News Trade Week thread

[DANGERZONE123]

Tom Lynch for pick 24?

 

[Daz]

We also need to consider

North were keen on Gunna however they have now moved to Gram so maybe the alternatives also went cold

On the surface yes we would all like a little more however I will reserve my trade judgement until more information becomes available and until we can assess what Adelaide does with those picks

We have actually denied any interest in Gram.

I would have loved Gunston at North.

 

[Crowfoot]

Bugger this.

I'm going out to get a carton of cigarettes and take up smoking.

Be back next Monday at 2pm.

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Tom Lynch for pick 24?

Absolutely not

 

[DANGERZONE123]

Absolutely not

I have no idea what Lynch is worth TBH, just figured we'd use one of those picks to get him. Can you give me an value?

 

[Mad Fan of AFL]

rather develop Mckernan than Lynch. Basically shown the same.

 

[PyroCrow]

Scott Lycett for pick 24?

Fixed.

 

[Hank93]

David Noble on the Crows website has stated this is part of the end result we are trying to acheive by Next Monday. Is that when the Mini Draft is.

I hope it is.

 

[spexau]

Next Monday is just when Trade Week ends. So he's saying it's part of what we want to achieve by the end of trade week. Mini-draft picks can only be traded up until the end of tomorrow I believe so we should see that part of it happen by then you'd hope. Other wise we're screwed.

 

[WALL-e]

Nathan Thompson has NFI.

Pick 25 (not a first rounder....).....Phil Smith....get off you goober.

 

[DANGERZONE123]

Perhaps instead of a mini draft pick we're getting a top 10 GWS pick?

 

[hendo8888]

People have been somewhat clouded by people posting the megatrade in 1 easy to read gain-loss list rather than seperate pieces coming together to form the big picture.
I'd be surprised if this trade isn't just a 'piece of the jigsaw puzzle' as they have put it.
Expect JOM to go to Freo at some stage today. He will then come to us for Pick 24 and whatever else it will take (probably pick 10).
We will then send him back to GWS for Pick 2 (Crouch/Kennedy) and probably one of their first rounders.

End result is we trade Gunston and a first round downgrade and get Crouch and the third and fourth round upgrades.
Huge, Huge win.

All the experts have us getting Crouch. Unless we seriously are going to trade 24 and Davis for it, the only explanation is that this is just part of the bigger picture.

 

[DANGERZONE123]

People have been somewhat clouded by people posting the megatrade in 1 easy to read gain-loss list rather than seperate pieces coming together to form the big picture.
I'd be surprised if this trade isn't just a 'piece of the jigsaw puzzle' as they have put it.
Expect JOM to go to Freo at some stage today. He will then come to us for Pick 24 and whatever else it will take (probably pick 10).
We will then send him back to GWS for Pick 2 (Crouch/Kennedy) and probably one of their first rounders.

End result is we trade Gunston and a first round downgrade and get Crouch and the third and fourth round upgrades.
Huge, Huge win.

All the experts have us getting Crouch. Unless we seriously are going to trade 24 and Davis for it, the only explanation is that this is just part of the bigger picture.

Sounds about right. Freo give like 1st and 2nd for first mini draft. mini draft to adelaide for 10. mini draft to GWS for 16 and mini draft 2

 

[PrideOf]

This.

It's like saying 'oh no, we gave away Sean Wellman for pick 45' when it was part of the jigsaw that brought the great D Jarman home (and the 97 and 98 premierships).

 

[Cap]

People have been somewhat clouded by people posting the megatrade in 1 easy to read gain-loss list rather than seperate pieces coming together to form the big picture.
I'd be surprised if this trade isn't just a 'piece of the jigsaw puzzle' as they have put it.
Expect JOM to go to Freo at some stage today. He will then come to us for Pick 24 and whatever else it will take (probably pick 10).
We will then send him back to GWS for Pick 2 (Crouch/Kennedy) and probably one of their first rounders.

End result is we trade Gunston and a first round downgrade and get Crouch and the third and fourth round upgrades.
Huge, Huge win.

All the experts have us getting Crouch. Unless we seriously are going to trade 24 and Davis for it, the only explanation is that this is just part of the bigger picture.

I will believe it - when I see it.

 

[Cap]

This.

It's like saying 'oh no, we gave away Sean Wellman for pick 45' when it was part of the jigsaw that brought the great D Jarman home (and the 97 and 98 premierships).

I recall that happened at the same time

 

[saintsrfreak]

People have been somewhat clouded by people posting the megatrade in 1 easy to read gain-loss list rather than seperate pieces coming together to form the big picture.
I'd be surprised if this trade isn't just a 'piece of the jigsaw puzzle' as they have put it.
Expect JOM to go to Freo at some stage today. He will then come to us for Pick 24 and whatever else it will take (probably pick 10).
We will then send him back to GWS for Pick 2 (Crouch/Kennedy) and probably one of their first rounders.

End result is we trade Gunston and a first round downgrade and get Crouch and the third and fourth round upgrades.
Huge, Huge win.

All the experts have us getting Crouch. Unless we seriously are going to trade 24 and Davis for it, the only explanation is that this is just part of the bigger picture.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...ra-denied-by-afl/story-fn69a32t-1226164300573

But the league ruled GWS could not retain a player the regulations dictated it must trade away.

 

[Cap]

welcome to 12 hours ago

AFL have already come out clarified themselves and GWS can in fact do it - if it is done properly.

 

[Mr Grieves]

Noble not giving anything away about the MD on TWR

 

[Wood_Duck]

Noble just confirmed we are looking at the 17 year old draft, given that we have some currency with the Davis pick.

I think we are on the right track, although Noble didnt give much away.

 

[Cap]

Noble not giving anything away about the MD on TWR

Noble just confirmed we are looking at the 17 year old draft.

 

[hendo8888]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...ra-denied-by-afl/story-fn69a32t-1226164300573

This question has been answered in about 25 threads to about 70 different people over the last day.
The trade put to the AFL last night wasn't accepted.
The whole concept of the trade, however, is still very possible.

 

[Mr Grieves]

Haha! My bad, he didn't give anything away when asked about Crouch

 

[afc1991]

He said he wouldnt give our plans away, but MD is on our radar. Biggest thing he gave away was mentioning the compo pick.

Fair to say the compo pick + something to get in the MD- if we do it.

 

[Wood_Duck]

Both statements are true. He said there is defiantely some interest but offered no information.