Tom Boyd

[Tas]

Completely clueless. Use your hands, mate.

 

[Bokonon]

Nope. Griffen wanting out to GWS definitely came first

All good, I try to be perfect but never manage.it. My memory let me down
I accept I got it wrong, and thank you both . In that case didn't the bulldogs agree to pay Griffen's contract when he came across?

 

[ManOfClay]

Completely clueless. Use your hands, mate.

Gold. How many times will this be posted.

 

[ManOfClay]

All good, I try to be perfect but never manage.it. My memory let me down
I accept I got it wrong, and thank you both . In that case didn't the bulldogs agree to pay Griffen's contract when he came across?

I believe we agreed to pay him for his contracted period with us, as he had a year to run on his Bulldogs contract. Helped us meet the salary cap.

 

[Defacto]

Worst trade this decade. GWS are laughing

 

[Dogsman16]

Worst trade this decade. GWS are laughing

Why would they be laughing? Griffen is cooked and Marchbank will most likely leave. I'd take Boyd before I'd take the pair of them currently.

 

[Tas]

Gold. How many times will this be posted.

It gets funnier every time it's posted, so hopefully many times more.

 

[Colonial]

All good, I try to be perfect but never manage.it. My memory let me down
I accept I got it wrong, and thank you both . In that case didn't the bulldogs agree to pay Griffen's contract when he came across?

The trade was
Boyd
For
Griff
A mill in cap space
Marchbank pick.

We are ahead at the moment. Could easily change.

Depends on how and what Griff March and Boyd all do for the next few years.

 

[Bokonon]

The trade was
Boyd
For
Griff
A mill in cap space
Marchbank pick.

We are ahead at the moment. Could easily change.

Depends on how and what Griff March and Boyd all do for the next few years.

Ok but not sure how. If Boyd didn't want to play for us, my opinion remains we are better off, regardless. Get Marchbank's future matters, but if in the end he wants to go I would again believes he is better off going. Not assuming he will want to go.

I'm happy to accept when I am wrong but you need to accept people will have different views. Isnt that what the forums are about?

 

[Pigdog]

The trade was
Boyd
For
Griff
A mill in cap space
Marchbank pick.

We are ahead at the moment. Could easily change.

Depends on how and what Griff March and Boyd all do for the next few years.

I would think that the next few years doesn't mean as much as the next 10... Especially for us.

 

[threenewpadlocks]

Worst trade this decade. GWS are laughing

Except for the fact one Boyd announced his intentions to come to the Dogs the Saints offered him a similar contract and were scrambling to find the appropriate trade assets to outbid the Dogs.

 

[Theo X]

Except for the fact one Boyd announced his intentions to come to the Dogs the Saints offered him a similar contract and were scrambling to find the appropriate trade assets to outbid the Dogs.

How does that make the trade any better? Saints would be laughing too at dodging a $7 million bullet.

 

[RWnBluey]

Ok but not sure how. If Boyd didn't want to play for us, my opinion remains we are better off, regardless. Get Marchbank's future matters, but if in the end he wants to go I would again believes he is better off going. Not assuming he will want to go.

I'm happy to accept when I am wrong but you need to accept people will have different views. Isnt that what the forums are about?

Ahhhh, the smell of fresh Noob in the morning.

You have a lot to learn about bigfooty my young Padawan.

 

[10571z]

can we just clear something up ... what figure are we assuming Boyd is on per year?

 

[who_let_the_dogs_out]

Completely clueless. Use your hands, mate.

And you can actually see the push from Weitering in that pic. Cheers for posting.

 

[Colonial]

Ok but not sure how. If Boyd didn't want to play for us, my opinion remains we are better off, regardless. Get Marchbank's future matters, but if in the end he wants to go I would again believes he is better off going. Not assuming he will want to go.

I'm happy to accept when I am wrong but you need to accept people will have different views. Isnt that what the forums are about?

I do. Its bf after all.
For instance

Opinion - we are ahead on this trade so far
Fact - How the trade went down

As for marchbank? Want him to stay. Not hapoy if he leaves.

 

[Defacto]

Except for the fact one Boyd announced his intentions to come to the Dogs the Saints offered him a similar contract and were scrambling to find the appropriate trade assets to outbid the Dogs.

errrr no we didnt...

if anything we had the better assets to trade that off-season

 

[Bokonon]

I do. Its bf after all.
For instance

Opinion - we are ahead on this trade so far
Fact - How the trade went down

As for marchbank? Want him to stay. Not hapoy if he leaves.

Absolutely hope he stays, he's a rare talent. Think he will. Agree with all the rest of your post

 

[Adam H]

Except for the fact one Boyd announced his intentions to come to the Dogs the Saints offered him a similar contract and were scrambling to find the appropriate trade assets to outbid the Dogs.

That never happened.

 

[doggies ftw]

can we just clear something up ... what figure are we assuming Boyd is on per year?

It gets higher every time an aints, gws or norf poster brings it up. Will soon be 2mil a year.

6mil over 7 years with a bit of that performance based and a huge chunk of it being frontloaded this year bringing it back to a reasonable level when we will need the cap space more.

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Not sure what you mean, Boyd wanted to go, you offerred overs, we took it. We certainly didn't pinch Griffen he was offerred in the Boyd trade

 

[joop]

Top of my head.

1-10
Stringer, Bontempelli, Wood, Dahlhaus, Liberatore, Murphy, Morris, Hunter, Johannisen, M.Boyd,

11 - 20
Wallis, Macrae, Dickson, Picken, Suckling, Crameri, Stevens, Adams, Campbell, Daniel,

20 - 25
Biggs, Redpath, Roughead, T.Boyd, McLean

Man you guys have a good side.

 

[Pannalstaroz]

I love this thread. So much rehashing of old threads.

 

[Dogsman16]

errrr no we didnt...

if anything we had the better assets to trade that off-season

St Kilda certainly enquired about Boyd. Certainly after he made clear he wanted out of GWS and back to a Victorian club.

Not sure of the contract size though

 

[joop]

Except for the fact one Boyd announced his intentions to come to the Dogs the Saints offered him a similar contract and were scrambling to find the appropriate trade assets to outbid the Dogs.

keep telling yourself this mate, justify your trade. Your salty tears are delicious.