VFL Round 3 Carlton v Collingwood 2.05pm Sunday 14th April

[Rebuildmode]

Coaches votes

Finn had more possessions, more clearances, more tackles and more fantasy points than Ned but rated much lower?

 

[Bianconeri]

Finn had more possessions, more clearances, more tackles and more fantasy points than Ned but rated much lower?

Ned was more dynamic with his clearances.

 

[jmac70]

Finn had more possessions, more clearances, more tackles and more fantasy points than Ned but rated much lower?

Fair to say that coaches don’t rate Finn?

 

[Jen2310]

Fair to say that coaches don’t rate Finn?

If they didn't, he wouldn't have gotten any votes. He got the highest votes of any of our AFL listers.
But Longy was great. Took some nice marks, and kicked a goal

 

[jmac70]

If they didn't, he wouldn't have gotten any votes. He got the highest votes of any of our AFL listers.
But Longy was great.

Looks like he needs to be regularly getting the top votes.

 

[manicpie]

 

[No SPIN]

Ned was more dynamic with his clearances.

What’s that mean?

 

[sr36]

Just finished watching the VFL replay and gee I thought Jiath looked great! Seemed to get his light frame in some really good positions in both marking contests and general play. He looked fast and had solid disposal skills.

Wouldn’t be surprised to see him get a chance this year.

Composed with the ball too.

 

[sr36]

Loved McDonald's tenacity and eagerness to defend all day. I'm far from a technical expert, so would love people's thoughts on whether its too late to improve his kicking?

I really enjoyed watching him. I felt like I was watching 80s football. The proper bogan mullet without the designed look, the steroid looking muscles, the balls and all back pocket who just hacked the ball out of defence.

 

[memoryofmchale]

What a load !! Dont know what games you have been watching ? McMahon has put on muscle in the past two years and is a much stronger player. Carnt hold his ground in contests ?? Seriously - I think you have him confused with someone else. This kid turns up every single game and is making a strong impact in Carltons side.

It’s a typical answer from a Collingwood supporter to criticise who we delisted, even if they’re going well.

Eg. Trent Bianco.

He’s had a much better season at Footscray than most of the VFL boys. Yet he’s the biggest spud according to the brain challenged on here.

Trey Ruscoe?

Nah, useless. He’s kicked more goals than AJ this season and is younger and spent a year in defence but must be the WAFL.

 

[stormskye]

What a load !! Dont know what games you have been watching ? McMahon has put on muscle in the past two years and is a much stronger player. Carnt hold his ground in contests ?? Seriously - I think you have him confused with someone else. This kid turns up every single game and is making a strong impact in Carltons side.

You joined Bigfooty, to reply to a post on a vfl game for a team you don’t follow from a month ago? Interesting .

Is that you Liam

 

[The Royal Sampler]

What a load !! Dont know what games you have been watching ? McMahon has put on muscle in the past two years and is a much stronger player. Carnt hold his ground in contests ?? Seriously - I think you have him confused with someone else. This kid turns up every single game and is making a strong impact in Carltons side.

Good job developing your posting muscles, Liam.

 

[Bianconeri]

Get a life !!!!

This is rich

FWIW I was surprised by your delisting and hope you get back on an afl list

 

[sr36]

It’s a typical answer from a Collingwood supporter to criticise who we delisted, even if they’re going well.

Eg. Trent Bianco.

He’s had a much better season at Footscray than most of the VFL boys. Yet he’s the biggest spud according to the brain challenged on here.

Trey Ruscoe?

Nah, useless. He’s kicked more goals than AJ this season and is younger and spent a year in defence but must be the WAFL.

I don't think anyone says Trey and Bianco are useless and not good VFL players. It's just a matter of what roles would they play in our senior team or long term in any AFL team?