Votes v Adelaide QF

[ImperialPurple]

5. Johnno
4. Blackie
3. Macca
2. Bell
1. Cook


Yes I am disappointed. Devastated? No. Only if we get smacked next week. Which I don't think we will.

Edit: forgot macca (how could I.... ) - he relegated parker to the bench.

MCarr did okay on Goodwin, but he was still influential, while I thought MCarr had too many turnovers.

 

[bushie]

5.) Johnno....sure he was the spare man but he did it well.
4.) M.Carr...kept Goodwin quiet
3.) Blackie...tried hard all day
2.) Farmer...not a lot of it but when he had it he made them pay.
1.) Hayden..Not sure where he played but he never gave up.

 

[Scham]

5. Jonno
4. Macca
3. Peake
2. M. Carr
1. McPharlane

Black next but gave away too many silly frees and turned the ball over far too many times to fit in the top 5 for mien. Hayden, Bell and Cookie were ok too - raffle the rest.

 

[YelloMit]

5: Johnson
4: Black
3: Bell
2: Sandilands
1: McManus

 

[dugrene]

5 johnno
4 Macca
3 Peake
4 Elvis
1 Bell

As for Mcarr ? imo, IP's words "MCarr did okay on Goodwin, but he was still influential, while I thought MCarr had too many turnovers I figure is code for " you effed up tooo often Matty" As a result he isnt in my votes.

 

[GoSarge]

Dont know if my views are welcome but Ill have a crack.

Was at the game today and this is how I saw it :

5) Black 32 possies, 12 marks, lots of running in to space. I thought clearly was your best player.
4) Johnson 26 touches 10 marks, Was excellent in defence.
3) Sandliands 23 ho and 9 touches. Was a bit quieter than usual, but still a very good game and still had a good influence.
2) Matthew Carr 13 touches, a good effort in keeping Goodwin quiet, I'd say he did his job.
1) Peter Bell. 24 touches. A hard working game.

 

[dugrene]

Dont know if my views are welcome but Ill have a crack.

Was at the game today and this is how I saw it :

5) Black 32 possies, 12 marks, lots of running in to space. I thought clearly was your best player.
4) Johnson 26 touches 10 marks, Was excellent in defence.
3) Sandliands 23 ho and 9 touches. Was a bit quieter than usual, but still a very good game and still had a good influence.
2) Matthew Carr 13 touches, a good effort in keeping Goodwin quiet, I'd say he did his job.
1) Peter Bell. 24 touches. A hard working game.

Err during the game we saw a banner that said 'go Sarge'. Is 'go Sarge' something to do with the Crows that I havnt sussed yet ?

 

[AJ_No.4]

Err during the game we saw a banner that said 'go Sarge'. Is 'go Sarge' something to do with the Crows that I havnt sussed yet ?

Sarge is Ian Perrie's nickname

 

[Freeeoo]

5. Black
4. Johnno
3. Bell
2. Macca
1. Dodd

 

[Lach72]

5. Johnno
4. Blackie
3. Macca
2. Bell
1. Cook


Yes I am disappointed. Devastated? No. Only if we get smacked next week. Which I don't think we will.

Edit: forgot macca (how could I.... ) - he relegated parker to the bench.

MCarr did okay on Goodwin, but he was still influential, while I thought MCarr had too many turnovers.

Snap

 

[Freo Big Fella]

5. Johnno
4. Blackie
3. Bell
2. Sandi
1. Cook

 

[blockerhall]

5. Black
4. Johnno
3. McManus
2. Bell
1. Parker

 

[Plugga]

5 Johnno
4 Black
3 McManus
2 M Carr
1 Bell


Mundy, Dodd, Schammer had SHOCKERS