Melbourne's #5 draft pick

[Falchoon]

Re: Re: Melbourne's #5 draft pick

Originally posted by DonFan
Commentary at Melbourne game next year.

Nathan Brown handballs to Nathan Brown then back to Nathan Brown.

Mark Dwyer came from Fitzroy (he of 100 Brownlow votes in his first 5 games) to St Kilda to join Mark Dwyer (he of no hair) who then became Mick Dwyer and would eventually move to Fitzroy.

 

[tashibatts]

Originally posted by lamby29
Lamb is one of my favourite players and it would be sad to see him go, but I would much rather see him play 22 senior games at a different club, than play in the VFL while at Melbourne.

Go Lamby!!

Well just look at how much time Watt got this year, and he was playing at FB
(and if you really wanted to support him.. you could buy a Roo Badge with his picture on it)


Go Roos

 

[Fraser]

Add Heath Black to your midfeild and 2nd round pic for #5

 

[BT]

Originally posted by pavezj
Didn't Melbourne get rid or Woewodin last year becoz of salary cap pressures? and aren't they still paying a percentage of that? if so i don't see what's changed that could make them squeeze in an extra 400 thousand in the budget.

Yes to the first two questions.

What's changed is that Powell jumped ship & Neeta goes onto the veteran's list next season, plenty of room for quality.

I'd rather Stevens than Brown, we have plenty like (but not as good as) Wirrapunda.

Who else is out of contract? I haven't given this much thought until now.

In the long run I reckon we'd be better off keeping all of our picks & not look for shortcuts. However ND needs a top 4 spot to keep his job i'd say, so we could be chasing every ready-made player up for grabs. Can't blame him really.

 

[Wrath]

Going to be an interesting trade period coming up, Melbourne need some guns, Bullies need some guns, Blues need an army, and several other clubs like geelong look to suppliment their lists with some quality.

l hope clubs dont get irresponsible with their cheque books again, player payments are in a downtrend and should keep heading downwards.

Wrath

 

[dasler]

Stuff trading pick 5, I'd use it on Farren Ray from the Peel Thunder in the WAFL. I reckon the kid will be a superstar by the time he's twenty three.

79Vintage in a word NO.......

 

[bacon buster]

aaron henneman and cory mcgrath

 

[Yze_Magic]

there are some really weak trade offers here


if i see HEATH BLACK offered again for pick 5, i will cry

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by bacon buster
aaron henneman and cory mcgrath

funny fella!

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by brentoncowell
we will give ya andrew williams and leon davis for that 5th draft pick

terrible effort

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by tashibatts
Dylan Smith and Teague..

(Smith was taken at #6, he is obvious quality)

Go Roos

no ***'n way

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by Aussie Jones18
Heath Black and Lawrence....

lol

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by aesop
Trent Croad & Freo's 1st Round Pick to Melbourne for pick 5 & Steven Armstrong

hahahha

thats a shocker

have you seen trent croad play footy?

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by Grave Danger
If Nick Stevens wants to go back to Melbourne, we'll let you have him for that No. 5 pick and Scott Thompson.

tempting, but after weighing it up, ill say no

but only just

 

[Yze_Magic]

Re: Re: Melbourne's #5 draft pick

Originally posted by OldSchool
How about Brown for your number 5 selection and Daniel Bell or Nick Smith ?

finally, someone with a clue

id trade pick 5 and Smith for Nathan g brown

done deal

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by Fraser
Add Heath Black to your midfeild and 2nd round pic for #5

 

[Falchoon]

Posting to interrupt tragics 9 in a row, is that a record?

 

[BT]

G'day YM

Originally posted by Yze_Magic
finally, someone with a clue

id trade pick 5 and Smith for Nathan g brown

done deal

Rather Stevens but I don't wanna give up Thommo. I can see it happening though.

 

[Falchoon]

In truth we'd be less interested in pick 5 than say Jeff White.

Heath Black and a second rounder we'll throw in Lawrence.

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by Falchoon
In truth we'd be less interested in pick 5 than say Jeff White.

Heath Black and a second rounder we'll throw in Lawrence.

oh dear

please

no more heath black?

 

[The Passenger]

just wondering if Cox for pick 5 would intersest you guys???


Probably wouldn't accept it as if we gave Cox away, I'd wanna see us get a KPP either up forward or down back, not a draft pick. We don't have a need for high picks now, we're a club moving forward, not recuirting.

But i'm just trying to get an idea as to what Dean Cox's trade value would be....??

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by Black Thunder
just wondering if Cox for pick 5 would intersest you guys???


Probably wouldn't accept it as if we gave Cox away, I'd wanna see us get a KPP either up forward or down back, not a draft pick. We don't have a need for high picks now, we're a club moving forward, not recuirting.

But i'm just trying to get an idea as to what Dean Cox's trade value would be....??

we have White, Jolly and jamar, the last thing we need is a ruckman

however, i reckon you might get some interest from Saints fans

beware though, good chance you will be offered heath Black

 

[The Passenger]

Originally posted by Yze_Magic
we have White, Jolly and jamar, the last thing we need is a ruckman

however, i reckon you might get some interest from Saints fans

beware though, good chance you will be offered heath Black

yea yea i know Cox would interest Melbourne as you guy's have deep ruck stock's, but just in general, i'm trying to ascertain if Cox is worth the fifth draft pick?? if not, higher or lower??

 

[Fraser]

Yzzzzze, how about a straight swap.

Heath Black for Jeff White. Then you can change your name to Black_magic or Heath_Magic

 

[Broadbridge_20]

Pick 5 + Brad Green for Simon Goodwin and Matthew Bode.

If the Saints want White we'll throw in Robertson and a 2nd rounder and would expect Milne + Goddard or Ball in return.