Autopsy Roast & Toast - Round 2 v Collingwood & changes for GWS Rd 3

[tigernsw]

What have we won, 27 of 35...? A few of these guys don’t know what it’s like to not win...And play like it...The three amigo’s all need to lift, and quick...

Less ping pong down at punt road. More tackling practice, running and ball handling

 

[Coach_Required]

Players with 1 tackle or less:

Broad 1
Markov 1
Rioli 1
Castagna 1
Lambert 1
Higgins 1
Vlastuin 1
Cotchin 1
Ellis 1
Short 1
Astbury 0
Riewoldt 0
Weller 0
Lynch 0
Martin 0
Edwards 0

16 players and a total of 10 tackles

LOL

 

[Aeons]

I agree, just saying it isnt 1 coach.

absolutely agree...to not change anything is piss poor...

 

[Roksman]

Gameplan had been debunked - not tonight - but towards the end of 2018.

Everyone needs to evolve but usually do it on their on terms, I think we've waited too long. Only round 2 so not the end of the world.

Having said that, tonight was more than that, we let them come at us and we thought we were too clever - paid the price.

Everyone knows who the passengers were and they will be in the VFL for a long time.

One more thing, that really reminded me of 2016 Richmond. Painful.

 

[parmy2balmey]

marathon not a sprint, got us down for another prelim

 

[Tigernator]

realistic chance of being 1-6 going into the hawks game

No surprises there with that draw we got, we will need to do some magic to win some of those.

 

[Makeshft_Mauler]

Unpopular opinion. Nankervis is is a poor rap ruck.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

wasnt that always the case, he just did heaps around the ground.

Sigh

i miss hammer

 

[Crumpet_avenger]

Someone at the club or here should rewatch the match and splice a compilation of missed frees to us that were paid to the Pies and send it to the AFL and ask for a please explain on consistency and interpretation.

Umps didn't cost us the game.
Lack of effort did

Umpire bashing is garbage. We were outplayed all night. Lucky to get late goals in q1 and q2 to make it look close.

Umpires had **** all to do with the result. Really need to move on from this

 

[Drofder]

Dave should never play on Mason Cox ever again. We are about the only club in the league that lets this spud dominate us. Some of its coaching and structure and a bewildering inability to block his obvious running channel, but it'd help if Dave wasn't giving him a 3m start all the time.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Also a roast:

The supporters who left early. Ffs we’ve been through much worse times than this. Grow some balls and back with the team til the end!

Though I can understand with how the trains are atm but still...

 

[biaseddustyfan]

realistic chance of being 1-6 going into the hawks game

i hope it's like 2014 where we needed to win the last 9 in a row to make finals. my heart could barely cope in the swans game

 

[fightingfury]

Where are those people who laughed at me about collingwoods talent pre season?
Worst feeling of I told you so ever

 

[Bojangles17]

Disappointing result beaten all over the ground incl umpires. First thing Dimma needs to address is the misplaced faith in 7/11 , huge questions over thAt pairs ability at the level
This is one area we have a depth of talent and those spots need to be turned over
Cal Moore needs an opportunity along with balta and jack Ross also to be blooded
Won’t lose a lot of sleep , Coll will soon be flag favs and we can hopefully work our way into the season to fight another day
Meanwhile refresh the side

 

[DustinsGuns]

Dave should never play on Mason Cox ever again. We are about the only club in the league that lets this spud dominate us. Some of its coaching and structure and a bewildering inability to block his obvious running channel, but it'd help if Dave wasn't giving him a 3m start all the time.

Not even astburys fault. The lack of ability for someone to stand in cox’s marking lane is from a set piece is astounding

 

[Barnzy]

Players with 1 tackle or less:

Broad 1
Markov 1
Rioli 1
Castagna 1
Lambert 1
Higgins 1
Vlastuin 1
Cotchin 1
Ellis 1
Short 1
Astbury 0
Riewoldt 0
Weller 0
Lynch 0
Martin 0
Edwards 0

16 players and a total of 10 tackles

LOL

It's hard to tackle when the opposition take a world record amount of marks.

Dimma got absolutely reamed. Starting with the selection then game plan.

 

[biaseddustyfan]

Where are those people who laughed at me about collingwoods talent pre season?
Worst feeling of I told you so ever

we have more talent we're just lazier and the umps hate us

 

[30YearsOfPain]

I actually thought Ellis played well for 3 quarters. He just sucked in the 4th.

He was certainly not the Lone Ranger in sucking

 

[Shazza_]

giants will flog us by 12 goals next week

 

[CholEstrol]

broad
vlaustin
edwards
grimes
short, lynch

dusty wtf. too much money?

 

[Stan Judkins]

Unpopular opinion. Nankervis is is a poor rap ruck.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Popular opinion from me!!!!
Not in the top 7-10 rucks for Hitouts, hitouts to advantage
Wow the amount of clear ball Grundy gave them had me stuffed
Nank good link man around the ground, but not centre, around the ground ruck contests MEH
Jack as our 2nd ruck, who the hell came up with that idea (genius)
Still the so called 3 amigos stunk it up (George, Butler, Rioli)

 

[NaturalDisaster]

It's hard to tackle when the opposition take a world record amount of marks.

Dimma got absolutely reamed. Starting with the selection then game plan.

Nothing to do with coaching.

Work rate was poor, simple.

 

[biaseddustyfan]

giants will flog us by 12 goals next week

gonna be there in my tigs puma suede

 

[Wacko23Jacko]

Too many outside players and not enough inside grunt!! We all called it... more ball winners less flankers!!!

With dusty playing outside since about September 2017 we can’t afford to carry passengers like Weller, Markov, Ellis in the same team.

Our smalls let us down tonight too, but it was lost in the middle!! Poor delivery into 50 and no stopping their run or spread.

Bring in Ross, bring in baker, he’ll bring in that hard nut from frankston in the VFL we threw a line too.

Sydney stack, Shai Bolton, both threw themselves at the contest well today.

 

[biaseddustyfan]

reckon there was about 14 centre clearances where they just hit it backwards to 4 free mids and then they pumped it forward from there

 

[Morro]

Will be without jack rance and grimes
Next week.

Time to blood the kids haha

We are in a bit of trouble against GWS