Pick our 5 draftees

[Ticktak]

After months and weeks of talking about who will we pick or who should we pick we are now less than 48 hours away.

Please post your final guesses and if you wish your final wish list. Just something fun to see who gets the closest.

I know there will be a few that can't help themselves but if you could refrain from comments it would be appreciated.

I'm not going to put a wish list but here is my final guess list.

10 - Schoenmakers
28 - Sibosado
44 - Rounds
60 - Dawson
72 - Lowden

 

[hendo8888]

Using Burgatron's Phantom draft as a guide
Here's how i'd like it to go

10 Jackson Trengove
28 Nick Suban
44 Casey Sibosado
60 Tom Rockliff
72 Charlie Sharples

how i think
10 Jackson Trengove
28 Matthew Broadbent
44 Casey Sibosado
60 Chris Hall
72 Ruckman (I'll say Tom Hill)

 

[lunacy]

Pick 10 Trengove
Pick 28 Nick Suban/Luke Shuey (would actually rather Shuey of the two).
Pick 44 Casey Sibosado
Pick 60 Zac Clarke
Pick 72 Luke Shiels

Rookie draft
Ben Bucovas
Glen Dawson
Charlie Sharples

Would be over the moon with the rookie picks but doubt all 3 would slide.

Ideally I'd hope Zac Clarke drops to rookie draft and take Sharples or Dawson with pick 60 (forwards), but unlikely given the opportunity for clubs to snag a ruckman with a late pick. Plus I can see Adelaide picking a ruckman.

I reckon Adelaide might pick up Shiels (underage) midfielder.

 

[AFC1990]

10. Schoenmakers - MR has not utterred his name, might tell you something
28. Hopefully a slider from the BF gaggle of top 16's, but I'll say Lisle.
44. Sibosado
60. Hislop
72. Jack Redden

Rookie draft - a ruckman, and two more KPP

 

[Vader]

10. Schoenmakers - MR has not utterred his name, might tell you something
28. Hopefully a slider from the BF gaggle of top 16's, but I'll say Lisle.
44. Sibosado
60. Hislop
72. Jack Redden

Rookie draft - a ruckman, and two more KPP

Safe bet that Freo will take Hislop. They've taken every other player Essendon have rejected for the last 5 years.

 

[DJ75]

What I'd like:
Pick 10 Trengove
Pick 28 Lisle
Pick 44 Mitch Robinson
Pick 60 Casey Sibosado
Pick 72 Tom Rockliff or Broadbent

What I think:
Pick 10 Davis
Pick 28 Casey Sibosado
Pick 44 Neville Jetta
Pick 60 Zac Clarke
Pick 72 Glen Dawson

Rookies:
Moss - Retained
Martin - Retained
Donnelly - Ireland
Sharples - dreaming I know
Bock Junior or as a REAL smokey Tom Bateman - the prototype ruckman for the future given the move to 4 boundary unpires
McAdam Junior (is he eligible?)


If the 'what I think' happened I would be bl@@dy stoked!!

 

[Jars458]

10 - Davis
28 - Cornelius
44 - Sibosado
60 - Ballyntyne
72 - Jarrded Redden

 

[magtrev]

Heh, I thought i was the only one leaning toward Schoenmakers after Rendell named every draftee but him >_>

 

[macca23]

Pure guesswork!!

1.Trengrove

2. Broadbent

3. Sibosado

4. Redden (Jack)

5. Bocovaz

 

[Untouchables]

Using Burgatron's Phantom draft as a guide
Here's how i'd like it to go

10 Jackson Trengove
28 Nick Suban
44 Casey Sibosado
60 Tom Rockliff
72 Charlie Sharples

how i think
10 Jackson Trengove
28 Matthew Broadbent
44 Casey Sibosado
60 Chris Hall
72 Ruckman (I'll say Tom Hill)

You Ideal draft and mine are very similar. Swap in Robinson for Suban and we are spot on.

 

[hendo8888]

You Ideal draft and mine are very similar. Swap in Robinson for Suban and we are spot on.

if i thought there was even a slight chance he'd still be available he'd be at 28 on my 'how i'd like' draft

 

[Campbell's Chunky]

Here is what I want:

10 Jackson Trengove
28 Jordan Lisle
44 Casey Sibosado
60 Tom Rockliff
72 Joel Tippett

Here's what I think will happen:

10. Trengove
28. Sibosado
44. Someone no ones ever heard of
60. Clarke
72. Someone no ones ever heard of

 

[cmndstab]

Here is what I want:

10 Jackson Trengove
28 Jordan Lisle
44 Casey Sibosado
60 Tom Rockliff
72 Joel Tippett

This draft pleases me. I am pleased by this draft.

 

[Macca19]

10 - Davis
28 - Schuey
44 - Cahill
60 - Dawson
72 - Tippett

 

[betterthanu]

Here is what I want:

10 Jackson Trengove
28 Jordan Lisle
44 Casey Sibosado
60 Tom Rockliff
72 Joel Tippett

Ied be very happy with that and ive never heard of Lisle

 

[akl0991]

10- Trengove (or Sidebottom if the kangaroos don't take him)
28- Cahill
44- Hall
60- Jarrad Redden
72- Charlie Sharples

Rookies:

1. James Boyd (well worth a punt in my opinion as he won the south adelaide league best and fairest and came runner up in the magarey medal at 19, also he is a tough in and under midfield player)

2. Ash Duncan

3. Another Young Ruckmen

 

[vlbl]

Pick 10 - Jackson Trengove

Pick 28 - James Strauss

Pick 44 - Casey Sibosado

Pick 60 - Glen Dawson/Ben Bucovaz

Pick 72 - Luke Thompson/Liam Shiels

Very doubtful this will actually eventuate, but i'm pretty confident we will take atleast 1 bottom ager either at ick 60 or 72. Only 9 hours to go guys.

 

[Deaneus!]

10 - Trengove
28 - Cornelius
44 - Clarke
60 - Sibosado
72 - Kinal

...a bit top heavy, but why not?

 

[hendo8888]

Using Burgatron's Phantom draft as a guide
Here's how i'd like it to go

10 Jackson Trengove
28 Nick Suban
44 Casey Sibosado
60 Tom Rockliff
72 Charlie Sharples

how i think
10 Jackson Trengove
28 Matthew Broadbent
44 Casey Sibosado
60 Chris Hall
72 Ruckman (I'll say Tom Hill)

so we didn't get any of the ones i wanted or thought we'd get
but we could still get 4 of them
Sibosado, Rockliff, Sharples and Hill
I would be very happy if we got even 1 of these in the Rookie draft, seems like amazing value to me

 

[cmndstab]

Hahahaha, nobody got more than one!

 

[ManInTheArena]

Hahahaha, nobody got more than one!

And it was only Davis

 

[Ticktak]

I already new I had NFI but how good is Rendell? He just plays things beautifully.

He is also just so good to listen to when interviewed.

 

[*PAF]

Pure guesswork!!

1.Trengrove

2. Broadbent

...

4. Redden (Jack)

...

Close macca, very close. Make that

Hartlett
Trengrove
Broadbent
Redden (Jarrad)

 

[macca23]

Close macca, very close. Make that

Hartlett
Trengrove
Broadbent
Redden (Jarrad)

Just a milliwhisker away and the wrong team for good measure!!

You'd have to be happy PAF.

I thought Port's first 3 draftees in particular were outstanding and the rest don't look too bad either.

Port had a great draft IMO.

 

[bus24]

Port had a great draft IMO.

Quite easily the best (considering what we know at this moment) IMO.

Can all change very quickly, though.