Remove this Banner Ad

Night Grand Final?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Crowked
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Night Grand Final a good idea?

  • Yes

    Votes: 7 22.6%
  • No

    Votes: 24 77.4%

  • Total voters
    31
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Crowked

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Oct 14, 2004
Posts
7,287
Reaction score
7,473
Location
The other end of the foot bridge
AFL Club
Adelaide
Another one of big Ed's latest priorities. I wonder what his agenda is on this one. :rolleyes:

From the Age.

Magpie chief urges night grand final
By Caroline Wilson
February 18, 2005


The prospect of a night grand final moved a step closer to reality yesterday when Collingwood president Eddie McGuire thrust the debate back onto the AFL's agenda.

McGuire, whose employer, the Nine Network, is an AFL broadcast rights holder, confirmed he had put forward the proposal - and gained a relatively enthusiastic response - at yesterday's annual meeting of the league.

He told The Age: "I think it's something that's probably inevitable."

Although AFL chief executive Andrew Demetriou has said a night grand final would take place "over my dead body", the bid to reopen the debate was embraced by most clubs at yesterday's meeting, at which 13 of the 16 club presidents voted to expand the AFL commission by one to include a woman for the first time.

While only about half the clubs indicated significant support for a night grand final, the fact that the push has come this time from the clubs was notable.

McGuire is believed to have pointed to the success of the Australian Open tennis final, staged at night this year for the first time, and the National Rugby League's move to play its grand final on a Sunday night - a move that attracted significant prime-time ratings in Melbourne.

"It's always exciting at the end of the year when the annual ratings are released to see the grand final and footy at No. 1," McGuire said. "The added attraction of the extra money it could raise could see that money distributed among the clubs, which would see more tickets become available to the club members."

The strongest opposition to McGuire's proposal came from former VFL chief and Kangaroos president Allen Aylett.

He disputed that recent grand finals had lacked atmosphere because large parts of the crowd did not support either side.

The Bulldogs were also opposed to a night grand final.

Channel Ten sports chief David White confirmed he had informally raised the prospect of a night grand final with Demetriou, who had always rejected it.

"I think a grand final at night would rate higher," said White, whose network holds the rights to all AFL finals this year and next, "but whether or not that makes it a better commercial proposition I'm not sure.

"We would have to be careful not to jeopardise what has traditionally been a very successful all-day event."

The AFL will soon reopen negotiations for a new TV deal. Chairman Ron Evans yesterday conceded that the league's determination to increase its coverage in the tough but lucrative Sydney market could cost it money to clinch the deal.

The AFL Commission is aware that that a night grand final would earn the competition significantly more.

Last season the AFL staged two night preliminary finals in a controversial move that gave Brisbane 36 hours less to prepare for the grand final.

Demetriou admitted Brisbane went into the grand final at a disadvantage.




Anyway, night grand final a good idea?
 
I voted no, as I would to any attempt to move it from the MCG.

People from the country coming to see it would get home in time to milk the cows. Too late for kids etc etc. From an Adelaide based perspective, we can drive home after the GF and get home about 2 am or so on the Sunday morning without having to stay overnight Saturday in Melbourne.

The only people advocating it are TV moguls who know that they could generate $60,000 for a 30 second ad in prime time at night.

Personally I prefer GF's in the day where the quality of play is not likely to be affected by a greasy ball.

I hope it always stays as a Saturday afternoon final, and at the G.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

macca23 said:
I voted no, as I would to any attempt to move it from the MCG.

People from the country coming to see it would get home in time to milk the cows. Too late for kids etc etc. From an Adelaide based perspective, we can drive home after the GF and get home about 2 am or so on the Sunday morning without having to stay overnight Saturday in Melbourne.

The only people advocating it are TV moguls who know that they could generate $60,000 for a 30 second ad in prime time at night.

Personally I prefer GF's in the day where the quality of play is not likely to be affected by a greasy ball.

I hope it always stays as a Saturday afternoon final, and at the G.

put me in on that.
 
The AFL is corporate giant who is goal is to Make as much money as possible, to supposedly feed back to grass roots football The gap between the top and the bottom is ever expanding. It is for this reason I think it will happen But I don't want it to personally.
 
drakeyv2 said:
I doubt this will be of concern to us in the near future.


I voted no.

But never say it will not concern us as TV has one powerful voice in the entertainment world & you only have to look overseas for examples of how much the TV $ dominate decisions that are made by sporting leagues world wide.
 
noddy said:
I voted no.

But never say it will not concern us as TV has one powerful voice in the entertainment world & you only have to look overseas for examples of how much the TV $ dominate decisions that are made by sporting leagues world wide.

I meant I don't think Adelaide will be playing in a GF in the near future! :D
 
I am a fan of the concept. Night time provides a better spectacle and atmosphere.

I always enjoy night games better - either at the game or on TV.
 
**** said:
I am a fan of the concept. Night time provides a better spectacle and atmosphere.

I always enjoy night games better - either at the game or on TV.

Yeh I like night games better.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Day grand final for me. The only night grand final we should have is the one held in March.

I'm not that much of a traditionalist but there is something that just feels more right about a day grand final.

Plus there's no guarantee that a night grand final would be shown live into NSW and Queensland.
 
macca23 said:
I voted no, as I would to any attempt to move it from the MCG.

People from the country coming to see it would get home in time to milk the cows. Too late for kids etc etc. From an Adelaide based perspective, we can drive home after the GF and get home about 2 am or so on the Sunday morning without having to stay overnight Saturday in Melbourne.

The only people advocating it are TV moguls who know that they could generate $60,000 for a 30 second ad in prime time at night.

Personally I prefer GF's in the day where the quality of play is not likely to be affected by a greasy ball.

I hope it always stays as a Saturday afternoon final, and at the G.
Nail. Hammer. Head :)
 
macca23 said:
I voted no, as I would to any attempt to move it from the MCG.

People from the country coming to see it would get home in time to milk the cows. Too late for kids etc etc. From an Adelaide based perspective, we can drive home after the GF and get home about 2 am or so on the Sunday morning without having to stay overnight Saturday in Melbourne.

The only people advocating it are TV moguls who know that they could generate $60,000 for a 30 second ad in prime time at night.

Personally I prefer GF's in the day where the quality of play is not likely to be affected by a greasy ball.

I hope it always stays as a Saturday afternoon final, and at the G.
Agreed, a greasy football is a bit too flukey for mine.

Plus there is nothing like running amok in the streets of Melbourne after a Grand Final win before the natives have gone to bed.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

macca23 said:
The only people advocating it are TV moguls who know that they could generate $60,000 for a 30 second ad in prime time at night.

I agree with this. If it wasnt about money then why were the prelims on delayed coverage?

As to Eddie saying it? Well at least it makes a change from Sheedy. Eddie should have sat down and let a Channel 9 executive come out with the idea and then give it his support or not.
 
I don't like the idea - it's just to make the tv stations more money - does that really come back to the afl? haven't they already paid for the rights and the afl has banked that money?

As much as I love the NFL please do not turn our game into a tv dominated one like that!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom