Autopsy Round 4 vs Adelaide - what did you learn?

[Superstar swan]

And that Jack stepped off his line (when he didn't)

That was absoluty horrendous. However massive, one sided, passionate fans such as adelaid oval and subi, are a huge advantage. Cannot help but think they make the umps edgy at times and trick the umps into seeing something that didint happen.

We need scg crowds like that

 

[bedford]

What was wrong with Sinclair ? his brother did a job on my local team yesterday

 

[momentbymoment]

Having watched the replay, we were better than I originally thought. We were awesome. If we had more of the rub in the final quarter, we would be chatting right now about how good our season looks. The team looks happy. They are working for each other. The balance is almost right. They will go deep into September.

 

[RUNVS]

Having watched the replay, we were better than I originally thought. We were awesome. If we had more of the rub in the final quarter, we would be chatting right now about how good our season looks. The team looks happy. They are working for each other. The balance is almost right. They will go deep into September.

We had too many passengers. If Rose was in the team instead of Papley, or even Jones instead of McVeigh, we probably would have won.

 

[MickyG]

What was wrong with Sinclair ? his brother did a job on my local team yesterday

foot infection

http://www.sydneyswans.com.au/news/2016-04-16/late-change-sinclair-out-nankervis-in

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Based on the first month we are a top 4 side, we are travelling quite nicely.

 

[grimlock]

Based on the first month we are a top 4 side, we are travelling quite nicely.

We are only in the eight on percentage

 

[MF]

Lloyd goes wondering when the pressure is on imo

He possibly misunderstood what Longmire meant when they asked him to fill Jetta's role.

 

[Punts]

Based on the first month we are a top 4 side, we are travelling quite nicely.

How to you figure that as we only played pies , blues , GWS and crows , out of them crows played finals last year

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

How to you figure that as we only played pies , blues , GWS and crows , out of them crows played finals last year

You cant go based on last year, we are playing a great brand of football if Geelong is touted as a top 4 side then so are we.

 

[Punts]

You cant go based on last year, we are playing a great brand of football if Geelong is touted as a top 4 side then so are we.

Well you can't go off 3 games then

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Sinclair was a huge out goes forwards and kicks goals.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Well you can't go off 3 games then

A month is a reasonable form guideline.

 

[Punts]

A month is a reasonable form guideline.

No not really when there are a few others 3 and 1

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

No not really when there are a few others 3 and 1

I know what you mean but we look bloody good, i didn't say we will finish top 4 but we are playing at that standard imo.

 

[RW]

I'm somewhere in between you guys. It's probably too early to be talking top 4 but there is a definite difference in how we are playing this year compared to last year.

 

[swannyfan]

It's the way we've gone about it and dominated in some games. Unlike last yr, even against lowly sides like Brisbane, we were mundane/almost beaten up there. Some of the ball movement has been dazzling, and the forward pressure, particularly against Pies was just awesome. Something i've not seen in yrs from Swannies. And if Adelaide are touted as having the best forward line in comp and now potential top 4, then we're certainly rigt up there given last night's performance.

Though if we're fair dinkum, we need to really take it up to Eagles and show the early promise, else, could fall right back into the pack or make us look like pretenders.

 

[The King!]

Id prefer Sinclair

But I thought Nankervis performed well

 

[MarkP]

At the time I thought the play on calls against Jack and Cunningham in the last quarter were very strange.

Harrys was there but very technical. You could call 20 like it a game easy. If they do it fine but like that not 15 in the pocket it was simply a significant and random outlier in a pretty rubbish game by the umps.

No opinion on Jacks but it looked very harsh.

 

[Tuco]

If we beat WC we're finals bound. If we don't, we're back in the pack.

 

[The King!]

I just think giving norf a shot at first was a big mistake

 

[Grongey]

Sinclair was a huge out goes forwards and kicks goals.

Yes, and also Talia was missed down back.

 

[kelpie_X]

Umpires kept you in the game early.... & result in the end was fair.

Bullshit! They kept you in the game early when we were smacking you in the midfield. We should have been a further two goals in front at quarter time. Either team could have won that game in the second half. You were lucky you did. Now crawl back to your little hovel whence you came

 

[The King!]

If you want to become a key player here then miss a game.

Talia and Sinclair have become stars

 

[Kennedy Parker]

If you want to become a key player here then miss a game.

Talia and Sinclair have become stars

What about Sam Reid?