Power v Eagles

[Stifler's mom]

Who will win?

 

[walkers a legend]

eagles just

 

[The Night Shift]

Port @ home and in some form atm.....

 

[parrot]

Port should win this one. Port are an interesting team, because they don't have a lot of talent, but are a very even team, and are very well coached. Weagles still rely almost completely on Judd, and I doubt he's even 60% fit. Pretty sure Williams will know how to negate the Weagles mono-dimensional Judd-one-man-gameplan. Weagles also rely on the Subi home-town free kick factor and therefore struggle in tight away-from-Subi finals. Expecting a good game between 2 of the AFL's regional teams. Port by 20 points.

 

[Ted Ed Fred]

Weagles also rely on the Subi home-town free kick factor and therefore struggle in tight away-from-Subi finals.

Is that right?

How many home finals did we win last year compared to away, and how many home games have we won this year compared to away?

 

[DOCKER MAN]

Power Easily, would not surprise me if it is a blow out
WCE's defence won't match up on ports fowards

 

[kane249]

Port should win this one. Port are an interesting team, because they don't have a lot of talent, but are a very even team, and are very well coached. Weagles still rely almost completely on Judd, and I doubt he's even 60% fit. Pretty sure Williams will know how to negate the Weagles mono-dimensional Judd-one-man-gameplan. Weagles also rely on the Subi home-town free kick factor and therefore struggle in tight away-from-Subi finals. Expecting a good game between 2 of the AFL's regional teams. Port by 20 points.

Hey Parrot Eagles have won 72% (5/7) of their game in the last 2 years when Judd isn't playing, guess that one man Judd-centric gameplan is really getting exposed

 

[Topdock65]

Port should win, cant see how the Eagles have improved since the 90 point beating five weeks ago...

Mark Williams is a very good coach and Port will win quite easy at Home.

 

[parrot]

Hey Parrot Eagles have won 72% (5/7) of their game in the last 2 years when Judd isn't playing, guess that one man Judd-centric gameplan is really getting exposed

You miss an important point of course - Judd has been playing with only 40% fitness for most of this year. Whether he actually takes the field or not, he has still been injured which explains the dramatic tappering of the Weagles performances this year. If he left, you're barely a top-8 side.

 

[kane249]

You miss an important point of course - Judd has been playing with only 40% fitness for most of this year. Whether he actually takes the field or not, he has still been injured which explains the dramatic tappering of the Weagles performances this year. If he left, you're barely a top-8 side.

See above parrot, 72% win ratio without Judd

Now your maths may be bad but a 72% win ratio would mean you get in the top 8 and would have you on the verge of the top 4

But I can see what you would find that hard to understand since Carlton can't seem to get above that 25% win mark anymore

 

[Drummond]

Eagles by 3 goals.

 

[Jono B]

Port should win this one. Port are an interesting team, because they don't have a lot of talent, but are a very even team, and are very well coached. Weagles still rely almost completely on Judd, and I doubt he's even 60% fit. Pretty sure Williams will know how to negate the Weagles mono-dimensional Judd-one-man-gameplan. Weagles also rely on the Subi home-town free kick factor and therefore struggle in tight away-from-Subi finals. Expecting a good game between 2 of the AFL's regional teams. Port by 20 points.

That is absolute rubbish.

 

[parrot]

See above parrot, 72% win ratio without Judd

Now your maths may be bad but a 72% win ratio would mean you get in the top 8 and would have you on the verge of the top 4

But I can see what you would find that hard to understand since Carlton can't seem to get above that 25% win mark anymore

I did warn you. Playing injured or not playing at all, it doesn't matter. A very simple point that you couldn't grasp. No matter, the scoreline told the story.

 

[kane249]

I did warn you. Playing injured or not playing at all, it doesn't matter. A very simple point that you couldn't grasp. No matter, the scoreline told the story.

So without Judd we win 72% of the time, can you explain how this supports your no Judd no Eagles theory?

 

[parrot]

So without Judd we win 72% of the time, can you explain how this supports your no Judd no Eagles theory?

Hilarious. I feel like I'm talking to a Collingwood supporter. You're no Rocket Scientist.

 

[kane249]

Hilarious. I feel like I'm talking to a Collingwood supporter. You're no Rocket Scientist.

Still waiting for your explanation parrot and all im getting is diversion tactics and personal insults.

Your theory, the eagles are a one man team and can only win because they rely on their Juddcentric game plan.
The proof, a 72% wining ratio without Judd

If your theory had any semblance of credibility the Eagles would have a 28% winning ratio or thereabouts without Judd. Clearly the stats don't back up your quarter-wit (i was going to say half-wit but that was being generous) theory.