Recommitted Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera - two year extension

[Mostyn]

its going to be fascinating how either team gets it done if NAS is in fact going home to SA.

Who is expendable for Adelaide they would be ok with parting ways with? Josh Worral? Josh Rachelle?

What about Port Adelaide? Miles Bergman? Todd Marshall?

If it's the Crows, it's two firsts and a good player who's on the edge of the 22 - Berry, Pedlar, Edwards, Butts, etc.

The Crows aren't trading anyone in their core. No reason someone would leave, unless they want opportunity.

 

[jackag24]

Next 2x 1st rounders for starters, then depends on whether Saints interested in any of our tradeable players. Mainly picks though.

So 2 picks in the late teens/20s

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Rachele and Adelaides 1st round + Future 1st for NWM.

Who says no?

Rachele!

Has a long term contract.

 

[sydney_gws]

Could St Kilda let Nas live part time in Adelaide and play for them? I know it sounds silly but players get 12 weeks annual leave.
Why does he want to go home anyway?
Or is " going home" really mean something else, like other people wanting/ needing money off him.

 

[Mostyn]

Is it?
Are you a lawyer?
There is zero chance it is legal for someone like Nasiah to end up at West coast against their will.
Zero.

Employers require employees to relocate to continue their employment all the time. It's rough but not illegal.

That being said, there zero chance it happens

 

[SSSSSS]

Could St Kilda let Nas live part time in Adelaide and play for them? I know it sounds silly but players get 12 weeks annual leave.
Why does he want to go home anyway?
Or is " going home" really mean something else, like other people wanting/ needing money off him.

Saints can buy Huddo's helicopter from us.

 

[Mostyn]

His not going to put himself in the draft his management would know the chances of him getting to a sa club is 0% . A trade gets done or he stays on a short term contract

The outcome will be you guys accepting unders, no matter where he goes. It's ALWAYS the outcome when a player is out of contract.

 

[Mostyn]

Not like it’s easier for Adelaide to do a deal . 2 firsts is crap and I don’t think they will give up better players then Berry/Whitlock themselves.

Unless Saints can talk Soligo into moving I don’t see how it would be worthwhile

Two firsts and a player like Berry or Butts is perfectly appropriate for an uncontracted player. Bailey Smith was only one first.

 

[Crouch]

Imo, he stays at Saints or goes to Port.

But if and i mean IF he chooses the Crows;

Two firsts + Butts/Taylor/Berry/Bond would likely be the offer. All are either in the 22 or unlucky to miss out and all are Victorians.

 

[Mostyn]

Three firsts and one of Berry or Taylor with maybe a future second coming back.

More than any player in history??

Feels too much.

 

[1990crow]

More than any player in history??

Feels too much.

Maybe. It's not far off Jeremy Cameron deal.

 

[Elixuh]

Has a big profile trade ever involved a good player from the side gaining the player?

It’s usually picks and fringe types isn’t it.

 

[Mostyn]

So 2 picks in the late teens/20s

One certainly would be.

That's what we have, same as Geelong only having a late first for Bailey Smith. We're offering the best assets available to us.

 

[Mostyn]

Maybe. It's not far off Jeremy Cameron deal.

That deal was a first round and two pick upgrades.

 

[Bushy70]

Could St Kilda let Nas live part time in Adelaide and play for them? I know it sounds silly but players get 12 weeks annual leave.
Why does he want to go home anyway?
Or is " going home" really mean something else, like other people wanting/ needing money off him.

.... Or maybe we should just relocate to Adelaide and he can be close to family AND stay a Saint...

 

[1990crow]

That deal was a first round and two pick upgrades.

Looks like it was 3 firsts with a second coming back in reality.
Not far off what I said.

Plus he's younger.

 

[Cosmicwinduptoy24]

When a big name player leaves it's nearly always to chase success which is why when they nominate their home state they pick the club in the better position 9 times out of 10. Big name players get offered similar money across clubs so the contending team is more attractive. Fringe players chase the money. FA is a bit different but even with that, the big name ones usually end up at a contending team. It's the nature of the beast.

The Crows have always been the logical choice and the longer the season goes the more attractive they've looked. Adelaide is tiny.. if he wants to hang out with his Port mates, hell even possibly live with them, there's nothing stopping him doing that. I've always thought it would be the Crows but I guess time will tell.

Dawson
Rankine

Two recent examples of this not being the case in SA.

 

[Mostyn]

Looks like it was 3 firsts with a second coming back in reality.
Not far off what I said.

Plus he's younger.

It was 13, 15 and 20 for 32, 35 and Cameron.

 

[AFLOnline]

I think he is personally, more damaging & younger.

And just simply better

 

[jackag24]

And just simply better

This is debatable. Butters is better as a pure mid.

 

[The Blue Max]

This is debatable. Butters is better as a pure mid.

NWM reminds me of a young Mickey O. NWM won’t play midfield in a winning side - but when the chips are down, he’s a better X Factor than Butters.

 

[danielG]

NWM reminds me of a young Mickey O. NWM won’t play midfield in a winning side - but when the chips are down, he’s a better X Factor than Butters.

He’s Andrew McLeod V2..
He’s silk.. and clutch.. very fine player..
If the AFL ever want an equitable system NAS should only be able to I want a trade back home (SA) and Saints trade him for the best deal , whether it be crows or power.. Same with Reid, WCE might actually get a good deal if it was open to all Vic clubs.. but instead the lower clubs will always get shafted..

 

[Pure_Ownage]

His not going to put himself in the draft his management would know the chances of him getting to a sa club is 0% . A trade gets done or he stays on a short term contract

St kilda will not risk him going to the draft which is why they will take the unders deal. The reality is in the draft he can whack a huge price on his head and refuse to talk to clubs-we have seen this movie before. It would be very unusual if after requesting a trade he signed at the 11th hour-i think this is more you guys haven't got to the acceptance stage yet (which i can understand) but its unlikely that happens.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

He’s Andrew McLeod V2..
He’s silk.. and clutch.. very fine player..
If the AFL ever want an equitable system NAS should only be able to I want a trade back home (SA) and Saints trade him for the best deal , whether it be crows or power.. Same with Reid, WCE might actually get a good deal if it was open to all Vic clubs.. but instead the lower clubs will always get shafted..

That will never happen because the afl have no balls re the aflpa.

 

[ep2018]

Three way trade between crows, saints and eagles? Saints get pick 1, crows get NWM, eagles get Curtin?