Steven Milne vs Mark Williams

[jazz]

This Poll proves that the majority of Bigfooty posters would make poor coaches.
They would let their personal feelings dictate their decisions and thus choose an inferior player.

Williams has a lot more talent than Milne.

 

[jakson68]

Williams by a street, Milne is very ordinary and certainly nothing to rave about

 

[Hugh Jars]

Firstly he managed 11 goals straight, not 12. Round 22 2005

Milne 11.0
Riewoldt 6.4 (14 marks)
Hamill 2.0

Secondly, I was at that game and whilst it was a magnificant individual performance, most of Milne's goals that night were crumbing goals (crumbing clinic actually).

Now somehow you think that because he had a ridiculous output he must have been the main target??? For this game I'll give you claims on being the second target after Roo, but he has spend most of his time as 4th of 5th option behind Riewoldt, Gherig, Hamil & Kosi (when forward).

I stand by my original statement: Milne would be crucified if he had to be the main target. Qualifier, first option when the team goes inside 50, over a reasonable period of time, not just a game here and there...

How many small forwards are the "main target" for their team in the AFL mate?

 

[Gold Member]

How many small forwards are the "main target" for their team in the AFL mate?

Mark Williams 2004, 2005.

Try reading the whole thread.