List Mgmt. Trade/Draft SuperMegaUltraThread - 2016 edition?

[Pat_Footy]

Lobb seriously overrated here

The only people not rating him haven't seen enough GWS games. He is a Josh Kennedy in the making

 

[wraglesweb]

The only people not rating him haven't seen enough GWS games. He is a Josh Kennedy in the making

No he's not

 

[Biggie]

The only people not rating him haven't seen enough GWS games. He is a Josh Kennedy in the making

Not by any stretch.

Good player for sure but not one you build a side around or indeed sell the farm for.

 

[Godfather32]

Well I wouldn't be trading Lamb unless he comes forward asking for a trade. What's the point? Lecras is on his last legs and Cripps/Hill aren't exactly generational players who can't be displaced.

This board seems to want to trade any player that isn't a regular in their first 2 seasons.

How about turning a player who isn't likely to get a game and wants to go home into something more useful?

 

[Biggie]

How about turning a player who isn't likely to get a game and wants to go home into something more useful?

Won't be long before we hear Lamb wants to return home I would think.

I'd be shocked as all hell if he didn't ask and signs a contract extension.

 

[Godfather32]

Won't be long before we hear Lamb wants to return home I would think.

I'd be shocked as all hell if he didn't ask and signs a contract extension.

Yeh, with Waterman on the horizon he just doesn't look like getting a game (not that he's deserved it).

 

[mezaire]

Just did some youtube watching, any chance Zac Fisher lasts to our 2nd and we only need to bid our 3rd for Waterman?
SPP, Fisher and Waterman then maybe Darcy Cameron with our 4th?

 

[avishka5]

 

[Obeanie1]

Well I wouldn't be trading Lamb unless he comes forward asking for a trade. What's the point? Lecras is on his last legs and Cripps/Hill aren't exactly generational players who can't be displaced.

This board seems to want to trade any player that isn't a regular in their first 2 seasons.

In mentioning Lamb in a trade its under the presumption he has asked for one and wants out. Tall forwards take time to develop.

Thats not my view with Masten. We have several young players gunning for his place in the besr 22.

 

[avishka5]

Club should really push lecca to hang up the boots at the end of the year. Yes his last few weeks have been somewhat good but the game has gone past him and he is gonna get worse as the year goes by. I was impressed by Tunbridge a few weeks back and even Karpany yesterday was impressive as a HFF. SPP(if we draft him) could spend his first few years playing as a forward. I wasn't a fan of hilly but started liking him again but i wouldn't mind us actually replacing him next season if he cannot find his 2015 form again. Tunbridge or SPP play his role and say karpany play leccas role.



Liam Ryan and Dacry Cameron ate or through the rookie draft is must IMO

 

[WCE_phil]

Club should really push lecca to hang up the boots at the end of the year. Yes his last few weeks have been somewhat good but the game has gone past him and he is gonna get worse as the year goes by. I was impressed by Tunbridge a few weeks back and even Karpany yesterday was impressive as a HFF. SPP(if we draft him) could spend his first few years playing as a forward. I wasn't a fan of hilly but started liking him again but i wouldn't mind us actually replacing him next season if he cannot find his 2015 form again. Tunbridge or SPP play his role and say karpany play leccas role.



Liam Ryan and Dacry Cameron ate or through the rookie draft is must IMO

We still need to have some players to get rid of next year.

 

[boondy]

The only people not rating him haven't seen enough GWS games. He is a Josh Kennedy in the making

He choked in front of almost a certain goal and kicked a point against us in the dying minutes then failed to outmark Chris Masten to double choke and enable us to win . He played 2 or 3 reasonable games . Kennedy played about 21

 

[Godfather32]

We still need to have some players to get rid of next year.

Butler, McGinnity, Priddis will probably go next year for a start

 

[Pat_Footy]

He choked in front of almost a certain goal and kicked a point against us in the dying minutes then failed to outmark Chris Masten to double choke and enable us to win . He played 2 or 3 reasonable games . Kennedy played about 21

He must be dreadful then. De-list pile according to you?

 

[boondy]

He must be dreadful then. De-list pile according to you?

You were the one jumping a shark (Mrs Lobb) saying he is Josh Kennedy in the making . If you delist everyone not capable of rising to Kennedy's level there would be no one playing .
If he gets delisted he is worth picking up

 

[Pat_Footy]

You were the one jumping a shark (Mrs Lobb) saying he is Josh Kennedy in the making . If you delist everyone not capable of rising to Kennedy's level there would be no one playing

yeah I did say he was a Josh Kennedy in the making. That doesn't mean he should be winning colemans at the moment. You said he blew it for GWS? Well, he brought them single-handedly back into the game. Regardless, he has been playing a significant role for the past 2 seasons. Almost their best player during their rise.

 

[Keys]

Club should really push lecca to hang up the boots at the end of the year.

No. He's past his best but he's still contributing

Simpson does need to be prepared to send him back to the WAFL if his form dips like it did during the midway part of this season

 

[garlic munchers]

Brisbane would love EMac - just lost Merritt and need some scperience with the youth.

Given they just finished 2nd last, they wouldn't in a million years give up a 2nd round draft pick for late 20's KPD 1 year after a knee reco and whom can't make the 5th best sides 22.

 

[garlic munchers]

Not by any stretch.

Good player for sure but not one you build a side around or indeed sell the farm for.

What Carlton said about Kennedy.

 

[avishka5]

We still need to have some players to get rid of next year.

2016
true

well this year

Delist:
bennell
mcginnity
collegde
lucas

retire:
ellis
cavka

trade
lamb

so that leaves us 4-5 spot free on the main list this year

Then next year guys like waterman, karpany, tunbridge all would be on their last chances

somone lucky hutchings over even hill could be a sneaky chance to be cut


Lecras, priddis and butler all likley candidates to retire.

 

[Keys]

Butler, McGinnity, Priddis will probably go next year for a start

Surely mcginnity goes this year

Surely

 

[Play by Numbers]

The only people not rating him haven't seen enough GWS games. He is a Josh Kennedy in the making

You need to take it easy.

 

[Pat_Footy]

2016
true

well this year

Delist:
bennell
mcginnity
collegde
lucas

retire:
ellis
cavka

trade
lamb

so that leaves us 4-5 spot free on the main list this year

Then next year guys like waterman, karpany, tunbridge all would be on their last chances

somone lucky hutchings over even hill could be a sneaky chance to be cut


Lecras, priddis and butler all likley candidates to retire.

Tunbridge and Karpany were on their last chances this year. They really haven't shown enough to warrant being kept.

 

[Godfather32]

Surely mcginnity goes this year

Surely

I wouldn't bet my house on it

 

[Pat_Footy]

You need to take it easy.

This board wets their pants over a Tunbridge tackle, yet can't identify obvious talent when they see it. I think people are too tunnel visioned on midfielders.