Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Melbourne v Collingwood

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Hoddle Street is a bottleneck like Thermopylae. Once it is blocked, one might as well sleep under the car. Last Monday, the traffic was at a standstill. Stuff this, I thought to myself. A Commodore stalled to my left so I jumped lanes and pulled into the Shell petrol station. Brazenly, I bought a packet of chips – that’s the equivalent of having a McShit. Rather than returning to my car, it was time for a stroll. Ahead of me loomed the Wolf’s Lair itself – Victoria Park.

Norm Smith once said that until you had beaten Collingwood at this hallowed ground, you could not call yourself a footballer. The same principle applied to spectators: unless you had braved the mob at Victoria Park, you had yet to earn your stripes. Stuff Moorabbin: the entire ground was an “Animal Enclosure”. And is there a more evocative phrase in the universe than “the ghosts of Victoria Park?” It brings to mind Leeter and Albert Collier, the Rose and Coventry brothers, the Pannams, that dirty little bugger Lou Richards and a host of other legends. And irrefutably, Victoria Park is a sacred site. By comparison Princes Park, the rat-hole of the Cheats, was always an odious experience even with the old Press Box in situ. Arden Street was Oil Drum Lane in everything but name; Windy Hill had a mystique of its own but still fell short of Victoria Park. To this day, Kardinia Park has always been the Handbaggery. I never made it to the Lake Oval, Glenferrie or Brunswick Street – but who cares? And one always “cleared the decks” before journeying to Victoria Park: its latrines were not for the faint-hearted. Under no circumstances was a “Number 2” ever contemplated.

As I walked into the ground, two games came to mind: a certain match in 1984 which I had attended with an old friend and her later-to-be-husband (a hotel room would have been a better option on their part – they saw little of the match). It was the return of Peter Moore to VP – how the mob had bayed for his blood. Our boom recruit, Michael Reynolds, kicked goals from long range but it availed us naught: a Lou Richards-like chimp wearing the number 22 cut us to shreds in the last quarter. My mind then turned to our last match at Victoria Park in 1992. Having had “the salty champagne” poured over his head as he sat on the bench, Jako returned to the field of battle to vanquish the Maggies. I will never forget the elation of that hour as I later walked up Johnston Street – as the Romans would say, it was an Eternal Victory. Its aurora is with me still.

By now it was late afternoon. Twilight was enveloping the ground. As I walked through the terraces of Victoria Park, musing on glory and transience, I was not alone. A man was sitting in one of the rows ahead of me. Even at that distance, he was ursine. I strode up hesitantly and said hello. He slowly turned around and stared. It was Murray Weideman, the venerable Captain of the 1958 Premiership side.

“How are you going Biff?” he rumbled. In awe, I mumbled back a reply. I had not seen Murray for some time. Alas, he had aged frightfully – now he was the Lion in Winter. Even so, his frame still testified to the magnificent specimen he once had been. We exchanged pleasantries and I sat down.

“So why are you here, Murray?” I ventured. “Shouldn’t you be over at the Lexus Centre with Eddy? They make good coffee. It’s climate-controlled, too”

“What a silly bloody question!” he rasped. Silence befell us. The Collingwood enforcer was looking out over the oval but not at anything temporal.

“So Murray, the Maggies are playing your old adversaries – the Dees - next Monday.”

Ominously, the nearby streetlamps were switched on at that point.

“You know Biff,” he croaked at last, “I can see him still, both awake and in my dreams: that red headed bastard in the raincoat. How much grief he caused us! And now they are going to cast him in bronze at the G. Fifty Eight was nice but no real payback. We still owe him!”

I turned around to stare at the old players’ race, as if expecting Norm Smith to stride out with the legions of yore. The wind rattled an old chain but no ghosts were forthcoming.

“Murray, please hear me out,” I pleaded. “For me at least, Collingwood is the Great Enemy – simultaneously loathed and respected. The loss in Fifty Eight still resonates down the years, even to those among us who were not around at the time. It was just as much of a Bloodbath Grand Final as ‘45. It was your finest hour. If it were not for that third quarter, we would have won six in a row.”

The slightest of smiles came to his face. Me, I would have been damned proud of such an accomplishment. Were the annihilations of 55, 56 and 60 still in his soul, to say nothing of the endless home and away defeats? When it became clear that he was not going to respond, I piped up again.

“Murray, let me ask you a question please. I know that both sides played finals against each other in the late 80s – and the 1990 Grand Final should have been Melbourne v Collingwood (we stuffed up) - but some would say that the last game of consequence to occur between the two clubs was the 1964 Grand Final. That was eons ago. Does the fixture still matter?”

Murray nodded his head sagely. “Collingwood versus Melbourne is always important – it does not matter where they sit on the ladder. Same as Collingwood versus Carlton or Collingwood against Richmond. In the old days, I would say the same about Collingwood versus Fitzroy.”

“What about Essendon?” I asked.

“They’re just big. They’re not special.”

“Hawthorn?”

“Uppity newcomers.”

“Geelong?”

“Forget the 1953 premiership,” he said huskily. “Lou Richard’s claim to fame is that he coined the word ‘Handbaggers’. They still haven’t won more premierships than Fitzroy.”

“What about St Kilda? They are a foundation club.”

He snorted and returned his gaze to the setting sun.

“Point taken,” I replied at last. “But do you think the glory days will return, when the Melbourne Football Club slugs out September with the Black and White?”

“Well we’re already waiting for you. Tell your boys to stop being shit. I never thought that a club once coached by Checker Hughes and Smithy would ever be accused of playing bruise-free football – but there you go. Perhaps they should revert to being called the ****ing Fuschias.”

I smiled. Far from being extinguished, the old fire burnt on. Our talk died away with the light. As darkness overwhelmed Victoria Park, I could have sworn that I saw thirty six ghostly figures, half Collingwood, the rest being Melbourne, playing out a home and away game as if it was 1910. Was our defender Joe Pearce among them, the man who died on the shores of Gallipoli? Perhaps it was all in my mind – ashes to dust and then nothing. It was time to depart. I bade farewell to Murray Weideman - everlastingly, the Captain of Collingwood - and took my leave. By the time I returned to my car, the congestion had cleared. Frost was in the air but I was toasty warm.

Dees by one point – from the worst tipper on the Board.

Biffinator.
 
Brilliant. This is where having read The Red Fox comes in handy, but my historical knowledge is nowhere near as good.
We used to be a good club once. Maybe the statue will bring some happier times. Or maybe the coach/players need to get it done.
We continue the wait. Glass half full.
 
Beautiful post Biff.
 
Brilliant, but my superstitious side wishes you had tipped against us!
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Great post & my sentiments exactly, with great rivalry comes great respect.

Almost every Melbourne club claims their greatest rival as the pies & we're often forgotten amongst that list.

Find me a bigger reason then them being the only thing between us & 6 premierships in a row & clearly the undisputed best team ever.
 
Oh No Biff! dont tip melbourne! you get it wrong every week!

gonna load up on the pies this week..

Comrade BS and others.

In light of my deplorable record as a tipper - at work, the rugby people are carving me up in the AFL competition - I am more than happy to change my selection to 'Collingwood by 80 points' if that will ease your misgivings.
 
A genuine thanks for the read Biff!! That 58' grand final is the reason my old man is a Collingwood and not a Dees supporter and why i'm posting over on the Pies Board and not here (lucky you guys :p). The Melbourne clash has been a great game in recent years. In round 2 last year I left the pub thinking that is the luckiest I have seen us to escape with a victory.

It should be a great game on Monday. Alot of Pies fans see this game as a real danger game for us. Melbourne has really troubled Collingwood in recent years and our outs with Swan and Thomas will test the depth of our midfield against what is an up and coming midfield unit of Melbournes. Moloney and Ball in the guts will be a great head to head match up too. I just wonder at the Dees quality up forward and how they will go against our defense which has been very solid this year. Although Malthouse in his members message made special mention and concern about Melbournes ability to convert once inside 50 so what do I know. Anyway best of luck guys - just not out on the field come Monday - should be a cracker of a game.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Melbourne v Collingwood

Melbourne
B: Daniel Nicholson, James Frawley, Joel Macdonald
HB: Cale Morton, Jared Rivers, James Strauss
C: Tom Scully, Brent Moloney, Liam Jurrah
HF: Jeremy Howe, Jack Watts, Jordan Gysberts
F: Jamie Bennell, Colin Sylvia, Brad Green
Foll: Stefan Martin, Jack Trengove, Jordie McKenzie
I/C: Clint Bartram, Matthew Bate, Nathan Jones, Ricky Petterd, Neville Jetta, Max Gawn, Michael Evans
In: Clint Bartram, Matthew Bate, Ricky Petterd

Collingwood
B: Leon Davis, Ben Reid, Heritier O'Brien
HB: Alan Toovey, Nick Maxwell, Heath Shaw
C: Tyson Goldsack, Steele Sidebottom, Sharrod Wellingham
HF: Chris Tarrant, Chris Dawes, Andrew Krakouer
F: Alan Didak, Travis Cloke, Leigh Brown
Foll: Cameron Wood, Scott Pendlebury, Luke Ball

I/C: Brad Dick, John McCarthy, Luke Rounds, Jarryd Blair, Simon Buckley, Tom Young, Alex Fasolo
In: Brad Dick, Luke Rounds, Jarryd Blair, Simon Buckley, Tom Young, Alex Fasolo
Out: Dane Swan (Soreness), Dale Thomas (Suspension), Dayne Beams (Foot)
New: Luke Rounds (Geelong Falcons), Tom Young (Wollondilly (NSW) / Sydney University), Alex Fasolo (East Fremantle)

Good that Petterd and Bartram are in the squad, really don't like seeing Matthew Bate's name there though.

Bartram, Jones, Gawn and Petterd on the pine for mine, it's a shame though because I would have liked to keep little Nev in there.
 
Thanks Biff. Love your writing mate :thumbsu:

We seem to have an edge in the midfield this time around but our delivery into the forward line will have to be impeccable if we are to win the chocolates. I picked the Dees last week and I will pick them again this week. Go Dees!
 
Hoddle Street is a bottleneck like Thermopylae. Once it is blocked, one might as well sleep under the car. Last Monday, the traffic was at a standstill. Stuff this, I thought to myself. A Commodore stalled to my left so I jumped lanes and pulled into the Shell petrol station. Brazenly, I bought a packet of chips – that’s the equivalent of having a McShit. Rather than returning to my car, it was time for a stroll. Ahead of me loomed the Wolf’s Lair itself – Victoria Park.

Norm Smith once said that until you had beaten Collingwood at this hallowed ground, you could not call yourself a footballer. The same principle applied to spectators: unless you had braved the mob at Victoria Park, you had yet to earn your stripes. Stuff Moorabbin: the entire ground was an “Animal Enclosure”. And is there a more evocative phrase in the universe than “the ghosts of Victoria Park?” It brings to mind Leeter and Albert Collier, the Rose and Coventry brothers, the Pannams, that dirty little bugger Lou Richards and a host of other legends. And irrefutably, Victoria Park is a sacred site. By comparison Princes Park, the rat-hole of the Cheats, was always an odious experience even with the old Press Box in situ. Arden Street was Oil Drum Lane in everything but name; Windy Hill had a mystique of its own but still fell short of Victoria Park. To this day, Kardinia Park has always been the Handbaggery. I never made it to the Lake Oval, Glenferrie or Brunswick Street – but who cares? And one always “cleared the decks” before journeying to Victoria Park: its latrines were not for the faint-hearted. Under no circumstances was a “Number 2” ever contemplated.

As I walked into the ground, two games came to mind: a certain match in 1984 which I had attended with an old friend and her later-to-be-husband (a hotel room would have been a better option on their part – they saw little of the match). It was the return of Peter Moore to VP – how the mob had bayed for his blood. Our boom recruit, Michael Reynolds, kicked goals from long range but it availed us naught: a Lou Richards-like chimp wearing the number 22 cut us to shreds in the last quarter. My mind then turned to our last match at Victoria Park in 1992. Having had “the salty champagne” poured over his head as he sat on the bench, Jako returned to the field of battle to vanquish the Maggies. I will never forget the elation of that hour as I later walked up Johnston Street – as the Romans would say, it was an Eternal Victory. Its aurora is with me still.

By now it was late afternoon. Twilight was enveloping the ground. As I walked through the terraces of Victoria Park, musing on glory and transience, I was not alone. A man was sitting in one of the rows ahead of me. Even at that distance, he was ursine. I strode up hesitantly and said hello. He slowly turned around and stared. It was Murray Weideman, the venerable Captain of the 1958 Premiership side.

“How are you going Biff?” he rumbled. In awe, I mumbled back a reply. I had not seen Murray for some time. Alas, he had aged frightfully – now he was the Lion in Winter. Even so, his frame still testified to the magnificent specimen he once had been. We exchanged pleasantries and I sat down.

“So why are you here, Murray?” I ventured. “Shouldn’t you be over at the Lexus Centre with Eddy? They make good coffee. It’s climate-controlled, too”

“What a silly bloody question!” he rasped. Silence befell us. The Collingwood enforcer was looking out over the oval but not at anything temporal.

“So Murray, the Maggies are playing your old adversaries – the Dees - next Monday.”

Ominously, the nearby streetlamps were switched on at that point.

“You know Biff,” he croaked at last, “I can see him still, both awake and in my dreams: that red headed bastard in the raincoat. How much grief he caused us! And now they are going to cast him in bronze at the G. Fifty Eight was nice but no real payback. We still owe him!”

I turned around to stare at the old players’ race, as if expecting Norm Smith to stride out with the legions of yore. The wind rattled an old chain but no ghosts were forthcoming.

“Murray, please hear me out,” I pleaded. “For me at least, Collingwood is the Great Enemy – simultaneously loathed and respected. The loss in Fifty Eight still resonates down the years, even to those among us who were not around at the time. It was just as much of a Bloodbath Grand Final as ‘45. It was your finest hour. If it were not for that third quarter, we would have won six in a row.”

The slightest of smiles came to his face. Me, I would have been damned proud of such an accomplishment. Were the annihilations of 55, 56 and 60 still in his soul, to say nothing of the endless home and away defeats? When it became clear that he was not going to respond, I piped up again.

“Murray, let me ask you a question please. I know that both sides played finals against each other in the late 80s – and the 1990 Grand Final should have been Melbourne v Collingwood (we stuffed up) - but some would say that the last game of consequence to occur between the two clubs was the 1964 Grand Final. That was eons ago. Does the fixture still matter?”

Murray nodded his head sagely. “Collingwood versus Melbourne is always important – it does not matter where they sit on the ladder. Same as Collingwood versus Carlton or Collingwood against Richmond. In the old days, I would say the same about Collingwood versus Fitzroy.”

“What about Essendon?” I asked.

“They’re just big. They’re not special.”

“Hawthorn?”

“Uppity newcomers.”

“Geelong?”

“Forget the 1953 premiership,” he said huskily. “Lou Richard’s claim to fame is that he coined the word ‘Handbaggers’. They still haven’t won more premierships than Fitzroy.”

“What about St Kilda? They are a foundation club.”

He snorted and returned his gaze to the setting sun.

“Point taken,” I replied at last. “But do you think the glory days will return, when the Melbourne Football Club slugs out September with the Black and White?”

“Well we’re already waiting for you. Tell your boys to stop being shit. I never thought that a club once coached by Checker Hughes and Smithy would ever be accused of playing bruise-free football – but there you go. Perhaps they should revert to being called the ****ing Fuschias.”

I smiled. Far from being extinguished, the old fire burnt on. Our talk died away with the light. As darkness overwhelmed Victoria Park, I could have sworn that I saw thirty six ghostly figures, half Collingwood, the rest being Melbourne, playing out a home and away game as if it was 1910. Was our defender Joe Pearce among them, the man who died on the shores of Gallipoli? Perhaps it was all in my mind – ashes to ashes, dust to dust. It was time to depart. I bade farewell to Murray Weideman - everlastingly, the Captain of Collingwood - and took my leave. By the time I returned to my car, the congestion had cleared. Frost was in the air but I was toasty warm.

Dees by one point – from the worst tipper on the Board.

Biffinator.

If you ever write a novel, please let me know. Your piece brought tears to my eyes, you bastard. Well done.:thumbsu:
 
Great read Biff, extremely well written.
 
Went to primary and high school with Murray's grandkid and was good mates with him :D.

I really do hope we play like last week and take it to the injury struck pies.
 
That is a quality Biff. Classical stuff. I thought Bucks skinfold tests may have got another guernsey this year but perhaps next year when he's in the hot seat. You've set some high standards.

You should seriously write a book with some of this stuff. It's gold!

I'm not too confident about this game. We have been playing much better 4 quarter footy the past 2 weeks and we'll need another strong performance to win on Monday.

PS. Shit I'm glad you guys pumped the pretty boys team last weekend. I eadgerly await your next game against the cheats. I'm expecting some bruises.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Fantastic read as always Biff!

I'll back your tip; one point loss... then a draw... a one point win seems the only logical conclusion to this series of games!!
 
Pies by 2 points

Great read Biff.

Agreed, so tired of Collingwood treating us like their little cousin. Can't wait until we're 1st and they're last.

I admire the **** out of them though, great organisation. Don't hate.
 
Fantastic read Biff. As a through and through black and white born in '59 I was very nearly a Demons fan. My mother bought me a Melbourne jumper before I had spoken more than a few words so I guess the Dees are pretty close to my heart. I actually got shivers down my spine reading your description of Vic Park. Almost as much as I used to do when I went there from boarding school as a kid every second saturday. Thanks for bringing it back to me and I wish your blokes well for the rest of the season... after monday!
 
Again Biff, awesome read.
Melb v Coll week turns my house weird... with the missus going for the Pies and me the Dees... usually quiet when the Pies win. But now we are taking my daughter to her first game of footy, it will probably be a bit different. (She has demons gear that her mum even bought her!)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Melbourne v Collingwood

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top