Richo vs Hall

[WatWouldCyrilDo]

With Richmond looking to clear out the list next year, Richoman may be out on his ass. So with both players available next year, IF you were in top 8 contention who would you choose?

Hall is younger at 32, seemingly physically fit but not so much mentally, and was playing some good footy this year.
Richo is older at 34, has been plagued by injuries this year but was in great form before that.

Me personally would not be able to go past Richoman. Both players are a gamble - Richo with his hammys etc, Hall with his brain; but if he can get his body right Richo seems like he would be better even with his age and he won't go around smackin blokes.

 

[Rosstickle]

I'd chose Richo man simply because he is my god.

 

[celtic_pride]

Bazza, even if only for the fact he's body appears to be in much better shape, Richo's had the better career though.

 

[brettman135]

i would take Hall