Mike Sheahan's Top 50 (Current players)

[David_Hilley#19]

MIKE SHEAHAN’S TOP 50
1 - Jonathan Brown - Brisbane Lions
2 - Chris Judd - Carlton
3 - Dean Cox - West Coast
4 - Nick Riewoldt - St Kilda
5 - Gary Ablett - Geelong
6 - Daniel Kerr - West Coast
7 - Chad Cornes - Port Adelaide
8 - Matthew Pavlich - Fremantle
9 - Matthew Scarlett - Geelong
10 - Adam Goodes - Sydney
11 - Darren Glass - West Coast
12 - Brad Johnson - W Bulldogs
13 - Lance Franklin - Hawthorn
14 - Shaun Burgoyne - Port Adelaide
15 - Jimmy Bartel - Geelong
16 - Nick Dal Santo - St Kilda
17 - Scott Lucas - Essendon
18 - Luke Hodge - Hawthorn
19 - Brendan Fevola - Carlton
20 - Simon Black - Brisbane Lions
21 - Sam Mitchell - Hawthorn
22 - Brad Ottens - Geelong
23 - Nick Stevens - Carlton
24 - Joel Corey - Geelong
25 - Andrew McLeod - Adelaide
26 - Travis Cloke - Collingwood
27 - Kane Cornes - Port Adelaide
28 - Barry Hall - Sydney
29 - Brent Harvey - Kangaroos
30 - Cameron Mooney - Geelong
31 - Steve Johnson - Geelong
32 - Simon Goodwin - Adelaide
33 - Tadhg Kennelly - Sydney
34 - Brendon Lade - Port Adelaide
35 - Sam Fisher - St Kilda
36 - Robert Murphy - W Bulldogs
37 - Craig Bolton - Sydney
38 - Ben Rutten - Adelaide
39 - Paul Chapman - Geelong
40 - Ryan O’Keefe - Sydney
41 - Luke Power - Brisbane Lions
42 - Dale Thomas - Collingwood
43 _ Lindsay Gilbee - W Bulldogs
44 - Hamish McIntosh - Kangaroos
45 - Nathan Bock - Adelaide
46 - Jamie Charman - Brisbane Lions
47 - Leigh Montagna - St Kilda
48 - Campbell Brown - Hawthorn
49 - Scott Pendlebury - Collingwood
50 - Brett Deledio - Richmond

Very surprised not to see Lloyd in there. I would put him ahead of at least 15 - 20 people.
Some people were very lucky to make it.

 

[Charliebrow 16]

This list is ridiculous, as well as Lloyd not being in there, where is Fletcher? Richo? There are way to many mistakes in this list but hey it's his opinion right?

But in saying that I think Sheahan may have a had a few too many to drink when he composed this list. Complete Rubbish.

 

[horj89]

That is a rubbish list.

Lloyd still easily top 30. Fletcher still top 50.

 

[BomberAce7]

MIKE SHEAHAN’S TOP 50
1 - Jonathan Brown - Brisbane Lions
2 - Chris Judd - Carlton
3 - Dean Cox - West Coast
4 - Nick Riewoldt - St Kilda
5 - Gary Ablett - Geelong
6 - Daniel Kerr - West Coast
7 - Chad Cornes - Port Adelaide
8 - Matthew Pavlich - Fremantle
9 - Matthew Scarlett - Geelong
10 - Adam Goodes - Sydney
11 - Darren Glass - West Coast
12 - Brad Johnson - W Bulldogs
13 - Lance Franklin - Hawthorn
14 - Shaun Burgoyne - Port Adelaide
15 - Jimmy Bartel - Geelong
16 - Nick Dal Santo - St Kilda
17 - Scott Lucas - Essendon
18 - Luke Hodge - Hawthorn
19 - Brendan Fevola - Carlton
20 - Simon Black - Brisbane Lions
21 - Sam Mitchell - Hawthorn
22 - Brad Ottens - Geelong
23 - Nick Stevens - Carlton
24 - Joel Corey - Geelong
25 - Andrew McLeod - Adelaide
26 - Travis Cloke - Collingwood
27 - Kane Cornes - Port Adelaide
28 - Barry Hall - Sydney
29 - Brent Harvey - Kangaroos
30 - Cameron Mooney - Geelong
31 - Steve Johnson - Geelong
32 - Simon Goodwin - Adelaide
33 - Tadhg Kennelly - Sydney
34 - Brendon Lade - Port Adelaide
35 - Sam Fisher - St Kilda
36 - Robert Murphy - W Bulldogs
37 - Craig Bolton - Sydney
38 - Ben Rutten - Adelaide
39 - Paul Chapman - Geelong
40 - Ryan O’Keefe - Sydney
41 - Luke Power - Brisbane Lions
42 - Dale Thomas - Collingwood
43 _ Lindsay Gilbee - W Bulldogs
44 - Hamish McIntosh - Kangaroos
45 - Nathan Bock - Adelaide
46 - Jamie Charman - Brisbane Lions
47 - Leigh Montagna - St Kilda
48 - Campbell Brown - Hawthorn
49 - Scott Pendlebury - Collingwood
50 - Brett Deledio - Richmond

Very surprised not to see Lloyd in there. I would put him ahead of at least 15 - 20 people.
Some people were very lucky to make it.

Mike had Barry Hall at number 1 12 months ago! He's now at #28. I dont disagree with the top 10 though. Does Brendon Fevola deserve to be in the top 20?

 

[BP_Rocket_4]

Nathan Bock Top 50??
Brendan Fevola and Nick Stevens better than Kane Cornes??

Some very ordinary decisions made, throughout the list.
Mike Sheehan hates a bit of controversy. hates it

 

[retroparty]

Is this based on 50 best players from last year or the best players currently playing (Career wise)?

If it was the 50 best current players. Lloyd should be in the top 5.

 

[Bombers1234]

Is this based on 50 best players from last year or the best players currently playing (Career wise)?

If it was the 50 best current players. Lloyd should be in the top 5.

Just a tad overboard there don't u think?

 

[sens]

How is robert murphy at 36 and Lloyds not there?

 

[Darealrath]

Is this based on 50 best players from last year or the best players currently playing (Career wise)?

If it was the 50 best current players. Lloyd should be in the top 5.

It's his prediction of who will be the best 50 in 2008. I'm hoping his end of year one includes at least 4 bombers.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Dale Thomas on the list lost all credibility