List changes.....prediction thread

[jackcass]

Note: this is done on a fantasy "if I was in charge basis"
Traded out: Seedsman, Karnezis, Kennedy, Scharenberg, Witts, Goldsack, McCaffer, Blair, Toovey, White, Frost

Traded In: Treloar, Aish, Kruezer, Dangerfield, Motlop, Carlisle

Rookie upgrade: Cox
Rookie delist: Gault, Armstrong

Delist: Young, Dwyer, Thomas and Keefe (to be re-rookied at start 2017)

That's a 1/3 of the list of 45 gone, not worried you're being overly conservative?

 

[spartan-magpie]

EFA

Excuse my ignorance, but what does efa mean?


Editors for accuracy. Lol. Sorry one of my many dumb moments.

 

[doodles98]

That's a 1/3 of the list of 45 gone, not worried you're being overly conservative?

I was being a bit conservative there wasn't I. So ok, lets throw Freeman, Oxley and Broomhead up for trade out too; and add Yarran, Dixon and Bennell to the traded ins.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Weird there's no retirements on the cards, shows how young we are.

you just named one lol

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Excuse my ignorance, but what does efa mean?


Edited for accuracy. Lol. Sorry one of my many dumb moments.

EFA

 

[jackcass]

Why Promote Gault. Done Nothing all Year. I have him Being De-Listed

Agree Dave, if he can't be retained as a rookie then he's likely gone.

Senior list: Young, Dwyer, Thomas, Keeffe.
Rookie list: Armstrong, Gault.

Young and Dwyer stiff but someone has to go and I think others like Seedsman, PK, and BK have greater longer term potential so should be retained.

Retain Gault if he can be kept as a rookie.

Promote Frost.

3x new senior list players and 1x rookie (if Gault gone) via Trade and draft.

Still have 2x international rookie or alternative sports spots and I'd hope we are searching far and wide to fill those.

Keeffe and Thomas added to the rookie list.

 

[jackcass]

you just named one lol

Only 29 so might be a bit premature to call it a retirement.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Why Promote Gault. Done Nothing all Year. I have him Being De-Listed

Dave give us your predictions. Not what you hope will happen but what you think will actually happen

Who will we delist/trade away
Who will we trade in.
How many draft picks will that leave us with.

For example
Do you think we will land Aish and Treloar
Do you think we will keep Scharenburg
Do you think we will trade Seedsman/Oxley Witts etc

 

[DaVe86]

I think the fact that karnezis, Dwyer and young could not get games in the second half of this year means they will be delisted or traded. I'm hoping to retain Dwyer on the rookie list maybe because he is great experience as a backup and serves out VFL team well.

I think Kennedy survives...just.

Seedsman and witts will be the trade bait to help get the treloar and aish deals over the line.

In: Treloar, Aish, frost (promotion)

Out: karnezis, keeffe, Thomas, young,Dwyer, Seedsman, witts

Rookie list - Gault and Armstrong removed, frost promoted.

I think we will also have to target a ruckman if we indeed trade witts.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Excuse my ignorance, but what does efa mean?


Editors for accuracy. Lol. Sorry one of my many dumb moments.

Apology accepted

 

[BringouttheGimp]

In borthwick

 

[TradeDraft]

In borthwick

Doubt we picking any VFL Magpies as we are Waisting those Spots on Keeffe and Thomas

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Doubt we picking any VFL Magpies as we are Waisting those Spots on Keeffe and Thomas

Grrrrrrr

 

[Yezeha]

So you think our 1st round pick, Seedsman, Karnezis, Scharenberg, and Kennedy is a good trade for Treloar and Aish with a couple of late picks thrown in for sweeteners? That's essentially 4x 1st round picks + seedsman.

Do you see any of these players becoming regulars in the seniors in the future? Scharenberg maybe but the longer he remains unsigned, the more likely he looks to leave. Seedsman has played one notably good game for his whole career. Kennedy will be going into his fourth year and he hasn't established himself in the senior team yet. Karnezis is stagnating badly.

 

[Sloth]

Crazy to trade Witts...what if Grundy goes down with a LTI?

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Smokey i dont think so

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Delisted:- Karnesis, Young, Thomas, Keefe, Dwyer

Traded out:- Scharenberg, White, Kennedy

Promoted:- Gault, Frost

Re-Rookied:- Cox

Traded in:- Treloar, Steve Johnson, Tom Bellchambers

3 live picks in draft including 1 first round pick and 2 second round Picks.

Smokey dont think so

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Crazy to trade Witts...what if Grundy goes down with a LTI?

Yes agree, totally find puzzling why dimish ruck stocks, assuming players want to stay, let them fight it out.
I can see when Kennedy rule (aka Sub rule) is disbanded that we play a solid twosome in ruck.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Do you see any of these players becoming regulars in the seniors in the future? Scharenberg maybe but the longer he remains unsigned, the more likely he looks to leave. Seedsman has played one notably good game for his whole career. Kennedy will be going into his fourth year and he hasn't established himself in the senior team yet. Karnezis is stagnating badly.

Scharenberg will be a star, oh, and he's staying. Forget everything else, he will stay and become top shelf for us.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

I was being a bit conservative there wasn't I. So ok, lets throw Freeman, Oxley and Broomhead up for trade out too; and add Yarran, Dixon and Bennell to the traded ins.

Ok, adding Yarran, thats a step too far

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Ok, im predicting when all else is done Seedsman will stay, in 2016 he'll play well and have a full preseason.
I'm sure if right
I'm equally sure i could be wrong.
But after all the teasing of talent, the misses etc somehow i still really like Seedsman, there ive said it, i like the seeds!

 

[Mukesh]

Did he? Damn. I don't know that. There goes that theory.

Jetta of the Sydney variety. They gonna need to clear the decks there to fit in a ruckman and maybe we could get him on the cheap.


Now that my Tarrant bubble is burst maybe we can bring in Reid and Jetta.

Now that could work...

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Im predicting they delist Keefe and Thomas
And some ther team selects Keefe before us and thomas we redraft as rookie

Went out on a limb there

 

[jackcass]

Do you see any of these players becoming regulars in the seniors in the future? Scharenberg maybe but the longer he remains unsigned, the more likely he looks to leave. Seedsman has played one notably good game for his whole career. Kennedy will be going into his fourth year and he hasn't established himself in the senior team yet. Karnezis is stagnating badly.

Yes I do, I think all 4 have the capacity to transition to regular senior performers. You've neatly avoided the question though.

 

[Yezeha]

Yes I do, I think all 4 have the capacity to transition to regular senior performers. You've neatly avoided the question though.

Okay. Here's your answer.

Of course I do. Why do you think I suggested it? Maybe if you want an answer, you shouldn't ask such a rhetorical sounding question.

Now, one for you. How do you think these players can become regulars in the seniors?