Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

[BRG93]

Would anyone take Charlie Dixon over Carlisle??

Personally think we need a CHF more urgently than a Key Defender at this stage (We Need Both Clearly) so I would go Dixon right now

 

[Yojimbo]

Could definitely co-exist. And roughie/Dixon would be a nice ruck combo.

I have watched a bit of Dixon and to me his durability is too much of
a concern, no doubt he has talent. Now Tom Lynch that is the player
i would like from the Gold Coast.

 

[Dogsman16]

Could definitely co-exist. And roughie/Dixon would be a nice ruck combo.

Also could do what the hawks did and trade a mature KPD defender (like they did with Lake) and start our tilt as soon as next year. I can see merit to chasing Dixon just as much as Carlisle.

 

[razorwick]

50/50

Dixon obviously has some discipline issues

Carlisle WADA issues

Need to see who performs better out of big will or our defensive unit. Who stands up and who doesn't. Roughead/Dixon combination makes for good reading. With Dixon we would have an irresistible forward line!! Think the Boyd/Dixon/Stringer combination could work with all 3 spending time at CHF/Full Forward etc.

Dixon had a glass of red before bed on the weekend"recommended by most doctors" and the previous issue was a family function where he had a beer with his old man over a Sunday roast, hardly a hanging offence. If he's available then move heaven and earth to get him he's what we need. Unfortunately mail is the Lions might have already done the deal. Luenberger linked to the dogs

 

[Roscoe_au]

Could definitely co-exist. And roughie/Dixon would be a nice ruck combo.

Dixon should be GCS main priority to re-sign. Interesting that he hasn't yet.

Does he meet our no dickheads policy?

 

[farstrider]

Dixon had a glass of red before bed on the weekend"recommended by most doctors" and the previous issue was a family function where he had a beer with his old man over a Sunday roast, hardly a hanging offence. If he's available then move heaven and earth to get him he's what we need. Unfortunately mail is the Lions might have already done the deal. Luenberger linked to the dogs

How strong's the mail on Luey?

 

[Roscoe_au]

Dixon had a glass of red before bed on the weekend"recommended by most doctors" and the previous issue was a family function where he had a beer with his old man over a Sunday roast, hardly a hanging offence. If he's available then move heaven and earth to get him he's what we need. Unfortunately mail is the Lions might have already done the deal. Luenberger linked to the dogs

Not the issue that he drank. The issue was that the club had a 3 week ban on alcohol and he drank, twice! Disrespectful to the coach and the leadership group that put it in place. If he had a problem with the ban, he should have spoken with the leadership group.

They are playing shit football and the club has a culture issue

 

[Roscoe_au]

I have watched a bit of Dixon and to me his durability is too much of
a concern, no doubt he has talent. Now Tom Lynch that is the player
i would like from the Gold Coast.

Big Lynch fan...

 

[razorwick]

How strong's the mail on Luey?

Lions need to free up some space to snare both Dixon and Rance. Rockliff Beams Rich and Hanley all on big coin. Lucy and Redden will be on the move.

 

[Roscoe_au]

Dixon had a glass of red before bed on the weekend"recommended by most doctors" and the previous issue was a family function where he had a beer with his old man over a Sunday roast, hardly a hanging offence. If he's available then move heaven and earth to get him he's what we need. Unfortunately mail is the Lions might have already done the deal. Luenberger linked to the dogs

Yikes. Rather persisting with Cordy than going down the Luenberger path. Not sure of his value beyond the centre square bounce?

 

[Dogsman16]

Somebody made comment on how unfair it is that GWS have zone access to the Riverina. Seems as if the media are catching on.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...mes-under-attack/story-fni5ezdm-1227381940673

 

[VitalDread]

Dixon had a glass of red before bed on the weekend"recommended by most doctors" and the previous issue was a family function where he had a beer with his old man over a Sunday roast, hardly a hanging offence. If he's available then move heaven and earth to get him he's what we need. Unfortunately mail is the Lions might have already done the deal. Luenberger linked to the dogs

Zac Smith had a glass of wine with his family a day before a game as well

 

[VitalDread]

Somebody made comment on how unfair it is that GWS have zone access to the Riverina. Seems as if the media are catching on.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...mes-under-attack/story-fni5ezdm-1227381940673

no longer can the AFL protect it's baby

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Would anyone take Charlie Dixon over Carlisle??

No. He is clearly a moron. Or I'll disciplined. Or arrogant. Any of these = no

 

[Zgope1]

I love Dixon. Would love him in a doggies jumper

 

[razorwick]

Yeah but he'll be allowed to play for the next 2 years. Will Jake?

No. He is clearly a moron. Or I'll disciplined. Or arrogant. Any of these = no

 

[VitalDread]

Yeah but he'll be allowed to play for the next 2 years. Will Jake?

Well it will take two years for the wada to have a answer so two flags in that time

 

[TheHoneyBadger]

No. He is clearly a moron. Or I'll disciplined. Or arrogant. Any of these = no

Not to mention fragile.

 

[Yojimbo]

No. He is clearly a moron. Or I'll disciplined. Or arrogant. Any of these = no

Clearly Pann you have not had your nightly medicinal glass of wine as
yet.

 

[razorwick]

Clearly Pann you have not had your nightly medicinal glass of wine as
yet.

I just had mine. Lucky for me I can just scrape my culture problem off the top of the yoghurt

 

[Bemoreboyddog]

Carlisle over Dixon for me. Think if Dixon goes anywhere, he goes up the highway.

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Yeah but he'll be allowed to play for the next 2 years. Will Jake?

i don't understand!?! Obviously Jake will be off everyone's trade table if he looks like, or does get, rubbed out.

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Clearly Pann you have not had your nightly medicinal glass of wine as
yet.

I have 2 kids under 6 big fella, it's a case of wine, heck the glass.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

So lets say we get Carlisle and he plays CHB.
I think Roughy as a ruck is a no brainer.
Is Talia a FB?
Can Fletch play forward? Can he play as a goal square FF in the long target role that Boyd is playing for us now?
Should Boyd, with a preseason under his belt, be moved to CHF?

FB: Talia
CHB: Carlisle
R: Roughead
CHF: Boyd
FF: Roberts

IS that insane?

FF Boyd CHF Stringer

 

[Butane]

Would he even be on $150k?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Probably. Into his second contract. Even some first contract players earn that these days.