Pavlich or Riewoldt

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Both by far their teams most important players... Both amazing talents and are both playing in the most important position on the ground... (some may argue that but that's my opinion)

Riewoldt's kicking is inconsistant and Pavlich's innability to kick crucial goals are points against...

If i had to choose one id go with Pavlich for 2 reason's

1. Reliable in terms of being out on the park... Missed his 1st game in something like 150??? this year
2. Can play in almost any position as his A.A record shows.

Not taking anything away from Roo id love him at our club as well...

 

[Blueboys7]

I would take pavlich in a heartbeat just mainly due to his consistency, versatility and the fact that he carries freo. Do like roo tho and as the op said i would have him in my team also in a heart beat.

But pavlich would be great for carlton

 

[Dippers_Mullet]

Pavlich for us definately.

Could stick him at CHB if we wanted to.

 

[Topper]

Pav.

Has played in an absolute joke of a team for so long without losing interest. Respect!!!!

 

[jman_cool]

Yep Pav....not a bad poll..... as I don't think many people would know back either in their team.

 

[Burzum]

Pavlich.

If Pav played for one of the big Victorian teams he would be known as the best thing since Carey.

 

[Upgrayedd]

Pavlich, his record speaks for himself, He's carried a dud team on his shoulders for 4-5 years now, Constantly kicking 3-4 goals a game as a CHF (yes, unlike Fevola/Franklin/Bradshaw" he's winning the ball up in the wing still ,and kicking goals

4 time B&F
5 AA's
And hes still got a fair bit of his career to play out.

 

[BUSTER29]

Pavlich comfortably.Is more versatile and more consistent.To big a gap between reiwoldts best and worst,an on occasions his kicking at goal just isnt up to scratch.

 

[Stronzo]

Pavlich by a hell of a lot.

 

[Porch Chops]

pav easy his consistent and is a great marker

 

[HolyWars]

Gotta go for the Pavlova.

 

[Stenchiss]

Pavlich please.

People are always bagging him because he's missed those late set shots, but those were just misses at inopportunte moments and not 'choking' . . . he gets them into a lot of winning positions.

 

[celtic_pride]

Bah worst poll result ever ...

People so overrate Pavlich... I am sorry, but several times this year (and in the past) Riewoldt, has lifted and carried the St.Kilda team to victories on the back of his performances ... I just recall seeing Riewoldt take hawthorn apart a few weeks ago, and I've very rarely seen Pav lift and carry his side to many victories (this year anyway)

You could argue that talent-wise pavlich is ahead of Riewoldt (and even I'd debate that highly) but for sheer leadership and for performing when his team needs him the most, Riewoldt easily over Pavlich ...

 

[Colin D'Cops]

Pavlova

 

[cormick]

Bah worst poll result ever ...

People so overrate Pavlich... I am sorry, but several times this year (and in the past) Riewoldt, has lifted and carried the St.Kilda team to victories on the back of his performances ... I just recall seeing Riewoldt take hawthorn apart a few weeks ago, and I've very rarely seen Pav lift and carry his side to many victories (this year anyway)

You could argue that talent-wise pavlich is ahead of Riewoldt (and even I'd debate that highly) but for sheer leadership and for performing when his team needs him the most, Riewoldt easily over Pavlich ...

First time I agree with you!!!

 

[adii_7]

pavlich; nicks close tho