List Mgmt. Hypothetical trades and wishlists thread

[Teamwork Talks]

Neither out of contract, or is saying that not allowed in a Wishlist thread?

Mitchell wasn't out of contract last year. Can still trade out contract players.

 

[Pessimistic]

If they agree. Can happen if destination offers better deal

I don't think we'll be too excited about another pick 88 though

 

[Soaring Hawk]

My dream scenario

2018 1st + Puopolo for Whitfield
Birchall for De Goey

2017 RFA
Trengove

2018 RFA
Lynch

Our starting midfield would be on-par with the best in the league (Smith, Mitchell, O'Meara, De Goey, Whitfield, McEvoy). I rate De Goey and would make a play for him.

With Glass, Hardwick, Morrison, and Glass, I think we have enough HB depth to cover Birchall by the time we're challenging again.

Although I'd rather Lever, we can trade for everyone, and Trengove would cover for the next few years before Nash is truly ready. I like Brand, but I'm still not convinced he's our next Lake / FB game-saver.

Lynch would immediately solve our tall forward options (although, not sure we would spend that type of coin). Perhaps just a dream.

 

[Dystopia]

Cyril's gone....

Didn't Wayne Carey start some crap rumour back in April this year, saying that Cyril was homesick or something, and Clarkon called him out for being a bullshiter !!!

 

[dipper86]

26 to 30+ age bracket in 2018
26
Gunston
Langford
27
Ceglar.
Shoey
Shiels
Breust
Dureya
28
Whitey
Vickery
29
Henderson
Stratton
Smith
Frawley
Rioli
McEvoy
30+
Poo
Birchall
Burgoyne
Roughead

Any number of these in bold could be gone come the end of trade period through either trade or delistings, the middle to old tier certainly needs a clean out.
Plenty of potential for 2nd round and 3rd round picks to replenish our peripherals, and/or packages with 2nd round picks acquired through trades and then packaged with a player to gain middle to late first round picks and/or players through trade.
I think we have a few good options to give our list a good shake up.

 

[HODGEYROAD]

I've heard a rumour today Roberton from St.Kilda could be coming to Hawthorn, what are people's thoughts on him ?

 

[OnceKicked50]

My dream scenario

2018 1st + Puopolo for Whitfield
Birchall for De Goey

2017 RFA
Trengove

2018 RFA
Lynch

Our starting midfield would be on-par with the best in the league (Smith, Mitchell, O'Meara, De Goey, Whitfield, McEvoy). I rate De Goey and would make a play for him.

With Glass, Hardwick, Morrison, and Glass, I think we have enough HB depth to cover Birchall by the time we're challenging again.

Although I'd rather Lever, we can trade for everyone, and Trengove would cover for the next few years before Nash is truly ready. I like Brand, but I'm still not https://openload.co/f/b0pVtXrywfQ/got.s07e01.720p.web.h264-tbs.mkv he's our next Lake / FB game-saver.

Lynch would immediately solve our tall forward options (although, not sure we would spend that type of coin). Perhaps just a dream.

im a little disappointed you stopped at Birchall for degoey actually. How about Leaver for shoemakers?

 

[wahawk]

Gutted!!

Chin up

You can trade contracted players

 

[wahawk]

Hearing Mayne's available

of course he is.

He's on $500,000 a year & played 3 games.

I was shocked collingwood took him

But not as shocked as I was when I found out what they were paying him

 

[Hawks1994]

Didn't Wayne Carey start some crap rumour back in April this year, saying that Cyril was homesick or something, and Clarkon called him out for being a bullshiter !!!

It's a strange rumour to start, last time I checked, the Tiwi Islands didn't have an AFL side

 

[HawksILove]

I've heard a rumour today Roberton from St.Kilda could be coming to Hawthorn, what are people's thoughts on him ?

Yes, I heard something like that, they were interested

 

[Brant]

I've heard a rumour today Roberton from St.Kilda could be coming to Hawthorn, what are people's thoughts on him ?

We've apparently been into him for a while - at least this season, probably longer.

He's been playing on larger forwards so gets hung out a bit, but as an intercept/rebounder he's sound.

But, with Sicily & Burton already there & Stratton/Birch/Frawley to return, I don't think we'd want to pay for him. Only if we lost Frawley + Stratts + Birch would I want.

*when I heard the number we were discussing a few months back I almost cried. Absolutely no inside mail but it started with a '7' & that's gotta be huge overs, unless he's an FA & we're looking to sling Saints another 1st rounder

 

[threesixpio]

The following video shows Conor McKenna has a good footy brain (Watch no 45):



It seems to me Conor's first instinct when he gets the ball is to accelerate. He then either gets caught or the game opens up. At 21yrs old his game sense will only get better.
I'd love him at the Hawks

Conor is out of contract.

Ken hell. Three Conors in the backline?

 

[HODGEYROAD]

We've apparently been into him for a while - at least this season, probably longer.

He's been playing on larger forwards so gets hung out a bit, but as an intercept/rebounder he's sound.

But, with Sicily & Burton already there & Stratton/Birch/Frawley to return, I don't think we'd want to pay for him. Only if we lost Frawley + Stratts + Birch would I want.

*when I heard the number we were discussing a few months back I almost cried. Absolutely no inside mail but it started with a '7' & that's gotta be huge overs, unless he's an FA & we're looking to sling Saints another 1st rounder

Nah he's not a FA just out of contract, that number you heard is absolutely sickening.

 

[Brant]

Nah he's not a FA just out of contract, that number you heard is absolutely sickening.

Even more sickening if we had to trade for him.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

If Mayne leaves Collingwood they'd have to pay him out $1.5M - he won't be leaving.

 

[threesixpio]

If Mayne leaves Collingwood they'd have to pay him out $1.5M - he won't be leaving.

Yeah - Buckley's chance......


......



......

 

[tige19]

The very person who gave a heads up to Mitchell being an Eagle last year prior to the media getting a sniff, has suggested that we will need to strap ourselves in for another emotional trade period as Wright continues to regenerate the list.

That literally means all but a very small handful of players could be tabled to see what the interest is, if they've not already got deals organised.

Nice

 

[MasterSamurai]

Roberton is surplus to needs. Doesn't excite me one bit nor does it make sense as far as our list profile. Hope we don't waste trades on him.
Well, there isn't too many players left to poach it seems with only Kelly available.
I also think norf and blues are throwing everything bar the kitchen sink at everyone so this may make it extremely difficult to get Balic/kennedy types.
We have to be Inventive.

 

[Brant]

Roberton is surplus to needs. Doesn't excite me one bit nor does it make sense as far as our list profile. Hope we don't waste trades on him.
Well, there isn't too many players left to poach it seems with only Kelly available.
I also think norf and blues are throwing everything bar the kitchen sink at everyone so this may make it extremely difficult to get Balic/kennedy types.
We have to be Inventive.

How/why is Kelly 'avaliable' but Kennedy/Balic are difficult to get?

I'd see Kelly as difficult to get with Balic & Kennedy being available

 

[OnceKicked50]

of course he is.

He's on $500,000 a year & played 3 games.

I was shocked collingwood took him

But not as shocked as I was when I found out what they were paying him

Glass houses...

 

[MasterSamurai]

How/why is Kelly 'avaliable' but Kennedy/Balic are difficult to get?

I'd see Kelly as difficult to get with Balic & Kennedy being available

I didn't mean it that way.
What I meant was with only Kelly available who is ungetteable for us, that leaves a few Slim choices like those two to add to our squad. Meaning that GW may be looking at a different option we haven't thought of.

 

[MasterSamurai]

Why would Brisbane want him though? They are behind us in terms of development so Cyril would not be there for their next premiership tilt.

Only way I would be comfortable seeing Cyril out the door is if Kelly was coming back the other way.

Even then I'm trembling at the thought of Cyril in different colours!

 

[Hawkboy62]

Ken hell. Three Conors in the backline?

Has pace, evasive skills, can kick goals and not yet re-signed with Bombers. Worth the enquiry even if only to push up his price. A few other clibs would be interested.

 

[threesixpio]

Would be a fair craic to have three Irish Conors