![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/north_melbourne.png)
- Banned
- #2,201
No Evidence of "raking Eye"..which implies spread fingers and movement across the eyes.. Did not happen.
Bad Luck
Did you watch the footage, Stevie Wonder?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Finals Wk 1
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
AFLW 2024 - Round 1 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
No Evidence of "raking Eye"..which implies spread fingers and movement across the eyes.. Did not happen.
Bad Luck
That was his secondary intention in that contest.They both did nothing wrong.
Cotchin won the ball, you saying he wasn’t going for it?
His hands touched the ball the same time the collision happened with Shiel, the ball was in dispute and they both went at it. Shiel didn’t protect himself.That was his secondary intention in that contest.
In the home and away he was getting a week for that, all day every day.
The old finals discount that seems to have disappeared
Two points to make here:Either that or supporters can grow up and accept that adults are able to make decisions that aren't influenced by superficial things such as which football team they support.
How's Jimmy Bartel saying what Toby did was not that bad. Yet threw his former teammate Tom Hawkins under a bus saying that he was known for doing that sort of stuff. Probably still bitter Geelong gave him the 'thanks for coming'. He did say he could have played another 2 seasons.
The Herald Sun was making him out to be the victim. Yet they also made convicted pedophile George Pell to be a victim too.I can't believe that Greene is being made out as the victim in this situation.
I guess those who think he is the victim also sympathise with rapists when the girl wears skimpy clothing![]()
The Herald Sun was making him out to be the victim. Yet they also made convicted pedophile George Pell to be a victim too.
Izzy Folau may have been playing alongside Toby Greene I reckonToby Greene, George Pell and Israel Folau appear in the same sentence for the first time.
If I was you I’d go back through your Year 10 Logical Thinking notes.Two points to make here:
1. Any professional organisation will insist that anybody in a decision-making position is to declare their conflicts of interest and have them step aside for any decision involving that interest. I imagine many people on this forum have had to do that at some point, and it is not on slur on their personal integrity but is a standard approach to upholding the integrity of the process. People have just been pointing out that's a reflection of the AFL's lack of professionalism (or is it something more sinister?) that they would have Messrs Christian, Wakelin and Williams (3 out of 4) with the same conflict of interest presiding over this decision.
2. We are all influenced to some extent by superficial things - it's what advertising and marketing depends on! Just read the posts on this forum to see how biased most people are towards the team they support. And look at how umpiring decisions can favour the home team - that's just a natural reaction to the influence of the crowd. Another example of the AFL's unprofessionalism was to tamper with the home ground allocations for the finals - again which team benefited?
You claimed Neale “didn’t touch his eyes” after the incidentYou are suspending a lot of people if your going to be that literal and also have zero evidence of any actual injury or impact
PiesWho hears the appeal?
That was his secondary intention in that contest.
In the home and away he was getting a week for that, all day every day.
The old finals discount that seems to have disappeared
Greene, Pell and Folau walk into a bar...Toby Greene, George Pell and Israel Folau appear in the same sentence for the first time.
No, but I sympathize with a guy who was caught speeding and received a fine, then got caught speeding again the next week and went to jail.I can't believe that Greene is being made out as the victim in this situation.
I guess those who think he is the victim also sympathise with rapists when the girl wears skimpy clothing![]()
A smiling face is an Earth-like starDid you watch the footage, Stevie Wonder?
No, but I sympathize with a guy who was caught speeding and received a fine, then got caught speeding again the next week and went to jail.
Greene, Pell and Folau walk into a bar...
How's Jimmy Bartel saying what Toby did was not that bad. Yet threw his former teammate Tom Hawkins under a bus saying that he was known for doing that sort of stuff. Probably still bitter Geelong gave him the 'thanks for coming'. He did say he could have played another 2 seasons.
Yeah but having a crack at Tom Hawkins?Jimmys a GWS board member.....
Yeah but having a crack at Tom Hawkins?
Not really. There really aren't very many players sticking their hands into other players faces. Ask Jack RiewoldtYou are suspending a lot of people if your going to be that literal and also have zero evidence of any actual injury or impact
tribunals have been around forever and panel members would have confronted these issues hundreds of times. Why is it suddenly an issue NOW? coz collingwood are perceived to have got an advantage (or even conspired to win an advantage) a crock. you are basically calling the tribunal members cheats.Two points to make here:
1. Any professional organisation will insist that anybody in a decision-making position is to declare their conflicts of interest and have them step aside for any decision involving that interest. I imagine many people on this forum have had to do that at some point, and it is not on slur on their personal integrity but is a standard approach to upholding the integrity of the process. People have just been pointing out that's a reflection of the AFL's lack of professionalism (or is it something more sinister?) that they would have Messrs Christian, Wakelin and Williams (3 out of 4) with the same conflict of interest presiding over this decision.
2. We are all influenced to some extent by superficial things - it's what advertising and marketing depends on! Just read the posts on this forum to see how biased most people are towards the team they support. And look at how umpiring decisions can favour the home team - that's just a natural reaction to the influence of the crowd. Another example of the AFL's unprofessionalism was to tamper with the home ground allocations for the finals - again which team benefited?
Greene, Pell and Folau walk into a bar...
How's Jimmy Bartel saying what Toby did was not that bad. Yet threw his former teammate Tom Hawkins under a bus saying that he was known for doing that sort of stuff. Probably still bitter Geelong gave him the 'thanks for coming'. He did say he could have played another 2 seasons.