Remove this Banner Ad

Swallow vs Swallow

  • Thread starter Thread starter nathan t
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

nathan t

Senior List
Joined
Jan 24, 2011
Posts
161
Reaction score
2
AFL Club
GWS
Andrew Swallow (Present) vs David Swallow (3 Years Time)
Who would you pick if you could have him for just One year?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

David, he is younger and a much much much much much much more rounded player. Did I mention he's better coz he's younger? oh, he's also a more rounded player.

so yeah, David for me.
 
david is already the better player

No, he's not.

The younger Swallow shows far more than Andrew did at the same age and looks to have a bigger skill set.

You can see why David is so highly rated.

All indications point to him going past Andrew down the track, but no, he is clearly not a better player already.
 
David, he is younger and a much much much much much much more rounded player. Did I mention he's better coz he's younger? oh, he's also a more rounded player.

so yeah, David for me.

Theres some clueless people around here. I suggest you watch Andrew's last few games. He has taken the next step this year and is pretty much an elite player now.

David may turn out better but in saying that im sure all North supporters are happy with Andrew.
 
I would take David in three years time over Andrew now.

Barring injury you would probably still be likely to get more years of service.


Now here's the OP:

Swallow vs Swallow
Andrew Swallow (Present) vs David Swallow (3 Years Time)
Who would you pick if you could have him for just One year?

Might pay to know what was asked of you before you answer it.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

david is extremely vanilla, will never be anything special

andrew without a second thought
 
If David is given the benefit of 3 years development... shouldn't Andrew?

Even then David won't have reached his prime, I'd take Andrew now.

But David should end up a superior player over their careers.

Not a shabby footballing family.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom