List Mgmt. MSD 2025 Prospects and Discussion Thread.

[speedy]

Banch looks small enough to play hb. Seems a little too quick though.

 

[The Nostradamus]

I heard Coop was very lucky to be renewed this season. That said, I think his form warrants another shot at afl level. But with RHJ plus Konstanty also on the list, let's see who wants to work hard for that spot, we certainly don't need 5 small forwards plying their trade in the VFL.

RHJ should buy a lottery ticket
Should’ve been one of the delisted at years end

 

[speedy]

Can I just confirm, Trembath is on our VFL list but has only played one game right? If he is AFL quality why didn’t we play him? I am sorry but I don’t follow what’s going on here.

Your confusion does seem to be based on some very sound logic.

 

[Harris 10]

Banch/Trembath vs Bergman/Tucker

I know which ones I’m more excited about.

 

[Nylex]

2 years running!
I'm still a noob though

Brady Buttox Rawlings?

 

[My Left Foote]

Does anyone know what length contracts our 2 most recent Shinboners are on? I haven’t seen anyone mention it repeatedly in this thread.

 

[giantroo]

Does anyone know what length contracts our 2 most recent Shinboners are on? I haven’t seen anyone mention it in this thread.

6 months.

 

[My Left Foote]

6 months.

Thanks GR, now that you say it, I did see Nostra mention it 14 times.

 

[buttox]

Brady Buttox Rawlings?

Tbh that's what I thought we would pick. Not who I wanted.
Selwood and mccartin was my preference but I can get behind these two. Both seem decent.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Thanks GR, now that you say it I did see Nostra mention it 14 times.

14 times lol

 

[Friday Night Lights]

Zac Banch = The Olive

 

[king of the road]

My prediction for tonight is banch and Trembath

Good call.

 

[king of the road]

Hosie literally came into the worst situation possible for him. If he'd went to a good side that could move the ball he might still be on a list.

Na. Couldn’t play a team game or defend.

 

[tales129]

Na. Couldn’t play a team game or defend.

Also one of the biggest figjams to get a gig.

Absolute flog of the highest order

 

[My Left Foote]

14 times lol

hoping at least one of the picks we take is only a 6 month contract to give us more list flexibility

I’m assuming banch is only a 6 month contract?

6 month contract
See how he goes but at least we can cull easily if needed

Not sure about this

Still think we should’ve just taken May as the KPF

But again 6 month deal so easy to cull if needed

Odds that either make it past their 6 month deal?

The positive for them and others is both lads are only on 6 month contracts

Apologies Nostra it was only 5 times, my bad.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Apologies Nostra it was only 5 times, my bad.

That’s ok apology accepted

Just don’t do it again

We want facts here

 

[Rod Stroker]

No Harley Reid?

Schnoz. Get. Rid. Of.

 

[DesertRoo]

No Harley Reid?

Schnoz. Get. Rid. Of.

lol,
They’re not sure if Trembath best position is forward or back, what’s the bet he ends up playing midfield and bends a few players in half

 

[The Talent Scout]

He’s the Glen McGrath of NMBF.

Once he gets his man (or even worse doesn’t get his man) he’ll keep peppering off stump, over and over and over and ****ing over…

Yep, line & length!

 

[chubbspeterson]

Tbh that's what I thought we would pick. Not who I wanted.
Selwood and mccartin was my preference but I can get behind these two. Both seem decent.

Interesting that McCartin didn't get drafted after all the publicity on Midweek Tackle a while back.

 

[Midas]

Say it again, if Banch is a better option at HF than Will Phillips would be I’ll eat my hat.

A complete waste of a pick when we have glaring deficiencies in ball use at half back and with big bodied midfielders.


The biggest success stories from these drafts are players that are mature, strong and generally play in the midfield but are versatile enough to move around … happy to be proven wrong but really not a fan of these picks.

 

[DuckYeah]

Im not one to look at someones stats but his stats are worse than Jordies and Banch is 22. Thursfield says “based on his vfl output he’d get a game” I call bullshit and he’s leaving me with a sour taste. Thursfield - another spud

 

[Kanga1996]

2 banch. 10 Trembath. Yawn

Nice get.

 

[north_lad]

People that have seen the draftees play: yeah these are pretty good picks happy with that, good luck boys

People who haven't: RAAAAAA NORTH GOT IT WRONG AGAIN FIRE THE WHOLE STAFF BLOW UP THE CLUB

Me: ...Jesus Christ

 

[buttox]

Interesting that McCartin didn't get drafted after all the publicity on Midweek Tackle a while back.

I have a mate who is a re Recruiter for Geelong. The word he used was head case.