Here2tellyouwhy
SA GREAT
- Joined
- Sep 3, 2005
- Posts
- 36,741
- Reaction score
- 105,562
- Location
- Adelaide
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Baghdad Bombers
- Thread starter
- #1,526
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Forward line is a little too risky for my liking, adding another premo will take away some of the risk with Wingard and Heeney. Roughead you can't go wrong with at that price and unlike the other two he's proven.Team so far. First crack for the year. Looks solid to me, what do you guys think?
Thanks mate, although i dare say it will change alot by the time the real shit starts.Yeah Zerret and rockliff arent locks yet, ill wait to see how zerret gels with the new look bombers team and rocky will come down to how he looks fitness wise, JPK and Selwood would be very high on the list for their replacements along with SP Cripps, Bont and Sloane,This is one of my favourites i've seen so far. I would opt to go for Jelwood & JPK rather than Zerrett & Rockliff though.
Team hasn't changed much.
Structure will either be 6/0/5 MIDS with 2/1/5 FWDS or 5/0/6 and 3/1/4
Pretty much Sloane/Priddis vs Gunston/GC Lynch
View attachment 336548
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Team hasn't changed much.
Structure will either be 6/0/5 MIDS with 2/1/5 FWDS or 5/0/6 and 3/1/4
Pretty much Sloane/Priddis vs Gunston/GC Lynch
View attachment 336548
My team with no Gawn.
Not interested in Goldy early and no way I'm starting with Witts.
Pretty much Gawn and FWD rookie OUT, Heeney and Sandi IN
View attachment 336578
Witts. deeerrrrIf sandi balls gets injured early (and there's every chance this could happen) you'll be up shit creek. Who do you trade him to?
Sloane to D.Swallow and North's Hibberd to T.Adams
Man that ruck cash spreads all sexy like on my team
View attachment 336579
Well you've got Gawn compared to my Sandi. We both have Ryder but Witts, man I don't know if I can do it.View attachment 336582
Current team I've been rolling with for over 24 hours.
Not sure on McDonald or McGrath at his price, so if scharenberg or Hampton impress in the preseason I'll downgrade mcgrath to one of those two and use the extra money to turn McDonald into rance.

Thanks for the feedback.Well you've got Gawn compared to my Sandi. We both have Ryder but Witts, man I don't know if I can do it.
That midfield tho
I think you have to cull a MID premo and fix up Witts and spend a little on upgrades in your backline.
Having SPP on the bench is over kill IMO. He should score well 80+
Isnt Adams coming off a bad preseason osr something? Thats why I have left him off ATMYeah I like this one more than the last.
Swallow+Adams have the potential to give you 200 points a week
Sloane+defensive rookie I think would be capped at 180 per week,
Thats where I'm at too.Thanks for the feedback.
I figure with witts, in the event of a worse case scenario Where he gets dropped after 2 games and doesn't rise in price, I could still swing Ryder from my forward line into the rucks until I can generate enough cash to upgrade witts into to a premo Ruck , then I'd move Ryder back into the forwards. It's 100,000 grand sitting wasted on the bench for 6-7 weeks, annoying but not the end of the world. But the potential upside is so good that I have to take the risk.
if SPP is as good as you say, I might yet get rid of swallow and use that money on strengthening my backline. But I've got my heart set on starting 6 ultra premo mids. They're too hard to bring in otherwise.
Big fan of the Hanners, Sloane and Jelwood picks. All three are underrated in the SC world. There's at least 330 points per week every week. All consistent, don't miss games, captain options. Tick, tick, tick.My team with no Gawn.
Not interested in Goldy early and no way I'm starting with Witts.
Pretty much Gawn and FWD rookie OUT, Heeney and Sandi IN
View attachment 336578
Thats where I'm at too.
Can get 6 premo mids even with Gawn at R1 but it leaves me with 3 on field rookies forward and back.
Taking Gawn out I get an extra premo for the FWD or BACK line.
Take Gawn out and my 6th MID premo and it's an extra premo FWD and BACK.
Once the best rookies show themselves we will know which of the 3 structures are gonne work best. Still really need balls to go weak in the rucks but it can be done.
Forward line is a little too risky for my liking, adding another premo will take away some of the risk with Wingard and Heeney. Roughead you can't go wrong with at that price and unlike the other two he's proven.
Maybe drop Heppell and get in Dahlhaus/Macrae.
Yeah its more whether or not there's enough solid playing rookies FWD and BACK.The total amount of premos in the team doesn't change, but it depends if you value a mid/fwd/def premium more than a ruck premo. I'd stick with the first option (3 rookies forward and back)
I have been toying with McCrae, do you know who had the better preseason? With Dahls leg issues last year, this year might be the first time I get McCrae I reckong.Cheers mate - Yeah when i think about it they are too similar.
I ended up downgrading Stefan Martin to Ryder, and took Wingard out for Dahlhaus. May put Macrae in instead, like both of them and very similar scorers
Yeah its more whether or not there's enough solid playing rookies FWD and BACK.
No point having 6 premo MIDS with 2 rookies in SPP and Myers who will play every game only to have rookies with iffy job security on your other lines.
If I need to sure up a line before lockout I wont hesitate.