Opinion Moore or Elliott

[Tarkyn_24]

And Jordy might be tracking the same way as well. It is funny how the guys with a lot of talent can never get on the park. Jordy was on the park less than Moore this year.

Tarkyn Lockyer also missed a year

 

[queensberryrules]

That the question was asked raises eyebrows as to intelligence.

On SM-G955F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Sea fog]

That the question was asked raises eyebrows as to intelligence.

On SM-G955F using BigFooty.com mobile app

They are hardly comparable in terms of shape etc. so I agree with that.

 

[Jelly Bean]

They are hardly comparable in terms of shape etc. so I agree with that.

Why? It is a very real question that list managers need to think through all the time. It doesn't matter how similar or different they are.

My view is Moore pretty clearly. Moore can be really effective at positions that we don't have much (any) depth - e.g. key defence, key forward, key forward with ruck. Elliott is good by position, but is best coming out of the goal square and frankly so are De Goey, Stephenson and WHE. He hasn't shown the flexibility to be able to play up the field too much yet.

If I had to choose, I'd choose Moore.

 

[Markfs]

both

 

[Somebody]

AFter this year Moore is now a proven finals star. Elliot looked good in the Geelong game but went missing vs GWS so the jury is still out on how well he can stand finals heat, which is the most important trait in a player unless you are happy to just make the 8.
So at this stage Moore, he was superb vs GWS.

 

[jathanas]

We have 3 other talented footballers on our list that can play the Elliot role. Moore on the other hand, we don't have as many riches.

I love Billy, but the question if asked today is a no-brainer. To give the thread context, the question was more valid last year.

 

[left at home]

Irrelevant now, still have both

 

[spartan-magpie]

Now we just need to sign up Grundy, Moore and DeGoaley.

 

[TradeDraft]

Irrelevant now, still have both

For Now

 

[Sea fog]

For Now

Think Moore will be the hardest to sell as Pickers is going to drive a hard bargain and if he plays well again, other clubs will offer big money. Jordy and Brodie will stay, but not sure about Darcy. Think that Brodie will have to knock a few years of his demands though.

 

[left at home]

For Now

That’s all that matters dave. Nothing lasts forever

 

[Sea fog]

That’s all that matters dave. Nothing lasts forever

Agree, but Lyon was talking one million for Moore this morning. There is no way we can pay him that, Jordy over one million and Grundy even more. Bulldogs etc. will offer Moore a lot.

 

[left at home]

Agree, but Lyon was talking one million for Moore this morning. There is no way we can pay him that, Jordy over one million and Grundy even more. Bulldogs etc. will offer Moore a lot.

Nah they will not get that with us. And Lyon hasn’t, like a lot of them got a clue.
They will stay for unders

 

[Sea fog]

Nah they will not get that with us. And Lyon hasn’t, like a lot of them got a clue.
They will stay for unders

You may be right but mid-career is when players like to maximise their earnings. Loyalty only goes so far. One of them may walk. I am tipping Moore the most likely. I know that Jordy gave up money to stay with us, he is very loyal.