Jack Watts

[DeGen]

Even if I have the receipt?

no return policy...

 

[bartelisahardnut]

Would Melbourne take geelongs newly acquired pick21 for him?

 

[bartelisahardnut]

Would Melbourne take geelongs newly acquired pick21 for him?

 

[Demonheart]

Would Melbourne take geelongs newly acquired pick21 for him?

No

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Would Melbourne take geelongs newly acquired pick21 for him?

We'll take Mitch Clark for him?

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Au contraire, Watts goes ok, just underperformed for his pick.

Watts goes ok... that's about it - he's a middling talent who just happened to be pick 1

 

[Nallad]

If Jack Watts was drafted at pick 70 instead of 1, would he of been delisted by now?

 

[Falchoon]

If Jack Watts was drafted at pick 70 instead of 1, would he of been delisted by now?

no, at 196cm and 23 years of age he's no worse than Sam Reid, Jesse White, Aaron Black, Liam Jones et al

 

[Rodney Dangerfield]

If Jack Watts was drafted at pick 70 instead of 1, would he of been delisted by now?

Too good at the essential skills of the game.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

If Jack Watts was drafted at pick 70 instead of 1, would he of been delisted by now?

These questions are so stupid. There's a reason that he was drafted at #1. If he'd gone at 70 we'd be saying "I can't believe a player with his skills/athletic ability slipped so low", and he'd have been able to play with none of the pressure that's been heaped on him since first coming to the club. No #4 jersey, no QB debut, no attention from opposition players/supporters, no media hype.

 

[Richo83]

no, at 196cm and 23 years of age he's no worse than Sam Reid, Jesse White, Aaron Black, Liam Jones et al

Black is much better than any of those players. And Jones and White have been shopped around by their clubs. If Watts isn't delisted, he surely should be traded, he just brings bad news to the club and doesn't really add that much to the side that a decent second rounder would provide. The only time he kicks goals is when he finds a mismatch. He has talent but you'd think his game would have clicked by now, at 23, he's not a kid anymore.

 

[Falchoon]

Black is much better than any of those players. And Jones and White have been shopped around by their clubs. If Watts isn't delisted, he surely should be traded, he just brings bad news to the club and doesn't really add that much to the side that a decent second rounder would provide. The only time he kicks goals is when he finds a mismatch. He has talent but you'd think his game would have clicked by now, at 23, he's not a kid anymore.

the question was would he be delisted, shopped around does not equal delisted.

 

[SterlingArcher]

No

I can't see any club bettering that?

The rumours in the media are GC and Adelaide. They would be stupid to offer up any of 8, 10 and 15. Admittedly I don't know much about Lyons, but 21 is probably just as good an offer? I'm unsure about what each party reportedly wants for this trade - is it Watts wanting out, Melbourne put the word out to test the waters, or clubs have ID'd Watts as the one for them. If it's even a little bit the first 2, 21 or Lyons (again, unsure of his worth) would surely have to be the best likely offer?

 

[MisterMarcus]

The dilemma with Watts is that he'd probably be a "good player in a good team".....but a "good team" probably wouldn't need him.

Whose place would he take at Hawthorn or Sydney, for example? He'd be no lock to make best 22.

 

[pistol17]

The dilemma with Watts is that he'd probably be a "good player in a good team".....but a "good team" probably wouldn't need him.

Whose place would he take at Hawthorn or Sydney, for example? He'd be no lock to make best 22.

Would be handy at freo

 

[Kram]

Would be handy at freo

Wouldn't even be best 22.

 

[Jars458]

No

You would be embarrassed to get that much? Don't rate him at all and certainly don't want him at the AFC.

 

[Scotty_222]

any more news come to light?

 

[Parkerman]

Watts to the Swans? Luckily we're banned from trading in players.

 

[Scotland]

No

Why not?

Think he is worth more/you can get better? Happy with his current output? Think 2015 will be his year?

 

[Kram]

Too good at the essential skills of the game.

Pity he has a heart the size of a pea.

 

[Demonheart]

I can't see any club bettering that?

The rumours in the media are GC and Adelaide. They would be stupid to offer up any of 8, 10 and 15. Admittedly I don't know much about Lyons, but 21 is probably just as good an offer? I'm unsure about what each party reportedly wants for this trade - is it Watts wanting out, Melbourne put the word out to test the waters, or clubs have ID'd Watts as the one for them. If it's even a little bit the first 2, 21 or Lyons (again, unsure of his worth) would surely have to be the best likely offer?

My preference is to keep him

 

[Demonheart]

You would be embarrassed to get that much? Don't rate him at all and certainly don't want him at the AFC.

Thanks for your contribution

 

[Demonheart]

Why not?

Think he is worth more/you can get better? Happy with his current output? Think 2015 will be his year?

I'm confident that Roos can get the best out of him, which I think will be worth more than that pick.

 

[Jars458]

Thanks for your contribution

Thanks for yours.