Hello barfly, to be honest mate i've only been to 3 Roys games 2nd half of tulla, westy on anzac day and cragieburn, most of time has been spent watching cragieburn and seen doutta's for a couple of halves due to work commitments and depending on where the eagles playing! I'm pretty sure coomans is Injured and only played a couple of games so I will not pass judgement on him, fisher was solid in backline that was under pressure all day in game against cragieburn and in fairness steve silvagni could of played that day and wouldn't of mattered as roys were fairly uncompetitive after quarter time and losing dulic.
So to answer your question I still haven't seen enough of the 2 but in the small parts of what i've seen and heard from people down there they should both still be very handy players at this level!
As to the other part of my post made in preseason clearly the recruiting of blokes from lower levels maybe even coaching has not worked, this division is too good and competitive to be relying on mediocre recruiting to challenge the big boys and to even win enough games to make the 4! Yes they've had injuries but so does everyone probaly very lucky for all involed at sewell that NS are in this comp! Would be thinking they need an influx of talent this offseason or might be last year in div1 and this coaching staff!
