Long way off our best 22

[hoogs]

7 changes to have our best 22 running around fit and firing on the park.

Hayden McPharlin Dodd
Grover Johnson Mundy
Headland Bell Black
Schammer Pavlich Crowley
Murphy Tarrant Farmer

R: Sandilands, J.Carr, Hasleby

I: Peake, M.Carr, Browne, J.Longmuir

E: Solomon
Walker
McManus
Parker
Cook
Webster
Gilmore
Duffield
Thornton
Drum
Collard
Dunn
Campbell
Warnock

 

[DOCKER MAN]

Headland out of that side cook in it and if thorton is in form he is in it to

 

[YelloMit]

Yeah, pretty good side.

 

[Freo95]

Quit posting this $hit on every thread!

 

[Docker_Brat]

Only 10 points against Essendon, a Jeff Farmer away from victory against that mob.

 

[Freo95]

Only 10 points against Essendon, a Jeff Farmer away from victory against that mob.

Yep

 

[Vintage]

Anyway, back on topic. I would have thought Solomon would be in our best 22? And I'd really like to see Thornton back too.

If Murphy's not in the team now its pretty hard to say he's part of our best 22.

 

[dominguez]

And 3 of them are atleast a month away, no point crying over spilt milk.

Solomon would be a certainty even with a full list.

 

[Topdock65]

Do you think J Lo needs a good 4 week stint in the WAFL ??

I do , he is either not fit or got no confidence.

Needs to be told , go back and put 4 good performance together and then come back and show why you are signed to a long term deal...

Solly, I believe is not worth it... Saw him closely last couple of years whilst i was in Melb and this guy gives away more free`s and clangers than most people... he is slow and no way in the world with a full list would he be in our best 22...

6 clangers vrs Eagles ...
3 free`s against ...

Take them away from his game stats and what did he do ?

Rather play a young guy ...

 

[pistol17]

Do you think J Lo needs a good 4 week stint in the WAFL ??

I do , he is either not fit or got no confidence.

Needs to be told , go back and put 4 good performance together and then come back and show why you are signed to a long term deal...

Solly, I believe is not worth it... Saw him closely last couple of years whilst i was in Melb and this guy gives away more free`s and clangers than most people... he is slow and no way in the world with a full list would he be in our best 22...

6 clangers vrs Eagles ...
3 free`s against ...

Take them away from his game stats and what did he do ?

Rather play a young guy ...

Longy is no where near fit, that is the reason for his poor form

 

[Cameron_K]

Do you think J Lo needs a good 4 week stint in the WAFL ??

I do , he is either not fit or got no confidence.

Needs to be told , go back and put 4 good performance together and then come back and show why you are signed to a long term deal...

Solly, I believe is not worth it... Saw him closely last couple of years whilst i was in Melb and this guy gives away more free`s and clangers than most people... he is slow and no way in the world with a full list would he be in our best 22...

6 clangers vrs Eagles ...
3 free`s against ...

Take them away from his game stats and what did he do ?

Rather play a young guy ...

J-los problem is his knees are basically gone, how would playing him in the WAFL help that??

It's basically he plays for Freo or he rests its as simple as that.

 

[Topdock65]

J-los problem is his knees are basically gone, how would playing him in the WAFL help that??

It's basically he plays for Freo or he rests its as simple as that.

Then its quite easy, he is out of side until he is fit... the output he is producing at moment is not worth him being in the side.

Bring in Campbell or Warnock...

 

[Cameron_K]

Then its quite easy, he is out of side until he is fit... the output he is producing at moment is not worth him being in the side.

Bring in Campbell or Warnock...

That is what you don't seem to understand, he will NEVER be at full fitness. The club is going to have to manage him his whole career. It could be another Clem

 

[Topdock65]

That is what you don't seem to understand, he will NEVER be at full fitness. The club is going to have to manage him his whole career. It could be another Clem

I understand about his knee, But whats the point in playing him?... his form or knee are causing him to look terrible. He was pitiful on Sat night.

Surely a fit player is better than a player who has a dodgy knee and his form has suffered.

J-Lo is no longer a automatic selection in my view.

 

[Ripper]

I understand about his knee, But whats the point in playing him?... his form or knee are causing him to look terrible. He was pitiful on Sat night.

Surely a fit player is better than a player who has a dodgy knee and his form has suffered.

J-Lo is no longer a automatic selection in my view.

I agree , Any one who can chase has to be better value than Justin at the moment, and I can't see how Warnock could be worse.

 

[Cameron_K]

I understand about his knee, But whats the point in playing him?... his form or knee are causing him to look terrible. He was pitiful on Sat night.

Surely a fit player is better than a player who has a dodgy knee and his form has suffered.

J-Lo is no longer a automatic selection in my view.

I totally agree with what your saying don't get me wrong, I would like to see Warnock given a go. The difference is J-Lo in the WAFL will do him no good, if he is left out he needs to rest.