Preview Round 10 Changes v St Kilda

[Swiggy]

in
Darcy
out
Voss

Think emmett gets one more chance because Sturt not playing yesterday
Ras should come in but they wont drop JOM

 

[muzzington]

jeremysharpnewfullforward?

 

[Freomaniac]

Does Draper get looked at?
He’s not noticeably bad but he’s just not noticeable at all.

I’d like more drive out of defense. Wagner or Worner. Chapman plays second tall?

Definitely need to restructure positions in front half.

Out: Draper, Voss, Emmett
In: Darcy, Wagner, Erasmus

Sub - JOM
Jackson plays forward.
Walters back into front 6.
Erasmus plays JOM role.
Chapman plays second tall. Wagner helps Walker and Clark to rebound.

Draper is a tall defender too isnt he? Unless you are talking about Hugh Davies. Draper wears the number 37. He reminds me of the last tall defender that wore number 37, that is Michael Johnson. I dont know if Draper could be as good as Michael Johnson.

I dont think draper will be dropped. played 6 or 7 games so far this season. He isnt great but he isnt terrible or hopeless.

As far as Hugh Davies is concerned, I would actually give him a game from the bench. Let him (Davies) play 50 percent of the game at Centre half back and Draper plays the other 50 percent at Centre half back. Both of them learning off the likes of Alex Pearce and Ryan will be good.

 

[_007_]

Outs
Emmett - We apply plenty of pressure. 29 turnovers for 1 goal 1 behind indicates we need to swap a pressure player for a goal scorer.
Fyfe (sub), Walters and JOM - We are not contenders, play younger players. I don't think we need them in as leaders either.
Voss - Out for Darcy.

Ins
Wagner - Push Chapman or Clark to wing to replace JOM.
Simpson - Develop as a mid/forward, in for Walters.
Sturt - Direct trade of pressure for goals. In for Emmett.
Darcy - Automatic inclusion for Voss.

Ryan Pearce Walker
Clark Draper Wagner
Sharp Young Chapman
Sturt Jackson Frederick
Amiss Treacy Switkowski

Darcy Brayshaw Serong

Johnson Aish Banfield Simpson

Fyfe

 

[332docker]

Emmett had had a good run, not enough goals to warrant he stays in

Try someone else I reckon

 

[One_Wing]

Outs
Emmett - We apply plenty of pressure. 29 turnovers for 1 goal 1 behind indicates we need to swap a pressure player for a goal scorer.
Fyfe (sub), Walters and JOM - We are not contenders, play younger players. I don't think we need them in as leaders either.
Voss - Out for Darcy.

Ins
Wagner - Push Chapman or Clark to wing to replace JOM.
Simpson - Develop as a mid/forward, in for Walters.
Sturt - Direct trade of pressure for goals. In for Emmett.
Darcy - Automatic inclusion for Voss.

Ryan Pearce Walker
Clark Draper Wagner
Sharp Young Chapman
Sturt Jackson Frederick
Amiss Treacy Switkowski

Darcy Brayshaw Serong

Johnson Aish Banfield Simpson

Fyfe

Glad we aren't over reacting to a weird loss under difficult circumstances.

 

[_007_]

Glad we aren't over reacting to a weird loss under difficult circumstances.

Oof you got me man. I am humiliated.

 

[hoss]

We aren’t going anywhere this year. Time to plan for 2025, another year of the rebuild. So deflating

Lol at the melodrama The way I read the ladder, it looks like we're two games off second spot. Must be missing something.

On Pixel 7 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Raz]

OUT : all the BIGFOOTY posters suggestions
IN: Common sense

 

[Freomaniac]

But really looks like no forward is setting the world on fire at WAFL level. Simpson 1 touch for a goal. Delean and Taberner on 2 touches for no score each.

the week before we had a few blokes kicking goals. Sam Sturt kicked 4 goals vs east perth

 

[sumavich]

Lol at the melodrama The way I read the ladder, it looks like we're two games off second spot. Must be missing something.

On Pixel 7 using BigFooty.com mobile app

I'm not missing that we are out of the 8, and have a tough few games coming up.

 

[gungho]

Is it too crazy to start trialling dudes forward?
Chappy?
Walker?
Aish?
Johnno?
Deelan?
Simpson?

Wilson?? Can we redraft him midseason?

 

[Randomizor]

Aren’t you one of the very smart people that looked like a genius last time you called for his delisting.

That didn’t answer my question

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Is it too crazy to start trialling dudes forward?
Chappy?
Walker?
Aish?
Johnno?
Deelan?
Simpson?

Wilson?? Can we redraft him midseason?

Are people watching the same Willo that has clearly enjoyed the more relaxed dietary rules following retirement?

 

[Randomizor]

Is it too crazy to start trialling dudes forward?
Chappy?
Walker?
Aish?
Johnno?
Deelan?
Simpson?

Wilson?? Can we redraft him midseason?

If anything I’d try Sharp forward, then trial some other players on the wing. Sharp at least can get it through the big sticks fairly consistently.

 

[Footskill]

If anything I’d try Sharp forward, then trial some other players on the wing. Sharp at least can get it through the big sticks fairly consistently.

He kicked one out on the full with set shot on Fri. Think off a step or running into goal and letting it fly from 50 is different to when the heat is on and from set shot

 

[Randomizor]

He kicked one out on the full with set shot on Fri. Think off a step or running into goal and letting it fly from 50 is different to when the heat is on and from set shot

I’m more thinking he might be a player waiting at the drop for the crumb, since none of our other players can seem to do that at the moment.

I don’t know. Just feel we can’t keep trying the same thing forward and expect different results.

 

[gungho]

Are people watching the same Willo that has clearly enjoyed the more relaxed dietary rules following retirement?

Mate, Stewy Dew would get a game with our current forward line.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Mate, Stewy Dew would get a game with our current forward line.

Willo would be absolutely abused playing AFL and I’m sure he’d admit it himself

 

[Joao]

Walters into the team and Emmett can be sub.

Maybe he can impact the scoreboard if he comes on late and is fresh when everyone else is tired. Used to work for Banners. I'd have Sturt in but he seems to be the mystery injury of the weekend and has been terrible as sub anyway.

 

[Footskill]

Seems we at a stage, where we packed it in and playing theoreticals. Player X has these attributes so they should be able play in position Y

 

[Sean_09]

Out: JOM, Voss, Emmett
In: Erasmus, Darcy, Warner


Ryan, Pearce, Warner
Aish, Draper, Clark

Darcy, Serong, Young
Sharp, Fyfe, Brayshaw

Fredrick, Treacy, Switkowski
Jackson, Amiss, Walker

Banfield, Erasmus, Johnson, Chapman

Sub: Walters/Simpson


Someone floated the idea of Walker playing forward and honestly I don't hate it. Might give a new option to play around with. JOM's currently holding back 3-4 players in Banfield, Johnson, Brodie & Erasmus - time to move on and re-earn that spot in the WAFL. Warner comes in to cover Walker, we looked electric last season with his rebound.

Darcy's a not brainer if fit. Switkowski on thin ice (might even throw him out for Sturt)

 

[Footskill]

Strange how 3 weeks prior most couldn't wait to get switta back asap and now after one game back they can't wait to get him out

 

[Joao]

There is no point bringing in Ras or Brodie or anyone else to do JoM's role. He's not playing inside mid which is the only position either of those two can play effectively. 100% guaranteed they'd both get hauled over the coals here for playing **** just like JoM does. The role sucks. Brodie would be worse at it and Ras would at best do about the same.

Last thing Ras needs is his confidence destroyed playing out of position and getting dropped. He'll get a look at some point through injury or similar in a role he can actually succeed in.

 

[Sean_09]

Strange how 3 weeks prior most couldn't wait to get switta back asap and now after one game back they can't wait to get him out

It's a lack of goal kicking or unable to spot up a lead inside 50 that hurts