Our historical record

[Kildonan]

• 
  Opponent Pl W L Draw Win% First Last
• Brisb Bears 15 9 6 0 60.0% 1987 1996
• University 14 8 6 0 57.1% 1908 1914
• Kangaroos 138 68 68 2 49.3% 1925 2004 *
  --------------------------------------------
• W Bulldogs 137 67 68 2 48.9% 1925 2004 *
• Hawthorn 139 66 72 1 47.5% 1925 2004 *
• Fremantle _13 _6 _7 0 46.2% 1995 2004 *
• West Cst _28 _12 15 1 42.9% 1987 2004 *
• Fitzroy Li 183 77 105 1 42.1% 1897 1996
• Port Adela 12 _5 _7 _0 41.7% 1997 2004 *
• Geelong C 194 78 116 0 40.2% 1897 2004
• Melbourne 192 75 116 1 39.1% 1897 2004
• Richmond 163 59 102 2 36.2% 1908 2004
• Sydney S 194 69 122 3 35.6% 1897 2004
• Adelaide C 23 _8 _14 1 34.8% 1991 2004 *
• Essendon 195 59 132 4 30.3% 1897 2004
• Brisb Lions 15 _4 _11 0 26.7% 1997 2004
• Collingwd 197 50 146 1 25.4% 1897 2004
• Carlton B 198 40 156 2 20.2% 1897 2004

We all know that our historical record is nothing to write home about, but with a few more good years we might actually start to put a dent in the huge deficit of wins our club has experienced over its history.

The asterisked clubs are those that we are likely to see a positive balance of wins against in the near future.

We are currently dead even with the Kangaroos

We are one game behind the Bulldogs and Freo

We are two games behind Port

We are three games behind West Coast Eagles

We are six games behind Adelaide and Hawthorn

If we can better than even the score with these teams over the next few years, we will have the better historical record of seven teams who are currently in the comp.

It will take a long time to even it out with many of the other clubs, but we are making hay while the sun shines eating away at their leads.

 

[evertonfc]

Future > Past

 

[Kildonan]

Future > Past

definitely

 

[Kildonan]

Record Against Each Team Updated 24/05/06

  Opponent      Pl  W   L D First Last Win% Difference
[COLOR="Red"]vs Bris Bears   15  9   6 0 1987 1996 60.0%   +3
vs University   14  8   6 0 1908 1914 57.1%   +2[/COLOR]
vs W Bulldogs  139 69  68 2 1925 2006 49.6%   +1
vs Kangaroos   140 69  69 2 1925 2005 49.3%   =
vs Fremantle    16  7   9 0 1995 2006 43.8%   -2
vs Port Adel    14  5   9 0 1997 2006 35.7%   -4
vs Hawthorn    140 67  72 1 1925 2005 47.9%   -5
vs West Coast   30 12  17 1 1987 2006 40.0%   -5
vs Adelaide     25  9  15 1 1991 2005 36.0%   -6
vs Bris Lions   18  6  12 0 1997 2006 33.3%   -6
[COLOR="red"]vs Fitzroy     183 77 105 1 1897 1996 42.1%   -28[/COLOR]
vs Melbourne   194 77 116 1 1897 2005 39.7%   -39
vs Richmond    166 62 102 2 1908 2006 37.3%   -40
vs Geelong     197 78 119 0 1897 2006 39.6%   -41
vs Sydney      196 70 123 3 1897 2005 35.7%   -53
vs Essendon    196 59 133 4 1897 2005 30.1%   -74
vs Collingwood 199 52 146 1 1897 2005 26.1%   -94
vs Carlton     200 42 156 2 1897 2006 21.0%   -114

 

[SpInNeR]

It is the essendons, carltons and collingwoods that reflect St.kilda real history, not a bunch of interstae teams that only just entered the comp.

 

[Kildonan]

Yes - we have a LONG way to go before we wipe the slate clean against these teams, starting with Melbourne, Richmond and Geelong.

But the foreseeable future sees a few opportunities to get the wood on a few teams. We have just pipped the Bulldogs and the match this weekend against the Kangas gives us the opportunity to get ahead of them too.

vs Fremantle (-2), vs Port Adel (-4), vs Hawthorn (-5), vs West Coast (-5), vs Adelaide (-6), vs Bris Lions (-6) might also be attainable within the next few years.

 

[Kildonan]

Record Against Each Team Updated 29/05/06

  Opponent      Pl  W   L D First Last Win% Difference
[COLOR="Red"]vs Bris Bears   15  9   6 0 1987 1996 60.0%   +3
vs University   14  8   6 0 1908 1914 57.1%   +2[/COLOR]
[B]vs W Bulldogs  139 69  68 2 1925 2006 49.6%   +1
vs Kangaroos   141 70  69 2 1925 2005 49.3%   +1[/B]
vs Fremantle    16  7   9 0 1995 2006 43.8%   -2
vs Port Adel    14  5   9 0 1997 2006 35.7%   -4
vs Hawthorn    140 67  72 1 1925 2005 47.9%   -5
vs West Coast   30 12  17 1 1987 2006 40.0%   -5
vs Adelaide     25  9  15 1 1991 2005 36.0%   -6
vs Bris Lions   18  6  12 0 1997 2006 33.3%   -6
[COLOR="red"]vs Fitzroy     183 77 105 1 1897 1996 42.1%   -28[/COLOR]
vs Melbourne   194 77 116 1 1897 2005 39.7%   -39
vs Richmond    166 62 102 2 1908 2006 37.3%   -40
vs Geelong     197 78 119 0 1897 2006 39.6%   -41
vs Sydney      196 70 123 3 1897 2005 35.7%   -53
vs Essendon    196 59 133 4 1897 2005 30.1%   -74
vs Collingwood 199 52 146 1 1897 2005 26.1%   -94
vs Carlton     200 42 156 2 1897 2006 21.0%   -114

 

[sainter]

I don't know about the rest of you but it makes me proud to support a club that has such a large and loyal supporter base in spite of those rather embarrassing records.