Votes (not that we deserve them) v West Coast

[Ben the Gooner]

3. Dyson - **** you all
2. Laycock - **** you all
1. Lloyd - for the lack of anyone better.

An abysmal effort. Our best two were the two whipping boys - have patience.

 

[bomberstomake8]

3. Watson
2. Dempsey (provided good run although he did screw up a few times)
1. dyson


i would hardly call laycock the second best man on the ground.. although he did a bit in the last quarter he had a lot of opportunities earlier where he could outmark his opponent, yet he was out bodied by a rookie in his first year (wilkes) and was thrown out the way by braun.... for someone of his size that just shouldnt happen.. anyways laycock was okay today, not deserving of a vote though

 

[BomberAce7]

3 - Lovett
2 - Watson
1 - Dempsey

Back to old ways - Stanton!

 

[Rack Watts]

1. Laycock (what a game, 3 goals and Layed some tackles too!)
2. Slattery (Best 2nd half he has played ever)
3. Dyson (Played the whole game out really well)

Bad luck to: Ryder, Dempsey and Fletcher.

The three guys that Essendon supporters were giving crap to. I will be the first to admit that I didn't think Dyson had the heart to do it. He played a great game today!

Stanton had a real dud of a game, NLM was horrible until the last 1/4.

 

[Hirdman]

3. Watson
2. Lovett
1. Lloyd

although all were average in the first half, I thought Dempsey's game was a good one and look forward to him being a fit and regular part of 09.

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

3. Lovett
2. Watson
1. Dempsey

 

[danzan22]

3. Ryder - Easily our best in defence today imo, set up some play ajnd took some very nice marks
2. Lovett - Well what a second half, got us back into the game
1. Laycock - Did ok (better than hille) in the ruck and was a good option up foward. Also laid a nice tackle which should of been rewarded.

 

[Johnny619]

Laycock - I can't believe I said it. Hope this is the turning point of his career!
Ryder
Lovett

 

[Barts]

Lovett my bog. Was the catalyst for our 2nd half. Watson played well as did Dempsey. Paddy was good as was Lloyd and Laycock did some good things in the last.

3. Lovett
2. Watson
1. Ryder

 

[Dr Moose]

Can't honestly think of anyone who should be proud of their effort today
3) Watson - didn't cause too many turnovers
2) McPhee - Got lots of the ball, even if he wasn't great with it
1) Laycock - not as much of a liability as usual efforts

 

[gdaytiger2001]

3. Watson - Rapidly becoming our most important player
2. Lovett - Carried the ball well and delivered into our forward line when no one else could.
1. Dempsey - Great first game back.

 

[loopy_cam]

Dempsey for rising star nomination.

 

[The_Young_Gun]

3: Lovett
2: Dempsey
1: Lloyd

&: Laycock, Dyson, Monfries, Jetta, Ryder.

 

[sen entertainment bloke]

3/Lovett

2/ Dyson

1/ Monfries

 

[hugorune]

3. Watson.
2. Laycock.
1. Ryder.
Unlucky: Dempsey.

Actually, scrap that. Give 1 to Dempsey as well. -1 to the umpires to balance it out.

 

[DonMania#5]

3. Lovett
2. Ryder
1. Laycock

 

[Burzum]

3. Jobe Watson
2. Andrew Lovett
1. Courtenay Dempsey

 

[efcboy]

3. Jobe Watson
2. Andrew Lovett
1. Courtenay Dempsey

ditto for me.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

3- Watson
2- Dempsey
1- Gus

-3= Stanton..jeez how many times did he kick it straight to a WC player
-2= Rama, fair dinkum why are we playing hik. Should have been dumped a month ago.
-1=Knights. Poor coaching all round. I know Hooker may not be great but at least he can play CHF. No CHF=no structure!

 

[The Dustbin]

Can't honestly think of anyone who should be proud of their effort today
3) Watson - didn't cause too many turnovers
2) McPhee - Got lots of the ball, even if he wasn't great with it
1) Laycock - not as much of a liability as usual efforts

McPhee had it 9 times.

 

[The Dustbin]

3. Lovett
2. Slattery
1. Dempsey

 

[lemon chicken]

3. Lovett
2. Slattery
1. Dempsey

Same for me. I fail to see how Dyson can get votes when he holds on the football and stuffs around like he has some kind of reasonable skill level. Just kick it!

 

[The Dustbin]

Same for me. I fail to see how Dyson can get votes when he holds on the football and stuffs around like he has some kind of reasonable skill level. Just kick it!

That piece of play by Dyson was terrible.

 

[Big Blow Hard]

3. Lovett
2. Ryder
1. Slattery

Don't know how anyone could consider Laycock amongst our best. A couple of tackles and goals does not make a good game. He was beaten by his opponent Wilkes today. He was not alone in that reagard though.

 

[Bomber32]

3. Watson
2. Lovett
1. Ryder