Movie Star Wars - Episode IX - The Rise of Skywalker - Spoilers and Rumors

[edgie]

But all those people worked really hard on the movie so we shouldn't criticise them even when they other people feel worthless.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[edgie]

Having read the comments, she says people shouldn’t be so vicious, which isn’t unreasonable. I don’t accept the argument that you can’t dislike it because people worked hard (the same argument used by Game of Thrones cast members) but neither would I walk up to an actor and say they are s**t at their job because I’m not an arsehole.

Was anyone saying that Daisey did a s**t job toward her?

 

[JackOutback]

Was anyone saying that Daisey did a s**t job toward her?

The anecdote was that at a friend's party, a random person came up to her and said, 'I liked TFA but hated TLJ'. And she thought it was a bit rude. She said she's happy for people to express their views, but there's a difference between disapproval and just being rude, either on social media or in person.

 

[Exe Gesis]

The anecdote was that at a friend's party, a random person came up to her and said, 'I liked TFA but hated TLJ'. And she thought it was a bit rude. She said she's happy for people to express their views, but there's a difference between disapproval and just being rude, either on social media or in person.

how is saying you hated a movie being disrespectful? how else are you supposed to express that?

 

[JackOutback]

how is saying you hated a movie being disrespectful? how else are you supposed to express that?

I think the point is, she didn't have to express it. I don't walk up to random people and tell them I hate their work. She wasn't saying people couldn't express a view, but her work is crititqued by film critics and through box office takings; if I met her, simple manners would preclude me from starting with a list of her work I didn't like.

 

[SM]

The anecdote was that at a friend's party, a random person came up to her and said, 'I liked TFA but hated TLJ'. And she thought it was a bit rude. She said she's happy for people to express their views, but there's a difference between disapproval and just being rude, either on social media or in person.

But saying you hated a movie is hardly being personal?

It's not like the person said "You were amazing in TFA I loved you in that movie, but TLJ was awful and your performance was s**t, you should be ashamed"

 

[glenferry23]

If you met a Hollywood movie in real life, pretty random to tell them you hated their movie (especially if you don't know them). That's a gutsy (and rude) move, most celebrities would probably just expect to get bailed up for a selfie. Not critique.

Having said that, not sure about Daisy's comment about that people worked hard on that film etc.

 

[SM]

If you met a Hollywood movie in real life, pretty random to tell them you hated their movie (especially if you don't know them). That's a gutsy (and rude) move, most celebrities would probably just expect to get bailed up for a selfie. Not critique.

Having said that, not sure about Daisy's comment about that people worked hard on that film etc.

Sounds like it was a friend who said it though? Though it could have just been a random, I dunno.

 

[glenferry23]

Sounds like it was a friend who said it though? Though it could have just been a random, I dunno.

Ah ok. I must admit I don't know the full details - I thought it was from the friend of her actual friend.

 

[edgie]

The anecdote was that at a friend's party, a random person came up to her and said, 'I liked TFA but hated TLJ'. And she thought it was a bit rude. She said she's happy for people to express their views, but there's a difference between disapproval and just being rude, either on social media or in person.

Which is ok, but there is a lot of rudeness and ignorance coming forth from the TLJ camp too.

Did she think RJ is rude when he insults members of the fan base?

 

[edgie]

I think the point is, she didn't have to express it. I don't walk up to random people and tell them I hate their work. She wasn't saying people couldn't express a view, but her work is crititqued by film critics and through box office takings; if I met her, simple manners would preclude me from starting with a list of her work I didn't like.

I'd feel no issue giving Ken Hinkley a thoroughly deserved mouthful.

I think it is ok to let people know how they are doing at jobs that we pay the wages for.

 

[Exe Gesis]

that rudeness on youtube/tweeter from fans is just as bad as the rudeness from disney/LFL/etc toward the fans

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Such a s**t movie - and sounds like RJ really is a campaigner.

I was upset at how they treated Ackbar the kamikaze scene should have been his moment but instead they gave it to a lady with purple hair.

Thanks Kathleen all because you wanted to make a point

 

[glenferry23]

I was upset at how they treated Ackbar the kamikaze scene should have been his moment but instead they gave it to a lady with purple hair.

Thanks Kathleen all because you wanted to make a point

Knowing what we all now know about Carrie Fisher, many things would have been done differently. Replace Holdo with Leia, Luke surviving this movie etc.

 

[JackOutback]

If you met a Hollywood movie in real life, pretty random to tell them you hated their movie (especially if you don't know them). That's a gutsy (and rude) move, most celebrities would probably just expect to get bailed up for a selfie. Not critique.

Having said that, not sure about Daisy's comment about that people worked hard on that film etc.

Exactly my thoughts on both fronts; pretty rude to just randomly tell someone (celebrity or not) you don't like their work. But people work hard on a lot of s**t films, it doesn't get you a pass.

Ah ok. I must admit I don't know the full details - I thought it was from the friend of her actual friend.

You are correct, she described them as a friend of a friend, someone she had barely met.

 

[JackOutback]

GG, don't be so sad.

 

[Exe Gesis]

GG, don't be so sad.

there is no more mirth in me.

 

[glenferry23]

GG is this sad react thing only applicable for Star Wars related threads? Or all across big footy?

 

[Richard Pryor]

But saying you hated a movie is hardly being personal?

It's not like the person said "You were amazing in TFA I loved you in that movie, but TLJ was awful and your performance was s**t, you should be ashamed"

Most creative types are pretty hypersensitive and would take it personally though. Just look at the carry-on after Gleeson made fun of the Logies, if Australian tv personalities feel self important about the Logies imagine how Hollywood folks feel about films.

 

[Exe Gesis]

GG is this sad react thing only applicable for Star Wars related threads? Or all across big footy?

everywhere, bigfooty, and beyond bigfooty

 

[Brick Loosener]

 

[Exe Gesis]

worlds smallest violin still plays for the worlds smallest sad face

 

[SavDog23]

I almost forgot there was a Star Wars movie coming out this year lol.

I've basically lost all interest in the Franchise which is pretty sad. Will go see IX but after that I couldn't give 2 shits what they do with it. They won't be taking my money for Disney+ or any future movies.

 

[SM]

I almost forgot there was a Star Wars movie coming out this year lol.

I've basically lost all interest in the Franchise which is pretty sad. Will go see IX but after that I couldn't give 2 s**ts what they do with it. They won't be taking my money for Disney+ or any future movies.

I think that's the wrong attitude, I think Disney+ could have the most accessible content for people that like traditional SW.. but then again I could be wrong. I'll give it a chance though.

 

[edgie]

Not much interest in Disney+ from me, I think streaming is about to jump the shark, and I have no interest in supporting further dilutions of the concept. It's a topic for another discussion though.