Jeff White Vs Josh Fraser

[Dane Swan 4 brownlow]

who is the better player

 

[BEEG]

ATM i think fraser but White has had the better career its really hard to say i have always been funny on White i dont no why i just have been i think at the end of there careers they will be both great players and always rememberd for carrying there teams ruck stocks

 

[boribori]

easily white
whites next off the list after big deano

 

[DarthTed]

Depends how they would be used.

White is a better ruck.

Fraser better up forward and a more versatile player.

Overall, probably Fraser.

 

[peppy la pew]

Both have seen better days, mummy boy White as a ruck-man for me, Fraser better around the ground.

I reckon most pies would be slightly disappointed with big Frase over his career, never seemed to reach his potential

 

[dutchy12]

White over his career but Fraser probably the more damaging of the 2

 

[BigWardy12]

White at Freo was better that Fraser
Fraser better than White after Freo

 

[BETON5]

easily white
whites next off the list after big deano

Both are champians for there club and the game i couldnt split the 2 with both having a big say on how successful there sides are goin to be...

 

[Kaiser Powser]

White has had a far better career than Fraser.

 

[Schmick]

It's an insult to White for even considering Fraser is better than him. Is Fraser even a "ruck"man?

 

[boribori]

whites been much more consistant
frasers had an up and down career
still a good player dont get me wrong

 

[markm106]

who is the better player

Think with white comming to the end fraser would be better now. But over the career i would say white. Also white hasnt had the opportunity to play up forward as he has been to good in the ruck.

 

[didak04]

It's an insult to White for even considering Fraser is better than him. Is Fraser even a "ruck"man?

umm well he plays ruck so the answer would be yes

 

[BEEG]

White has had a far better career than Fraser.

that would be because his alot older i think after there careers are done fraser will be looked at as the better player maybe not ruckman but player

 

[boribori]

that would be because his alot older i think after there careers are done fraser will be looked at as the better player maybe not ruckman but player

of course mr collingwood fan

 

[gollytas]

White by so far we shouldn't even be talking about it.

 

[Scotland]

Is Dane Swan 4 brownlow going to start any threads soon that aren't about comparing an over-rated Collingwood player to a clearly better opposition player?

What's up next? Matthew Pavlich vs Travis Cloke?

 

[THRILLHOU]

I saw this thread and thought this has to be a pies supporter lol. I would take Jeff White though

 

[Dane Swan 4 brownlow]

Is Dane Swan 4 brownlow going to start any threads soon that aren't about comparing an over-rated Collingwood player to a clearly better opposition player?

What's up next? Matthew Pavlich vs Travis Cloke?

who is the better player leon davis or Chris Judd / James hird in his prime

 

[LeisureSuitLori]

Fraser will take the honours this year with (FINALLY) a good ruckman to back him up.
For once he wont be burnt out come mid year. No wonder the poor bloke doesnt have any hair left!!
BIG year for Josh coming up.

 

[boribori]

lol travis cloke vs pavlich
i wouldnt be suprised if the collingwood fans answered cloke
leon davis vs judd hahahaha
thats a tough one collingwood fans

 

[boribori]

Fraser will take the honours this year with (FINALLY) a good ruckman to back him up.
For once he wont be burnt out come mid year. No wonder the poor bloke doesnt have any hair left!!
BIG year for Josh coming up.

my god if only collingwood fans knew how stupid they look
i wouldnt be suprised if you all rate rocca ahead of j brown

 

[Zeke]

i wouldnt be suprised if you all rate rocca ahead of j brown

It's an interesting topic...

 

[jonesy86]

as a ruckman and nothing else...White by a mile

as an allround package it's line-ball, however Fraser is still only 25 with time on his side

 

[Tigersman]

as a ruckman and nothing else...White by a mile

as an allround package it's line-ball, however Fraser is still only 25 with time on his side

Your kidding yourself!

Open the other eye and you will see that White is a far better player and is easily in the top 3 or 4 ruckmen in the comp. Not so with Fraser.

How is Frasers back injury this year? Has it gone or is it an on going issue?