwards were shutdown over the last 8 quarters.
They need a strong and tall forward to help them out not sure another quick non tall is answer.

They definitely lacked a tall especially through. Taha did kick 9 goals in 3 finals though. 6 against Rupo though.

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

West Coburg won't be going back up. Marby will.
Most premier clubs don't want West Coburg in Premier anyway, Shore Reserve too narrow. Little chance West will have Coburg City Oval like they did pre covid.

 

[Div1fanatic]

West Coburg won't be going back up. Marby will.
Most premier clubs don't want West Coburg in Premier anyway, Shore Reserve too narrow. Little chance West will have Coburg City Oval like they did pre covid.

I think its safe to say most EDFL clubs dont want West Coburg in their comp if it means they have to play at Shore Reserve.

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

I think its safe to say most EDFL clubs dont want West Coburg in their comp if it means they have to play at Shore Reserve.

Yes correct. West Coburg don't want to leave Shore its all been dictated by the premier division clubs they play at Coburg City Oval.

 

[Gremlin77]

Yes correct. West Coburg don't want to leave Shore its all been dictated by the premier division clubs they play at Coburg City Oval.

What a load of crap. Shore reserve has been home of West Coburg for as long as I can remember, it’s unique no doubt, BUT it’s a park with goals at each end. Such a cop out clubs complaining about it, or worse blaming losses on the ground.

Could count on one hand how many ground in this league are above satisfactory, especially when compared to some of the bush leagues.

 

[Vlodrive]

What a load of crap. Shore reserve has been home of West Coburg for as long as I can remember, it’s unique no doubt, BUT it’s a park with goals at each end. Such a cop out clubs complaining about it, or worse blaming losses on the ground.

Could count on one hand how many ground in this league are above satisfactory, especially when compared to some of the bush leagues.

Yep. A lot of country grounds absolutely s**t all over the grounds in the EDFL. Though there are some hidden gems. Rupos oval was in great nic for finals this season & same with Sunbury Kangaroos. I was surprised to see the condition of Keilors ground in the finals this year.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Div1fanatic]

What a load of crap. Shore reserve has been home of West Coburg for as long as I can remember, it’s unique no doubt, BUT it’s a park with goals at each end. Such a cop out clubs complaining about it, or worse blaming losses on the ground.

Could count on one hand how many ground in this league are above satisfactory, especially when compared to some of the bush leagues.

Heres a fun topic:
2023 EDFL DIV 1 ground power rankings
1. Roxburgh Park
2. Craigieburn
3. Glenroy
4. Westmeadows
5. Rupertswood
6. St Albans
7. Deer Park
8. Keilor Park
9. Tullamarine* (LEO DINEEN)
10. Hillside
11. Moonee Valley
12. West Coburg

Thoughts? Objections?
This is purely based on ground condition average from round 1-18.

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

What a load of crap. Shore reserve has been home of West Coburg for as long as I can remember, it’s unique no doubt, BUT it’s a park with goals at each end. Such a cop out clubs complaining about it, or worse blaming losses on the ground.

Could count on one hand how many ground in this league are above satisfactory, especially when compared to some of the bush leagues.

Lets not forget too, they're based in the worst LGA/Council in Metro Melbourne...the City of Merribek, formerly known as Moreland.

This is a Council that let its premier venue, Coburg City Oval go for years without a proper redevelopment especially after a fire burnt down the grandstand.

 

[CouldNotPlay]

Heres a fun topic:
2023 EDFL DIV 1 ground power rankings
1. Roxburgh Park
2. Craigieburn
3. Glenroy
4. Westmeadows
5. Rupertswood
6. St Albans
7. Deer Park
8. Keilor Park
9. Tullamarine* (LEO DINEEN)
10. Hillside
11. Moonee Valley
12. West Coburg

Thoughts? Objections?
This is purely based on ground condition average from round 1-18.

Roxy has one of the best surfaces going around and their bottom oval is just as good.

 

[Turbos mail]

Heres a fun topic:
2023 EDFL DIV 1 ground power rankings
1. Roxburgh Park
2. Craigieburn
3. Glenroy
4. Westmeadows
5. Rupertswood
6. St Albans
7. Deer Park
8. Keilor Park
9. Tullamarine* (LEO DINEEN)
10. Hillside
11. Moonee Valley
12. West Coburg

Thoughts? Objections?
This is purely based on ground condition average from round 1-18.

Are you serious.
Moonee Valley and West Coburg in top 12. That’s a joke.
Roxy is reasonable but just lock your car and make sure no shootings in the area.

 

[MortlockWatcher]

Turbos mail ... it says grounds in Division 1 ...

 

[stroketurboego]

Heres a fun topic:
2023 EDFL DIV 1 ground power rankings
1. Roxburgh Park
2. Craigieburn
3. Glenroy
4. Westmeadows
5. Rupertswood
6. St Albans
7. Deer Park
8. Keilor Park
9. Tullamarine* (LEO DINEEN)
10. Hillside
11. Moonee Valley
12. West Coburg

Thoughts? Objections?
This is purely based on ground condition average from round 1-18.

Old news
Deer Park Glenroy and WM are no longer in Div 1



Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[torpfrom50]

Are you serious.
Moonee Valley and West Coburg in top 12. That’s a joke.
Roxy is reasonable but just lock your car and make sure no shootings in the area.

They are last and second last on the list of DIV 1 grounds. What is the joke?