Reiwoldt vs Pavlich

[Jimbo88]

Just wondering on everyones thoughts, the obvious candidates for this years AA Chf, cancelling out hall because he plays a different style, mor ff.

Being biased i'd choose reiwoldt.

 

[gdmclean]

Pavlich for his straighter kick at goal.

 

[toddy]

Pavlich for his straighter kick at goal.

Before he did his shoulder i wouldve rated Roo as one of the straightest kicks for goal, how things change. As for my choice tough one but ! am biased as a Qlder and a keen follower of St.Kilda (due to some family support for them) albeit being a lions man, so Reiwoldt by a nose!

 

[Neutral_observer]

Brown

 

[weagles_fan]

Brown

How about Miller "neutral" boy?

 

[Williams02]

How about Miller "neutral" boy?

HA HA Great call enjoyed that

 

[Neutral_observer]

How about Miller "neutral" boy?

Would take Miller ahead of that crybaby Riewoldt any day

 

[weagles_fan]

Would take Miller ahead of that crybaby Riewoldt any day

That's why Melbourne have been so successful isn't it?With a recruiting policy like that of course.

 

[Rhys87]

pavlich, not long ago i would have said riewoldt.

 

[goal sneak]

That's why Melbourne have been so successful isn't it?With a recruiting policy like that of course.

Riewoldy went pick 1.
Miller went pick 55.

Are you not the full quid?

 

[Mordecai]

This year Pavlich.

Overall Reiwoldt.

What is the goal-kicking accuracy of these two this year?

 

[Dandy_GO]

This year Pavlich.

Overall Reiwoldt.

What is the goal-kicking accuracy of these two this year?

Actually, both over their careers and over this year it's pretty hard to split them in that category.

Both have had 81 scoring shots this year, with Pav kicking 2 more goals than Riewoldt. Granted this doesn't take complete misses into account, but even then I'd expect it to be pretty close.

Having said this, I voted for Pavlich. Has dominated as a forward, midfielder and backman. Pure class.
Very hard to split the two though - both fantastic players.

 

[rgauci]

This is a very tough choice.

Pavlich just, because he can go on-ball and have such an impact.

 

[pafc4life]

Pavlich. Probably the best player in the AFL.

 

[KING-JAMES]

Pavlich this year but not overall. Anyone give Scott Lucas a chance at All Australian. 51 goals isnt bad, altough people call him a hog his a bloody good one.

 

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

plays against mnay opponents every week.

#1 for marks
# 2 for contested

 

[Patty#32]

I'd rather Riewoldt too...

 

[Kenny_01]

Pav. Does everything well, leads by example. Great leader overall really and always ends up playing on 2 players.

Also kicks the big goals.

 

[woodydrake]

I before e except after c