Tom Boyd

[Kermit]

you insinuated (yes a big word) we paid purely 2 first rounders but when you got called out your now arguing semantics (yes another funny word). I reckon you'd cheat at scrabble.

I insinuated nothing of the sort. It may surprise you to know that there is more than 1 Bulldog supporter posting on this thread. Perhaps you should try reading it again

 

[Werewolf]

Dogs give us shit over McCartin. It's called what goes around, comes around.

I thought before the '14 draft that St. Kilda's best bet was to pick McCartin (but they needed Petracca too) and my opinion hasn't changed

 

[Defacto]

Redpath >>>>> McCartin too ... averaging more disposals, marks and over twice as many goals ....

the right comparison would be membrey or bruce given how long redpath has been in the system

 

[Defacto]

I thought before the '14 draft that St. Kilda's best bet was to pick McCartin (but they needed Petracca too) and my opinion hasn't changed

i'd love petracca too and you are right

 

[Mofra]

Lets be serious. Boyd will probably end up being a very good forward. At the moment it looks bad, but a long way to go. Still the money they shelled out will have serious repercussions in getting OOC players from other clubs.

So re-signing all of our required players and signing a FA isn't enough?

The doomsday sayers were convinced the Boyd deal would lead to an exodus. They were wrong.

Thanks for your concern

 

[FallingLiefs]

i just realised this McCartin vs Boyd was a thing.

McCartin was a) the better junior, b) the better AFL style player and c) the better pick

and right now, McCartin >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Boyd.

oh and he's being payed $5mil less.

 

[sataris]

So there won't be the battle of the 2 $1m forwards this weekend?

 

[MJ_Dogs]

Ffs can we please put this argument to bed? I've stated before that I think the saints have a very promising future. Can we all agree that both teams have great lists on their own merit?? We'll be battling each other for flags in the coming years that's for sure

 

[Kermit]

He's already started, who knows if any truth in it. But he's tweeted, dogs have tried a massive cover-up.

You mean Barrett is p*ssed he didn't get to break this "news". Shocker

 

[luckysaint48]

He got in a fight with a team mate, who cares? He's only 20 and Im sure he regrets it. Maybe this will be a moment that marks a positive change for him.

It's still a couple of years away, but he will be a dominant player.

I don't know why people (and potentially other Dog's players) blame him for taking a $1mil/year contract - that's the fault of the Dog's management.

 

[Ozil]

Lol seriously Bulldogs fans are a punch of pussies. Always keen to put the boot in but when its their turn they have a cry

You should probably have that chip on your shoulder attended to.

 

[Flandersss]

i just realised this McCartin vs Boyd was a thing.

McCartin was a) the better junior, b) the better AFL style player and c) the better pick

and right now, McCartin >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Boyd.

oh and he's being payed $5mil less.

Shhhhh.

You'll upset them.

 

[Maddo11]

Good work stealing that off Titus

Has anyone ever seen Mofra and Titus in the same room before?

Illumenarty confurmd

 

[Cudi_420]

Hogan > Boyd.

Close thread.

 

[10571z]

So his at $200k a goal now? Will he play again this season?

 

[Kermit]

wow man, I hope you are trollin'

Not even close. My analogy may suck but the point is the same- Collingwood gave up 2 1st rd picks, they got Treloar and a 2nd rd pick in return. What part of that is incorrect? And for what it's worth, I think it was a good trade

 

[Ozil]

Hogan > Boyd.

Close thread.

Keep it on track bud. Boyd and St Kilda discussion only.

 

[Jezzarayman]

Too bad Zaine doesn't look like a Sherrin

 

[GreyWind]

So his at $200k a goal now? Will he play again this season?

He'll play if his form in the VFL warrants selection after his suspension has ended. But yes he will play AFL again this season.

 

[nobbyiscool]

I wonder how many people in this thread have never chinned a mate... I've personally not made a habit of it, but I've definitely done it!

 

[threenewpadlocks]

I've been one of the most vocal defenders of Boyd but I can't anymore. Dumb dumb dumb dumb and if he has character issues we're locked into 5 more years of a contract.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

i just realised this McCartin vs Boyd was a thing.

McCartin was a) the better junior, b) the better AFL style player and c) the better pick

and right now, McCartin >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Boyd.

oh and he's being payed $5mil less.

That's just bullshit, Boyd was the highest rated young key forward since Tommahawk, he was a better Junior than Paddy.

 

[Jaeger]

Boyd must be extremely up himself. I would be too if I was him though.

No surprise that some of his team mates would resent him. On huge money and is not in their best 18.

Needs to pull his head in and start giving back to the club who have set him up for life.

 

[Gunstall555]

Has anyone ever seen Mofra and Titus in the same room before?

Illumenarty confurmd

Actually on reflection Mofra beat Titus to the punch by 8 minutes...so who is stealing from who?

 

[Jack Bradley]

Bulldogs need to implement a No dickhead policy and quick. Starting to worry about the #culture.