Toast Round 17 = Carlton 59-115 Collingwood

[PonsfordMagpie]

Every Collingwood-Carlton match featuring Pendlebury and/or Sidebottom.

Round 7 2007 (Coll 119-95 Carl) = WON (Pendles)
Round 4 2008 (Carl 111-88 Coll) = LOST (Pendles)
Round 12 2008 (Coll 89-119 Carl) = LOST (Pendles)
Round 8 2009 (Coll 53-104 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 17 2009 (Carl 40-94 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 6 2010 (Carl 102-155 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 18 2010 (Coll 105-57 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 3 2011 (Coll 102-74 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 17 2011 (Carl 79-98 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 3 2012 (Carl 122-62 Coll) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2012 (Coll 62-85 Carl) = LOST (Sidey)
Round 2 2013 (Coll 117-100 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2013 (Carl 77-118 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2014 (Carl 70-104 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2014 (Coll 91-76 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 5 2015 (Carl 45-120 Coll) = WON (Pendles)
Round 19 2015 (Coll 105-87 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2016 (Coll 84-99 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 15 2016 (Carl 45-57 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2017 (Coll 56-79 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 3 2018 (Carl 76-100 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 14 2018 (Coll 79-59 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 7 2019 (Carl 87-106 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 14 2020 (Carl 48-72 Coll) = WON (Pendles)
Round 2 2021 (Carl 85-106 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 18 2021 (Coll 62-91 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 11 2022 (Coll 79-75 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 23 2022 (Carl 74-75 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 10 2023 (Carl 57-85 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 20 2023 (Coll 76-93 Carl) = LOST (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 8 2024 (Carl 79-85 Coll) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 21 2024 (Coll 84-81 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 4 2025 (Coll 63-46 Carl) = WON (Pendles, Sidey)
Round 17 2025 (Carl 59-115 Coll) = WON (Pendles)

It's been a generation of tormenting Carlton

 

[neilk]

Light work.

Watched from home with my 2 day old son. Getting the education started early.

Go Pies!

Congratulations!!!!
Looks like Kirby beat me to Grandfatherhood.

 

[CaptainHowdy87]

I would think Carlton about the worst team in the AFL at the moment

Their bottom 6 players wouldn't get a game at any other club. The most top-heavy side in the comp.

 

[nickyds35]

We are really going to have some selection headaches come finals time.

IN: De Goey, Sidebottom, Hill, Schultz, McCreery, Frampton
OUT: Markov, Sullivan, Parker, Steele, ???

 

[TradeDraft]

Their bottom 6 players wouldn't get a game at any other club. The most top-heavy side in the comp.

Spot on - No Depth

Have a Few Guns but not much after that

 

[Jen2310]

Eh.
Winning is overrated.

 

[cakewalk_1]

Pendlebury equalled KB's record tonight against Cark-Ton as most individual wins against this putrid club, 25 wins.

On another note, I thought their Ex President Luke Sayers flashing his Knob on social media was the most embarrassing thing for the club this year. But these last 3 weeks, possibly 4 next week has easily rivaled it.

 

[Apples]

Was Howe just rested when subbed or did he have an injury?

Rested

 

[PonsfordMagpie]

Just an absolute pleasure watching us destroy Carlton without a feeling of stress or anxiety. It's a tale of two clubs at the moment with the way we're performing and the way they're in free fall. Nights like tonight have to be savoured by the whole supporter base.

There's a lot of moving parts to explain why the 2025 Collingwood side is a great team, but I think the key backbone to our current success is our defence. On average we're conceding 67.8 points per game which is exceptional. Opposition sides are finding it challenging to score against us. Full credit to all our defenders from Moore, Frampton, Maynard, IQ, Howe, Perryman, J Daicos and Houston.

The MMM brigade kicked 8 between them, so all are doing their job very well at the moment. Great to see Jamie Elliott surpass his season high goal tally to now 41 goals, beating his previous season best of 39 goals from 2023.

The atmosphere was unique tonight. Haven't seen Carlton supporters look this subdued in years. They looked beaten before the ball had even been bounced.

Overall, a perfect way to start the weekend, and we've done the double over Carlton for another season which is always considered a "successful season"

 

[NMBB]

Fly's the man

 

[NMBB]

Just an absolute pleasure watching us destroy Carlton without a feeling of stress or anxiety. It's a tale of two clubs at the moment with the way we're performing and the way they're in free fall. Nights like tonight have to be savoured by the whole supporter base.

There's a lot of moving parts to explain why the 2025 Collingwood side is a great team, but I think the key backbone to our current success is our defence. On average we're conceding 67.8 points per game which is exceptional. Opposition sides are finding it challenging to score against us. Full credit to all our defenders from Moore, Frampton, Maynard, IQ, Howe, Perryman, J Daicos and Houston.

The MMM brigade kicked 8 between them, so all are doing their job very well at the moment. Great to see Jamie Elliott surpass his season high goal tally to now 41 goals, beating his previous season best of 39 goals from 2023.

The atmosphere was unique tonight. Haven't seen Carlton supporters look this subdued in years. They looked beaten before the ball had even been bounced.

Overall, a perfect way to start the weekend, and we've done the double over Carlton for another season which is always considered a "successful season"

How do we fit in tonight's outs?

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Dan Houston

9

Dan Houston

Age

28

Ht

186cm

Wt

88kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

18.2

5star

K

11.8

4star

HB

6.4

4star

M

4.9

5star

T

3.0

5star

MG

289.2

4star

D

17.6

4star

K

11.6

4star

HB

6.0

3star

M

3.3

3star

T

3.4

4star

MG

319.9

5star

D

16.6

4star

K

12.4

5star

HB

4.2

4star

M

7.0

5star

T

2.6

4star

MG

279.8

5star

must be thanking Jeebus he didn’t end up at Carlton

 

[PonsfordMagpie]

How do we fit in tonight's outs?

Glad I'm not in MC. The upside is we have great depth.

 

[CaptainHowdy87]

Gary Lyin' and Jason Cunstall were disgraceful on commentary yet again. They cannot hide their contempt for us. Dunno why Whately and Huddo let them talk so much.

I'm paying $25 a month for Kayo, but I think I might just watch the game on the 7+ app next week. I haven't listened to the channel 7 commentary all year, but surely Cornes and Hodge can't be any more biased than them.....right?

 

[Chrispiesssss]

 

[Fruit]

The ladder flatters Carlton. Only 3 spots outside the 8

Only 3 wins above 17th

 

[PonsfordMagpie]

The play of the night.

 

[eddiesmith]

As predicted pre game, it’ll be a comfortable 10 goal win after Carlton fire all their shots in the first qtr.

Just a shame we didn’t finish them off in the last, but you can’t have everything!

 

[BillyElliott]

 

[BillyElliott]

Eh.
Winning is overrated.

Wash your mouth out Jen.

 

[CaptainHowdy87]

Bruzzy set the tone early with some bone crunching tackles.

He was great tonight. He was cherry ripe after that extra 1-2 weeks of recovery.

 

[BillyElliott]

Bruzzy set the tone early with some bone crunching tackles.

He was great tonight. He was cherry ripe after that extra 1-2 weeks of recovery.

How fired up was he from the start? Loved it.

 

[Vicky Park]

I have to say Sullivan was very good tonight
Best game he’s played for us

Love Sullivan. Depth, fringe, but better than that. Love his attitude too. We bring him up from the twos, he does what’s asked of him, and we send him back. Rinse and repeat, depending on injuries and match ups.

It’s tough on him, but the compensation is that he’s at a great club. We are flying at the moment, but where we’re really killing it is with second tier guys like Sullivan.

 

[ottoman]

Great win, but I'm feeling a bit low.
Went and had a look at the Carlton board, you know, to bathe in their tears.
But they seem resigned to their sh...ness.
That's not fun.
They weren't blaming the umpires, they weren't even talking about how fu...ing awesome we are. They were just conceding how s--t they are.
Their supporters have become just as hollow as their players.
I had the popcorn ready and everything.
Feeling a bit let down.
Oh well.

 

[PiCkLeJuiCe]

The atmosphere was unique tonight. Haven't seen Carlton supporters look this subdued in years. They looked beaten before the ball had even been bounced.

There was no atmosphere at all. The 20 min earlier start caught a lot of people off guard so there was almost no noise when the ball was bounced to start the game.

The first quarter was eerily quiet in terms of crowd involvement. My watch normally alerts me of a noisy environment many times during a game. Last night, I was alerted just once.

By the end of Q3 when Crisp slotted his goal, he turned to the crowd which was a sea of empty white seats of allocated Carlton member seating.