Nathan Fyfe vs Jake Carlisle

[Tragic sainter]

The only people who would be thinking Carlisle are Essendon supporters.

Not true, I'd take Carlisle easily. A gun midfielder who can't kick, or a gun tall?

 

[benbanjo]

Oranges were the second ones listed, as was carlisle. Fyfe was clearly the apples

I'll show myself out...

haha,
i hate watching freo play so try not to watch too much, fyfe is a gun, watch a air bit of the bombers and Carlisle is a super player!! our needs probably fyfe though

 

[Fireballs]

Not true, I'd take Carlisle easily. A gun midfielder who can't kick, or a gun tall?

His kicking is much improved thankfully.

 

[Wurundjeri]

Fife

 

[Power Raid]

Carlile will be a great KPP but Fyfe is a better player today

 

[Bailey01]

Nathan Fyfe. Jake Carlisle is too inconsistent and is definitely not the most promising key defender, Daniel Talia is.

 

[Ambrosia]

Nathan Fyfe. Jake Carlisle is too inconsistent and is definitely not the most promising key defender, Daniel Talia is.

Carlisle and Talia too different as players to really compare. Talia offers very little rebound but is excellent at nullifying his opponent. In comparison Carlise offers good rebound but can leak goals.

Personally I'd take Carlisle over Talia because as has more development left in him and has a bit of x factor in him.

As far as Carlise V Fyfe goes it isn't a contest at this point in time in their careers.

 

[Bailey01]

Carlisle and Talia too different as players to really compare. Talia offers very little rebound but is excellent at nullifying his opponent. In comparison Carlise offers good rebound but can leak goals.

Personally I'd take Carlisle over Talia because as has more development left in him and has a bit of x factor in him.

As far as Carlise V Fyfe goes it isn't a contest at this point in time in their careers.

Yeah Talia's role is probably to nullify his opponent but I think as he continues to develop he will become better at rebounding in defence. Carlisle is definitely better at rebounding and becoming a "swingman".

 

[Upgrayedd]

In what context? would take Fyfe in an overhead contested situation, If we needed a midfielder or a forward

Would take Carlisle if i needed someone to kick straight

Fyfe every day of the week

 

[Jade]

Nathan Fyfe. Jake Carlisle is too inconsistent and is definitely not the most promising key defender, Daniel Talia is.

Carlisle > Talia in:

Contested Possessions, Marks, Contested Marks, Possessions, Disposal Efficiency, Rebound 50s....

And that's not to say Talia is a poor player - he's not. But your above quoted comment is rose tinted crap. Carlisle has thus far been a vastly better young KPD.

And as for the poll, Fyfe.

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Love how opinions change over a season, all the Bombers fans making outlandish declarations for Carlisle. No one would think twice in this comparison, Fyfe every day of the week, and twice on Sundays.

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Carlisle > Talia in:

Contested Possessions, Marks, Contested Marks, Possessions, Disposal Efficiency, Rebound 50s....

And that's not to say Talia is a poor player - he's not. But your above quoted comment is rose tinted crap. Carlisle has thus far been a vastly better young KPD.

If only a KPD main job wasn't to shut down an opponent. Jake Carlisle is a decent player but he's not a great Defender yet. The fear in his eyes when one out in the 50 was very amusing in the second half of the season. Don't think Talia has ever had to be moved off an opponent like Carlisle was with Waite and Josh Kennedy.

 

[The Prosecutor]

If only a KPD main job wasn't to shut down an opponent. Jake Carlisle is a decent player but he's not a great Defender yet. The fear in his eyes when one out in the 50 was very amusing in the second half of the season. Don't think Talia has ever had to be moved off an opponent like Carlisle was with Waite and Josh Kennedy.

When was Carlisle ever moved off Kennedy other than to go forward for the final quarter of our first match?

Considering Kennedy kicked a combined total of three goals in our two games, I hardly think Kennedy got on top of him at all.

 

[Ambrosia]

If only a KPD main job wasn't to shut down an opponent. Jake Carlisle is a decent player but he's not a great Defender yet. The fear in his eyes when one out in the 50 was very amusing in the second half of the season. Don't think Talia has ever had to be moved off an opponent like Carlisle was with Waite and Josh Kennedy.

This post is bullshit. Carlisle has never shown fear in one on one contests its the hard leading athletic forwards who trouble him like Buddy, Cameron and Waite.

 

[SJgun]

Fyfe