I'd just go Swan.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
(New) Player Comparison Thread
- Thread starter chrisknights
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
I'd just go Swan.
JDWCE
Norm Smith Medallist
Swan for me as well 
foley4brownlow
Team Captain
thanks for the opinions guys
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
- Nov 23, 2008
- 12,452
- 293
- AFL Club
- Essendon
It really depends. If O'Keefe can keep the form going, he'll be a handy pick up, but Franklin is a bit of a loose cannon. I think he has scored 100+ only once this season. 50/50.
Brennan V. Goodwin for me.
Last year, round 11-22 Brennan managed to average 95, clocking up a fee big scores along the way. As for Goodwin, didn't crack the 100 once. Look another year back, and Goodwin had a strong finish to the season.
Who should I play?
Hill vs Broughton
Otten vs Hartlett vs Robinson
Couple of tough ones there.
Hill vs Broughton
Otten vs Hartlett vs Robinson
Couple of tough ones there.
Franklin Vs Higgins for what? To Trade in or trade out?
If your talking trade in id definately go franklin definately wouldnt trade in higgins with his groin problems and injuries this season.
If you talking trade out then higgins for sure. Surely you couldnt be talking about trading out franklin you must have bigger issues than that in ur team
WhippingCupcakes
Team Captain
Ablett + Kornes or Bartel v Marc Murphy/Nick dal Santo?
These are upgrades.
These are upgrades.
For 6th midfielder: Coughlan or Muston
Current midfield is Ablett, Swan. Gibbs, J Selwood, Cogs, Rich (Hartlett, De Boer)
Getting Muston in this week and will be upgrading Rich to Bartel next week. Before last weeks game was planning to do Rich to Muston and then upgrade Hartlett next week but with Rich's big score on the weekend I'm going to keep him another week and do the Bartel upgrade.
So now looking at whether to downgrade Hartlett or Cogs to Muston. When I got Cogs was planning on keeping him as 6th mid. His dropping last week has made me a little worried about that now but you would think he'll come back and make more cash and score fairly well. Neither Hartlett ot Cogs have peaked but I still want to get Muston in and get Bartel when he drops. If I trade Cogs to Muston - Muston will need to be 6th back with Hartlett as good back up for the season. Plus I will make 60k more than the Hartlett trade. If I trade Hartlett then I will have the choice of Cogs or Muston as 6th back with the other as backup but will make less money.
Essentially:
Option 1 - Final midfield:
Ablett, Bartel, Swan, Gibbs, Selwood, Muston (Hartlett, DeBoer)
Option 2 - Final midfield:
Ablett, Bartel, Swan, Gibbs, Selwood, Coughlan (Muston, DeBoer)
Is Muston good enough to be 6th mid or is Cogs a better option (bearing in mind my other 5 mids are absolute premium guns)
Thoughts?
Current midfield is Ablett, Swan. Gibbs, J Selwood, Cogs, Rich (Hartlett, De Boer)
Getting Muston in this week and will be upgrading Rich to Bartel next week. Before last weeks game was planning to do Rich to Muston and then upgrade Hartlett next week but with Rich's big score on the weekend I'm going to keep him another week and do the Bartel upgrade.
So now looking at whether to downgrade Hartlett or Cogs to Muston. When I got Cogs was planning on keeping him as 6th mid. His dropping last week has made me a little worried about that now but you would think he'll come back and make more cash and score fairly well. Neither Hartlett ot Cogs have peaked but I still want to get Muston in and get Bartel when he drops. If I trade Cogs to Muston - Muston will need to be 6th back with Hartlett as good back up for the season. Plus I will make 60k more than the Hartlett trade. If I trade Hartlett then I will have the choice of Cogs or Muston as 6th back with the other as backup but will make less money.
Essentially:
Option 1 - Final midfield:
Ablett, Bartel, Swan, Gibbs, Selwood, Muston (Hartlett, DeBoer)
Option 2 - Final midfield:
Ablett, Bartel, Swan, Gibbs, Selwood, Coughlan (Muston, DeBoer)
Is Muston good enough to be 6th mid or is Cogs a better option (bearing in mind my other 5 mids are absolute premium guns)
Thoughts?
id prefer midfeild 2. having the choice of playing coughlan or muston. you could then make a decision based on who they are playing, what the conditions will be like and so on.
Cheers. I'm leaning towards that too. Wiouldn't have even considered option 2 if Cogs hadn't been dropped and then I started thinking about the extra 65k. May rethink if Cogs doesn't come back this week.
If T.Tuck comes back in (doubt it) I may trade Chad and pickup Mustard for Beams, if Tucky doesn't play I'll upgrade him to Bartel/Ablett/Swan and miss out on Muston.
Dalsantowhatastar
Senior List
Easy Question
Ablett or Bartel?
Ablett or Bartel?
What about Swan or Montagna Dalsanto?
Dalsantowhatastar
Senior List
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
you're a Collingwood supporter, shouldn't you be telling us?
With Hodge still stuck on the Bench, i really have to trade the Chad. Will bring in either Enright or Fischer
With Hodge still stuck on the Bench, i really have to trade the Chad. Will bring in either Enright or Fischer
iluvparis
Import Whisperer
- Apr 1, 2005
- 50,055
- 40,656
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Calgary Flames, Man Utd
Gia or ROK?
Both good choices, but with Hall and Micky O back i'd go (and did last week) ROK... Super consistent
Signd Sealed Saint
Club Legend
Picked Roughead from the start, he's an absolute spud. Worse than Buddy this bloke. Is he even a keeper?
Uhhh... no. At least Roughy has a bit of consistency in his game. Buddy has none whatsoever (In DT of course)
