NAB Final, do we tinker or keep the same?

[Menzel 2 Murphy]

suggestions?

 

[BlueBelle]

If Kennedy is fit then I would bring him in for the game.

 

[Menzel 2 Murphy]

If Kennedy is fit then I would bring him in for the game.

who goes out? not harts????

 

[BlueBelle]

who goes out? not harts????

Harts stays. I'd say Jackson.

 

[Rhys87]

Whitnall should go...

barely played him in the 3 games so far.

 

[Enso]

Harts stays. I'd say Jackson.

Agreed. Jackson for Kennedy. Nothing against Jackson, but the best move IMO.

 

[Mayesy_23]

Jackson for Kennedy. That should be it.

 

[Menzel 2 Murphy]

i think jackson will play just to give him "big match" experience

remember, we are still building

the real thing starts round one!

 

[marcmurphy3]

Kennedy in for Bower
Jackson in for Grigg

 

[BlueBelle]

Kennedy in for Bower
Jackson in for Grigg

I think we should persist with Bower.

 

[CattyBossDog]

Whitnall should go...

barely played him in the 3 games so far.

You don't drop the captain - period!

 

[NAVYGIRL]

Agree that we cant just drop him..... but I think he needs to do a lot of work and play like a deserving captain......

 

[Thrawn]

Play to win.

Even though it has no bearing on the H&A, it will give supporters confidence, maybe raise our membership numbers a little and put in some cash in the bank.

Better than losing.

but I think he needs to do a lot of work and play like a deserving captain...

Wait for the season proper before you start making such judgements. I think Pagan is easing him into it.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Kennedy in for Bower
Jackson in for Grigg

I concur. Can't be Kennedy for Jackson. We will be too top heavy.

 

[Badabing]

I think we should persist with Bower.

Agree. I liked what I saw of him tonight.

Go the fro!

Surely his nickname is Vinnie???

 

[CattyBossDog]

Can't be Kennedy for Jackson. We will be too top heavy.

At the Dome.
With the roof closed.
...and no wind.
...and hence with the ability to control the ball better.


Mate, I don't mind being a little top heavy indoors. If hoops was played outdoors it'd be all guards. Bring on the big boys I reckon. StKilda smashed the lions with a 'top heavy' team there.




Man, I hate using StKilda as a reason for anything but failure.

 

[HBF]

Keep the changes to a minimum. You'd have to bring Kennedy back if he was fit, and even though he played pretty well, Hartlett might just be the unlucky one to be omitted.

 

[Rhys87]

i didn't say drop.

just call it a rest..... because at the moment that's mainly what he is doing on the bench.

 

[blues4flag]

i think jackson will play just to give him "big match" experience

remember, we are still building

the real thing starts round one!

Would also want to give Kennedy some "big match" experience. Could be a bit top-heavy if we swap him for Jackson, but Harts played well enough to stay in the team next week and wouldn't want to replace Bower after only one game. Jackson for Kennedy would be best, it's not like one extra tall will be much of a problem given the extended bench.

 

[marcmurphy3]

I concur. Can't be Kennedy for Jackson. We will be too top heavy.

Thats what I thought. Kennedy has to come in for Bower or Harlett and I just thought that Harts deserves a game more after last nights performance.

 

[marcmurphy3]

Keep the changes to a minimum. You'd have to bring Kennedy back if he was fit, and even though he played pretty well, Hartlett might just be the unlucky one to be omitted.

Hartlett should play and Bower should go out.

 

[AndyWalkersGirl]

I was really impressed with Harts last night - his kicking and marking ability were pretty good, and he provides a good, agile target up in the forward half of the ground. Keep him in I say. And let the guy play up forward this year, he's still only 20, and I reckon he could give us a bit of grunt up there. With Waite down back, whitnall roaming, Kennedy and Hartlett interchanging off the bench.

Next week - Jackson out, Kennedy In.

One and Only change. Please Mr. Pagan

 

[Jeremias]

If fit, Kennedy must come in, probably for Jackson.

Bower is a chance to be dropped as well.

Those are the only 2 guys I would consider leaving out of the team.

 

[Andyt30]

Whitnall should go...

barely played him in the 3 games so far.

the only way lance will be out only if he;s injured
no way would ya drop ya captain
no Drop Kouta he was crap kept stuffing up with the ball