Injury Injury update thread

[THATSGOLD]

Is Reid playing VFL?
Sorry im unable to watch it at the moment.. If so, i guess that's good news...

Reid got injured in the vfl 2 weeks ago.

 

[Apex36]

Reid got injured in the vfl 2 weeks ago.

Latest update has Reid likely to play this week.

 

[THATSGOLD]

Latest update has Reid likely to play this week.

Yeh vfl again woohooo..

 

[Maggie5]

Yeh vfl again woohooo..

I think he was referring to Sam Reid.

 

[NT.Thunder]

He needs to play at least one full game at VFL. He's missed too much football.

I'm not worried about him being injured during either game, as far as I'm concerned if the medical staff deem him fit to play VFL or AFL his body is 100%. It's just getting match fitness and feel for the game that I want to see.

Playing him against WCE would be a big mistake IMO.

 

[Collingwoodity]

He needs to play at least one full game at VFL. He's missed too much football.

I'm not worried about him being injured during either game, as far as I'm concerned if the medical staff deem him fit to play VFL or AFL his body is 100%. It's just getting match fitness and feel for the game that I want to see.

Playing him against WCE would be a big mistake IMO.

Freeman or Reid?

 

[Kappa]

Season over for Broomhead?

 

[NT.Thunder]

Freeman or Reid?

Reid.

*edit - Kappa are you asking a question or stating a fact?

Wow, season over for Broomy is devastating for him the club and supporters. Let's hope he reloads for next season and comes out stronger than ever.

Imagine how disappointed the look must be on his face now considering how he looks after kicking a goal.

 

[Apex36]

Reid.

*edit - Kappa are you asking a question or stating a fact?

Wow, season over for Broomy is devastating for him the club and supporters. Let's hope he reloads for next season and comes out stronger than ever.

Imagine how disappointed the look must be on his face now considering how he looks after kicking a goal.

I took it as him asking a question, and a fair one at that. 6 weeks out with 8 rounds to play. You'd assume he will have to come back through the VFL. At this stage he will likely struggle to get back in the senior team even if we make finals. Really unfortunate timing for the kid.

 

[NT.Thunder]

I took it as him asking a question, and a fair one at that. 6 weeks out with 8 rounds to play. You'd assume he will have to come back through the VFL. At this stage he will likely struggle to get back in the senior team even if we make finals. Really unfortunate timing for the kid.

Yeah I wouldn't expect to see him this season again barring more injuries from our playing group during finals.

 

[Copeland]

Even if Reid plays 1 quarter in the VFL this week, just get him in, im serious sick of him not playing ones.

We all want him mate, he would be huge to our side, I just have a feeling we will never see the best of Reid again. Not for a prolonged period anyway.

 

[Apex36]

Being reported that Elliott is in doubt after not training today. Any of the usual suspects have any insight on this Scodog10 Snell1234 ?

 

[Harry O]

Still can't believe so many Collingwood supporters are taking this injury curse so casually. Davoren has stuffed half the list and Eddie seems oblivious to the disaster.

 

[popin]

umm ok then

 

[Bucksboys]

Still can't believe so many Collingwood supporters are taking this injury curse so casually. Davoren has stuffed half the list and Eddie seems oblivious to the disaster.

It's every club.. that's the modern game, you are comparing it to the old days and those days are gone

 

[Harry O]

It's every club.. that's the modern game, you are comparing it to the old days and those days are gone

No it is not. Stress fractures and repeated soft tissue injuries to the same players suggest a fitness regime in crisis. Lucky for the club our supporters are blind to failure.

 

[Apex36]

Still can't believe so many Collingwood supporters are taking this injury curse so casually. Davoren has stuffed half the list and Eddie seems oblivious to the disaster.

Do you ever have anything positive to post. Seriously struggling to remember anything you've ever said that wasn't just bitching about something...

 

[Bucksboys]

No it is not. Stress fractures and repeated soft tissue injuries to the same players suggest a fitness regime in crisis. Lucky for the club our supporters are blind to failure.

Uh huh

ADELAIDE Kyle Cheney (Back) Test
Brad Crouch (Foot) 6-7 Weeks
Harry Dear* (Shoulder) TBA
Mitch Grigg (Ankle) 1-2 Weeks
Matt Jaensch (Knee) Season
Mitch McGovern (Knee) 1-2 Weeks
Brent Reilly (Skull) Retired
Rory Sloane (Cheekbone) 3-5 Weeks
Updated Tuesday July 14

BRISBANE LIONS
Claye Beams* (Knee) Season
Michael Close* (Knee) Season
Darcy Gardiner (Shoulder/Ankle) Season
Josh Green (Foot) 4 Weeks
Cian Hanley (Knee) Season
Ryan Lester (Knee) 6 Weeks
Matt Maguire (Retired) Season
Jaden McGrath (Foot) 3-4 Weeks
Luke McGuane (Knee) Indefinite
Jackson Paine* (Ankle) Season
Mitch Robinson (Ankle) 1 Week
Josh Watts (Groin) Test
Trent West (Knee) Test
Updated Tuesday July 14

CARLTON
Dennis Armfield (Arm) 4 Weeks
Bryce Gibbs (Pectoral) Season
David Ellard (Calf) 2-3 Weeks
Sam Docherty (Hamstring) Test
Cameron Giles (Foot) Indefinite
Billy Gowers (Shoulder) 1-2 Weeks
Nick Graham (Foot) 2 Weeks
Michael Jamison (Concussion) Test
Chris Judd (Knee) Retired
Ciaran Sheehan* (Groin) 5 Weeks
Dale Thomas (Shoulder) Season
Andrew Walker (Knee) 1 Week
Robert Warnock (Shoulder) Season
Updated Tuesday July 14

COLLINGWOOD
Brendan Abbott (Shoulder) Test
Taylor Adams (Suspension) 2 Weeks
Tony Armstrong (Knee) Test
Tim Broomhead (Shoulder) 6 Weeks
Nathan Freeman (Hamstring) 2-3 Weeks
Corey Gault (Hip Flexor) Test
Tyson Goldsack (Knee) Test
Levi Greenwood (Thigh) Available
Brent Macaffer* (Knee) 3-4 Weeks
Ben Reid (Calf) Test
Jackson Ramsay (Shin) 3-5 Weeks
Updated Tuesday July 14

ESSENDON
Tom Bellchambers* (Foot) Season
Alex Browne (Concussion) Test
Jake Carlisle (Ankle) 4-6 Weeks
Paul Chapman (Groin) 1 Week
Travis Colyer* (Foot) Season
Orazio Fantasia (Thigh) 1-2 Weeks
Dustin Fletcher (Abdominal Tendinitis) 1-2 Weeks
Heath Hocking (Back) Test
Nick Kommer (Thigh) 1-2 Weeks
Jake Melksham (Hamstring) Test
David Myers (Knee) Test
Jobe Watson (Shoulder) Season
Jason Winderlich (Shin) 2 Weeks
Updated Tuesday July 14

FREMANTLE
Michael Apeness (Knee) TBA
Ryan Crowley (Suspended) TBA
Zac Dawson (Thumb) 1-2 Weeks
Michael Johnson (Hamstring) 4-5 Weeks
Anthony Morabito (Knee) TBA
Alex Silvagni (Hamstring) 1-2 Weeks
Updated Tuesday July 14

GEELONG
Mitch Clark (Calf) 2 Weeks
Nakia Cockatoo (Adductor) Test
Josh Cowan (Hamstring) 2 Weeks
Jordan Cunico (Knee) Test
Cameron Delaney (Foot) 4-6 Weeks
Mitch Duncan (Foot) 2 Weeks
Lincoln McCarthy* (Foot) Indefinite
Hamish McIntosh (Calf Tendon) 3 Weeks
Joel Selwood (Suspension) 1 Week
Rhys Stanley (Foot) Season
Nathan Vardy (Knee) 2 Weeks
Updated Tuesday July 14

GOLD COAST
Harley Bennell (Wellness) TBC
Jared Ellis (Shoulder) 2-3 Weeks
Jarrod Garlett* (Ankle) Indefinite
Daniel Gorringe (Groin) Test
Jarrod Harbrow (Ankle) Test
Kade Kolodjashnij (Glute) Test
Jack Martin (Hamstring) Test
Jaegar O'Meara* (Knee) Season
Dion Prestia (Knee) Indefinite
Luke Russell (Finger) 4 Weeks
Henry Schade (Hip) Test
Danny Stanley (MCL) 2 Weeks
Updated Tuesday July 14

GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY
Phil Davis (Ankle) 4 Week
Pat McKenna (Achilles) Test
Tim Mohr (Knee) Season
Shane Mumford (Ankle) Season
Joel Patfull (Ribs) 1 Week
Dylan Shiel (Knee) 6-12 Weeks
Updated Tuesday July 14

HAWTHORN
Jed Anderson (Back) 1 Week
Kaiden Brand* (Shoulder) Season
Taylor Duryea (Shoulder) Test
James Frawley (Shoulder) 1-2 Weeks
Jarryd Roughead (Lip) TBC
Brendan Whitecross (Shoulder) Test
Updated Tuesday July 14

MELBOURNE
Sam Frost (Toe) 2-3 Weeks
Dean Kent (Hamstring) 2 Weeks
Cameron Pederson (Wrist) Season
Christian Petracca* (Knee) Season
Christian Salem (Hamstring) 2 Weeks
Jack Trengove (Foot) Season
Updated Tuesday July 14


NORTH MELBOURNE
Leigh Adams (Concussion) Indefinite
Sam Durdin (Shoulder) Season
Nathan Grima* (Back) Retired
Robin Nahas (Hamstring) Test
Daniel Nielson* (Knee) Season
Drew Petrie (Suspension) 1 Week
Kayne Turner (Concussion) Test
Ed Vickers-Willis (Shoulder) Season
Daniel Wells (Achilles Tendon) Indefinite
Updated Tuesday July 14

PORT ADELAIDE
Alipate Carlisle (Back/Hip) 2 Weeks
Mitch Harvey (Groin) Test
Tom Jonas (Quad) Test
Jared Polec* (Foot) Indefinite
Mason Shaw (Groin) 2-3 Weeks
Matt White (Hamstring) 1-2 Weeks
Updated Tuesday July 14

RICHMOND
Dan Butler (Knee) 1 Week
Jason Castagna (Ankle) Test
Reece Conca (Hamstring) Available
Nathan Drummond* (Knee) Season
Shane Edwards (Leg) 2-4 Weeks
Corey Ellis (Hip flexor) Available
Todd Elton (Knee) 1-3 Weeks
Nathan Foley (Knee) Indefinite
Ben Griffiths (Shoulder) Test
Ricky Petterd* (Foot) Indefinite
Jayden Short (Ankle) Season
Tyrone Vickery (Suspension) 2 Weeks
Updated Tuesday July 14

ST KILDA
Blake Acres (Hand) 1 Week
Jack Billings (Shin) 4-5 Weeks
Tom Curren (Ankle) 10-11 Weeks
Nick Riewoldt (Calf) Test
Updated Tuesday July 14

SYDNEY
Alex Johnson* (Knee) Indefinite
Ben McGlynn (Hamstring) Test
Lewis Melican (Groin) Indefinite
Gary Rohan (Hamstring) 3 Weeks
James Rose (Hamstring) Test
Updated Tuesday July 14

WEST COAST
Mitch Brown (Knee) Season
Damien Cavka (Foot) TBA
Scott Lycett (Thigh) Test
Eric Mackenzie* (Knee) Season
Patrick McGinnity (Wrist) 1 Week
Simon Tunbridge (Ankle) Season
Alec Waterman (ill) 4-5 Weeks
Updated Tuesday July 14

WESTERN BULLDOGS
Brett Goodes (Arm) 2-3 Weeks
Matt Fuller (Quad) 3 Weeks
Joel Hamling (Back) Test
Mitch Honeychurch (Back) 1 Week
Nathan Hrovat (Hamstring) 1 Week
Tom Liberatore* (Knee) Season
Toby McLean (AC Joint) 5-7 Weeks
Fletcher Roberts (Ankle) Test
Jordan Roughead (Back) Test
Clay Smith (Knee) Season
Koby Stevens (Bruised Lung) Test
Updated Tuesday July 14

 

[Anzacday]

No it is not. Stress fractures and repeated soft tissue injuries to the same players suggest a fitness regime in crisis. Lucky for the club our supporters are blind to failure.

Must admit I am concerned with either the misinformation they're peddling or the lack of knowledge that is apparent.
To misdiagnose Broomhead which exacerbated his problem is simply unacceptable.
Quite within his rights to say get me outta here.

 

[Good_Old]

Must admit I am concerned with either the misinformation they're peddling or the lack of knowledge that is apparent.
To misdiagnose Broomhead which exacerbated his problem is simply unacceptable.
Quite within his rights to say get me outta here.

Can anyone elaborate on this? Did they make him return to the game or something?

 

[Bard]

Can anyone elaborate on this? Did they make him return to the game or something?

They let him spend an extra day or 2 in Adelaide rather than rushing him in for scans... Haven't seen anything to suggest this made the injury worse... Just meant we got to it 2 days later which is SOOOO MASSIVE when you look at his 6 weeks out.

 

[Good_Old]

They let him spend an extra day or 2 in Adelaide rather than rushing him in for scans... Haven't seen anything to suggest this made the injury worse... Just meant we got to it 2 days later which is SOOOO MASSIVE when you look at his 6 weeks out.

What's his injury anyway? AC joint or fracture in his acromion process isn't it? Either way all that can be done is immobilisation.

 

[Anzacday]

Can anyone elaborate on this? Did they make him return to the game or something?

My understanding is the injury occurred in the 1st quarter

 

[jmac70]

No it is not. Stress fractures and repeated soft tissue injuries to the same players suggest a fitness regime in crisis. Lucky for the club our supporters are blind to failure.

What would you have us do? I would really like to know cause this is my 40th year of being a paid up supporter.

 

[Good_Old]

What would you have us do? I would really like to know cause this is my 40th year of being a paid up supporter.

Write a strongly worded letter to the club.