Movie Star Wars - Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker - Spoilers and Rumors

[mike123]

It was interesting hearing Ronald D Moore talk about social media and the writing process. If they had a plan for this trilogy, they need to see it through, and not start tinkering to appease some fans. Sure, some people won't like it, but plenty still do; better to have a coherent film that most like than an incoherent one that no one likes.

It's a shame this kind of thinking was thrown out for the last Jedi.

 

[JackOutback]

It's a shame this kind of thinking was thrown out for the last Jedi.

Except it wasn't. The fans played no role in the creative process and RJ wrote a script in communication with the Star Wars story group and its overall plan. That's the point Moore was trying to make; artists create and then put their work out to be judged. Not everyone will like it, but trying to finish the trilogy by committee will make an even worse film.

 

[mike123]

Except it wasn't. The fans played no role in the creative process

They were though, RJ tried to subvert the fans at every turn.

 

[SM]

It was interesting hearing Ronald D Moore talk about social media and the writing process. If they had a plan for this trilogy, they need to see it through, and not start tinkering to appease some fans. Sure, some people won't like it, but plenty still do; better to have a coherent film that most like than an incoherent one that no one likes.

They don't have a plan and were openly proud of it from the start.

 

[Tuco]

Luke not being dead would be stupid.

Yes. If they go down that route the ST is just 'Insert pic of dog driving car and not knowing what he's doing here'

 

[mike123]

Yes. If they go down that route the ST is just 'Insert pic of dog driving car and not knowing what he's doing here'

I think it's well past that point.

 

[Exe Gesis]

I'm getting excited again.....tons of rumors and leaks and info.....

Be prepared for a youtube avalanche....

 

[Exe Gesis]

 

[JackOutback]

Because all the leaks were so accurate ahead of TLJ?

 

[edgie]

I leaked that Luke would go out like a chump

Sent from mTalk

 

[Exe Gesis]

 

[Exe Gesis]

I wonder if the Two Part movie means Episode 8 is being re-made. So you get to watch two movies back to back, released at the same time or a month apart. I wonder is all.

 

[Tuco]

Careful, young padawan. Remember. Excitement leads to expectation. Expectation leads to subverted expectations. Subverted expectations leads to Russian bots. Russian bots leads to suffering.

 

[Exe Gesis]

A new Sith Lord to be revealed in 2019. Yes please.

 

[Exe Gesis]

Careful, young padawan. Remember. Excitement leads to expectation. Expectation leads to subverted expectations. Subverted expectations leads to Russian bots. Russian bots leads to suffering.

It's quite possible Ep IX is going to the best or the grandest star wars movie ever. Grand in scope, grand in the amount of characters all brought together into one film.

 

[edgie]

Except it wasn't. The fans played no role in the creative process and RJ wrote a script in communication with the Star Wars story group and its overall plan. That's the point Moore was trying to make; artists create and then put their work out to be judged. Not everyone will like it, but trying to finish the trilogy by committee will make an even worse film.

Are you thick?

It's well established that RJ threw JJ's overall treatment out the window.

 

[edgie]

It's quite possible Ep IX is going to the best or the grandest star wars movie ever. Grand in scope, grand in the amount of characters all brought together into one film.

You mean apart from Luke, Leia, Han....

You know. The big ones.

 

[edgie]

They were though, RJ tried to subvert the fans at every turn.

But at the same time, still copy Empire + Jedi.

 

[Chris_6678]

Yeah nah those vids are fake.

 

[JackOutback]

Are you thick?

It's well established that RJ threw JJ's overall treatment out the window.

You quote a three-month old post, miss the point completely, and I'm thick?

Regardless of whether he threw out all of JJ's treatment (and it's just speculation how extensive the treatment was and how much was thrown out or retained), everything was done with the approval of Kennedy and the Star Wars story group. So they were happy with the direction and signed off on it. They need to stay the course and not let fans write it for them, because fans are often stupid.

 

[Exe Gesis]

Well apparently they've deicided to not stay the course but retcon alements of ep8

 

[Colonial]

You quote a three-month old post, miss the point completely, and I'm thick?

Regardless of whether he threw out all of JJ's treatment (and it's just speculation how extensive the treatment was and how much was thrown out or retained), everything was done with the approval of Kennedy and the Star Wars story group. So they were happy with the direction and signed off on it. They need to stay the course and not let fans write it for them, because fans are often stupid.

Yep

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

 

[mike123]

But at the same time, still copy Empire + Jedi.

It’s quite marvellous really. It copies the narrative structure of empire besides rushing the start and moving the battle of both after the climax and add scenes of Jedi mixed in there and still manages to subvert expectations.

The problem is the actual subverting is just bad writing designed to trick the audience.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Except it wasn't. The fans played no role in the creative process and RJ wrote a script in communication with the Star Wars story group and its overall plan. That's the point Moore was trying to make; artists create and then put their work out to be judged. Not everyone will like it, but trying to finish the trilogy by committee will make an even worse film.

No he didn't stop making up lies...

Knights of Ren where clearly supposed to appear, Rey's parents were clearly supposed to be of some importance.. and RJ decided to do his own thing, please be an adult now.

 

[edgie]

They started the trilogy by committee. Continued it by committee. Why not finish it by one?

Sent from mTalk