Jmp vs Bartlett????

[Asgardian]

Round 1: Callum Bartlett
Round 2: Jasper McMillan-Pittard
Round 3: Derek Wanganeen
Round 4: small fwd/project ruck or if available...Ah Chee

Probably just me, but Wanganeen playing for the Crows doesn't sound right

 

[Asgardian]

We wont take Lucas in my opinion becasue he was one of the names that was mentioned to me that they were looking at 13.

Faith, which of these guys (Scully, Trengove, Martin, Morabito, Cunnington, Rohan, Jetta, Butcher, Lucas, Talia, Melksham, Carlisle, Black, Sheppard & Tapscott), wouldn't you take at pick 13 ahead of Bartlett or McMillan-Pittard.

 

[lunacy]

A question to Adelaide fans, I think Lucas will still be available at our pick.
So would you choose Lucas or JMP?
Thats been a question i've tried to answer all day.

Lucasa. I'd be very happy with either jetta/bartlett/lucas with pick 13. Then maybe Melksham. all before JMP. But Rendell will obviously get the best available and he'd know more than us.

I'm a bit worried about getting JMP just because he is smart. We dont need another VB (smart, nice guy with good leadership) at pick 13. That type of player would be good in 2nd round (although JMP probably wont last until then), but his ability on the field doesnt seem as great as his ability off the ground.

 

[lunacy]

We wont take Lucas in my opinion becasue he was one of the names that was mentioned to me that they were looking at 13.

So that means we wont take JMP either

 

[FAITH]

Faith, which of these guys (Scully, Trengove, Martin, Morabito, Cunnington, Rohan, Jetta, Butcher, Lucas, Talia, Melksham, Carlisle, Black, Sheppard & Tapscott), wouldn't you take at pick 13 ahead of Bartlett or McMillan-Pittard.

Scully/Trng/Martin clearly best.
Moraib next best clearly.
Cunngt/Rohan/Jetta next best clearly.
Butcher next.
Talia next.
Melksham next
These players we have no chance in my opinion at 13. forget them.

Lucas/Carlisle and Tapscott dont rate at 13. they are more in my opinion 15-20.

My preference would be:
1.Sheppard;
2.Black;
3.Moore.
4.JMP;
5.Bartlett (Just cant see him being taken at 13 at this stage).

Thats it.

 

[FAITH]

Lucasa. I'd be very happy with either jetta/bartlett/lucas with pick 13. Then maybe Melksham. all before JMP. But Rendell will obviously get the best available and he'd know more than us.

I'm a bit worried about getting JMP just because he is smart. We dont need another VB (smart, nice guy with good leadership) at pick 13. That type of player would be good in 2nd round (although JMP probably wont last until then), but his ability on the field doesnt seem as great as his ability off the ground.

 

[FAITH]

So that means we wont take JMP either

I was never given JMP or Bartlett info freely. I had to seriously probe him before he said 'they are around our first pick'.
Whereas Lucas he actually told me that we are considering him at pick 13.
I never asked him about Lucas. He told me.